
Vacation rentals in New Castle
Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb
Quick stats about vacation rentals in New Castle

Total vacation rentals
Explore 10 vacation rentals in New Castle

Nightly prices starting at
New Castle vacation rentals start at €35 per night before taxes and fees

Verified guest reviews
Over 1,120 verified reviews to help you choose

Rentals with dedicated workspaces
10 properties have a dedicated workspace

Wi-Fi availability
10 of New Castle vacation rentals include wi-fi access

Popular amenities for guests
Guests love Kitchen, Wifi, and Pool across New Castle rentals

4.9 Average rating
New Castle stays are highly rated by guests—averaging 4.9 out of 5!
Top-rated vacation rentals in New Castle
Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

Hot Tub Arcadia - Relax and Play
Designed with couples in mind, where relaxation and entertainment await! You'll enjoy the serenity of a small-town country getaway. Features: •Hot Tub •Arcade •Popcorn Movie Bar •Board Games •Claw Tub •King bed •Workspace with vanity. •Twin bunk bed •Murphy Bed for 5th guest •Fully equipped kitchen •Outdoor patio with seating for two and completely private hot tub. •Wi-Fi and smart TV •Washer/dryer Ideal for: • Couples seeking a romantic getaway • Small families looking for a relaxing vacation

Quiet setting, perfect for family & professionals.
Instantly feel wrapped in warmth of this charming sanctuary. This loving home is your cozy hideaway. This charming abode is well-appointed with washer/dryer, dishwasher, coffee bar, and many extras. Relax outside as you listen to birds and smell the flowers in this park-like setting. Enjoy the large deck with a classic Midwestern view of lush farmland. Plenty of parking, ideal for horse trailers or boats. This home is ideal for relaxing getaways, lodging for family visits, or long-term stays.

Rustic Lake house with HOT TUB and Pool Table
Come relax in your cozy 1978 Lake House! Conveniently located between Muncie and Hartford City-16 min. from Taylor University, 24 min. from Ball State, 10 seconds from the dock! Enjoy the outdoors-Take out the kayaks, go fishing, enjoy the lake, soak up the sights in the hot tub, then end your night with a campfire! Inside-Shoot some pool on the 1800's pool table, pull out a board game with the family, or just relax in the four-season sunroom while watching the sunset. Enjoy Lake Time!

Maxwell-Commons #105, New Castle IN, 2bd2bth dwntn
#105 Maxwell-Commons: downtown LOFT for business, family, pleasure - HAVEN for peace. Wild party? PLEASE go elsewhere. Nea: HC Saddle Club; Go-Karts; NC High School; Hall of Fame. Indianapolis 50min; Richmond 30min; Muncie, Anderson 20min. Bring toiletries. Coffee available. THERE ARE STAIRS. 3 or 100s of guest voiced complaint re overnight trains. I am powerless over the midwest rail-schedules. It is fair to let would-be guests know. There are 2 assigned outdoor parking-spaces.

A peaceful night under the stars in the country.
Get away from it all when you stay under the stars. Join us for a peaceful country stay, close enough to drive to nearby shopping and dining, and far enough to hear the crickets and see the stars. Your cozy place will include a kitchenette, coffee pot, microwave & TV. The dining area inside or on the attached deck, full size bed & full bath with shower. Only 3.9 miles from Interstate 70. Should you choose to, use 100-foot zipline to exercise your pet or a path to walk around our field.

New Hagerstown Apartment-Self Check-in. Sleeps 4+
Have fun with the whole family at this stylish place. Whether you are looking to visit family in the area or just wanting a small-town vibe to escape to, my welcoming apartment has everything you need. The unit comes with AC, Wi-Fi, Netflix, a private bathroom, and a fully stocked kitchen. Located in the heart of Hagerstown, the unit is blocks away from the local shops and restaurants on Main Street. My adorable apartment offers a deck, grill, pull-out couch, Keurig, and more!

Monét Water Lily Suite • Breakfast • Antique Alley
Experience our restored historic 1888 bank in your private Water Lily Suite, inspired by Monet's series. This boutique retreat blends art, music, and mid-century modern right on Main Street, in the heart of Indiana's Antique Alley. Sleeping up to 5 guests, the spacious suite offers a full kitchen, living room, dining room, and bath. Wake to complimentary artisan pastries, house-made granola, and Nespresso, fresh flowers in the summer months, and a vinyl record collection.

THE STARR LOFT Earlham, IUE, Reid, Relaxing Swing!
Second floor of an 1865 Tin shop, industrial building. High, open beam ceilings & exposed brick walls. Bathroom features a soaker tub plus a lux walk in shower. The kitchen features quartz counters, a large farmhouse sink, really nice appliances and thoughtful touches everywhere. The wifi is excellent. Have issues with stairs? This is not a good choice for you. If you're up for stairs and want a unique slice of history in a hip package then you will not be disappointed.

Summit Lake Guest House
A quaint & unique space; the Summit Guest House provides a farmhouse setting, perfect for kids, & anyone looking to slow down and enjoy the peaceful country life. Excellent views of local farmland w/ ample wild life. Minutes away from Summit Lake & Wilbur Wright birthplace. Host lives on premises and is available to help with any needs. The space is fully fenced and has a small gated backyard, perfect for little ones! We look forward to hosting you, ~Kristen & Tim

The Cabin
The Cabin is located on 30 acres and boasts stunning backyard prairie views and endless wildlife. It features a 1 bedroom, memory foam sleeper sectional, queen air mattress, full bath, laundry, kitchen, living room and walk in basement. Outside you will enjoy a private fire pit, 2 car detached garage, private back porch, tree swings, walking path, food plots for wildlife and wildflowers. Come and relax and enjoy! We look forward to welcoming you at your next stay.

The Camp in Oxford (OH)
The Camp in Oxford includes3 private acres nestled right alongside the Indian Creek River and surrounded by sprawling farmland. Located just 5 miles from Miami University, 13 miles from Brookville Lake and short drives to Hamilton, Cincinnati or Dayton, this beautiful 2 bedroom modern cottage is waiting for your next visit. Fully furnished and equipped with every amenity you'd expect from a 5 star property.

A historic downtown stay at The Patrick Henry
At the heart of historic downtown New Castle, this 1860s building is host now to retail, a photo studio, and your peaceful home away from home. Two years of restoration have resulted in a building with history, character, and a hub for all the city and county has to offer.
Popular amenities for New Castle vacation rentals
Other great vacation rentals in New Castle

Historical country estate guest house on 10 acres

New Castle Retreat | Beautiful Duplex • Near Parks

Wilderness Creek Farm Tiny House

4 Bedroom Home - Hot Tub - Fire Pit

Barndominium country retreat

Downtown Muncie | Luxe Loft, Spa Bath, 1 Bed, BSU

Muncie Green Oasis

Modern 2 bedroom 9 min to BSU
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best places to stay in New Castle?
New Castle has guest houses and vacation rentals throughout its neighborhoods, as well as options in quieter, residential areas for a more relaxed atmosphere. Consider stays near parks or the historic downtown for convenient access to cafes and local attractions.
What are the best things to do in New Castle with kids?
Families can explore interactive exhibits at the Indiana Basketball Hall of Fame, play at local parks, or enjoy community recreation centers. During warmer months, outdoor splash pads and seasonal activities are frequently suggested.
What are some of the best things to do in New Castle?
Explore the Indiana Basketball Hall of Fame, discover local history at community museums, or stroll around the courthouse square. Parks and seasonal community events also draw visitors throughout the year.
How is the weather in New Castle?
New Castle has cold winters with temperatures ranging from 21–36°F (-6–2°C), and warm, humid summers reaching up to 85°F (30°C). Spring and fall bring milder weather and moderate rainfall, so layers and rain gear are frequently recommended.
When is the best time to visit New Castle?
Late spring to early fall is often recommended for comfortable temperatures and a variety of outdoor activities. Cooler months have a quieter atmosphere and seasonal events, making them appealing for those seeking local traditions.
What are the best places to visit in New Castle?
Visitors frequently explore the Indiana Basketball Hall of Fame, local museums, and the historic downtown area, which has cafes, shops, and the courthouse square. City parks and community art spaces also attract those looking to experience the town’s character.
What are some hiking trails in New Castle?
New Castle has greenways and walking paths in local and regional parks, where you can explore wooded areas and enjoy wildlife viewing. Community nature preserves nearby often provide loop trails suitable for casual hikers and families.
What are some family activities we can do in New Castle?
Families often visit parks and local playgrounds, participate in events at recreation centers, or tour interactive exhibits at the Indiana Basketball Hall of Fame. Seasonal fairs and outdoor movie nights add to the local experience.
What are some of the best day trip ideas from New Castle?
You can explore nature preserves, visit neighboring small towns with historic districts, or discover regional museums and art centers around New Castle. Many travelers enjoy venturing to local lakes or participating in seasonal festivals in nearby communities.
Are there any pet friendly accommodations available in New Castle?
Many accommodations in New Castle welcome pets, especially in residential neighborhoods and near local parks. You can find stays with easy access to walking areas and green spaces for your companion.
What are some local tips for visiting New Castle?
Locals often suggest trying regional flavors at community diners and exploring art displays in public spaces. Bringing a light jacket year-round is recommended, as weather can shift between sunny and rainy.
What is New Castle known for?
New Castle is frequently recognized for its high school basketball heritage and the Indiana Basketball Hall of Fame. The historic courthouse square and community festivals highlight its Midwestern traditions.
What are the best hidden gems to explore in New Castle?
Less-traveled parks, local art murals, and small museums often provide unique perspectives on New Castle’s community. Seeking out neighborhood cafes and seasonal crafts markets can reveal more about the area’s local culture.
What are the best foods to try in New Castle?
Many visitors enjoy regional comfort dishes, including tenderloin sandwiches, homemade pies, and classic American breakfasts at family-owned diners. Locally rooted bakeries and seasonal produce stands often round out the culinary experience.
What should I bring for a trip to New Castle?
Packing layers, a waterproof jacket, and comfortable walking shoes is often suggested, as weather can change from cool to warm with occasional rain. Bringing a reusable water bottle and sunscreen helps during outdoor activities.
What is the nightlife in New Castle like?
New Castle has a quiet nightlife scene, with a handful of local pubs, casual restaurants, and seasonal community gatherings. Live music and informal events at town venues are often part of the evening’s options.
What are the most popular events or festivals in New Castle?
New Castle celebrates seasonal fairs, car shows, and basketball tournaments, especially around summer and fall. Community concerts, holiday parades, and arts festivals also draw residents and travelers alike.
Are there family friendly vacation rentals in New Castle?
Many vacation rentals in New Castle are designed with families in mind, featuring larger living spaces and proximity to parks or community recreation. Neighborhoods close to schools or playgrounds are frequently suggested for family stays.
Destinations to explore
- Nashville Vacation rentals
- Chicago Vacation rentals
- Indianapolis Vacation rentals
- Columbus Vacation rentals
- Pittsburgh Vacation rentals
- St. Louis Vacation rentals
- Cleveland Vacation rentals
- Louisville Vacation rentals
- Cincinnati Vacation rentals
- Detroit Vacation rentals
- Milwaukee Vacation rentals
- Knoxville Vacation rentals
- Lucas Oil Stadium
- Indianapolis Motor Speedway
- Indiana Convention Center
- Gainbridge Fieldhouse
- Indianapolis Zoo
- Eagle Creek Park
- Childrens Museum
- Indiana State Fairgrounds & Event Center
- Broad Ripple Park
- Butler University
- University of Indianapolis
- Grand Park Sports Campus
- IUPUI Campus Center
- Holliday Park
- Circle Centre Mall Shopping Center
- Indianapolis Canal Walk
- Garfield Park
- Fort Harrison State Park
- Indiana State Museum
- Indiana World War Memorial
- Victory Field
- Eiteljorg Museum
- White River State Park
- Soldiers and Sailors Monument





