Vacation rentals in Tappan Lake

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Tappan Lake

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

An A-frame structure is nestled among trees, overlooking a serene pond. The geometric design features large windows and a wooden deck, creating a harmonious connection with nature. A fountain adds movement to the tranquil water, while lush greenery encircles the scene, enhancing the secluded atmosphere.

Place to stay in Beach City

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 404 reviews

Romantic A-Frame Escape | Fireplace, Tub, Lakeview

Forest Lane Aframe - @forestlane__ Escape to our cozy A-frame cabin nestled in the woods, overlooking a serene pond with a bubbling fountain. Enjoy mornings with fresh local coffee on the deck, afternoons kayaking or relaxing in the hammock, and evenings soaking in the deep tub or unwinding by the indoor fireplace or outdoor campfire area . This peaceful retreat offers everything you need to disconnect and recharge—nature, comfort, and a touch of romance - The perfect couples or solo getaway

Guest favorite

Cabin in Strasburg

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 325 reviews

Scandinavian Cabin• Hot Tub• Fire Pit • (6 guests)

On the Outside •Hot Tub •Fire Pit •Gas Grill •Level 2 EV charger •Adirondack Chairs Built in ‘22! In the woods of Strasburg 30 minutes > Pro Football Hall of Fame 15 minutes > Sugarcreek (Amish Country) 20 minutes > 6 wineries The White Oak Cabin: •2 bed •2 bath •Fully stocked kitchen 🧑‍🍳 •4 Electric Fireplaces 🔥 •Living room with 50”TV 📺 •Climate control in each room ❄️ •Step ladder to loft 🪜 In the loft: •Dedicated workspace 💻 •1 Huge Sectional-room for 2 😴 •50” TV •Fireplace

Guest favorite

The cabin exterior is illuminated at night, showcasing its rustic log design. Snow blankets the ground surrounding the structure, and a covered porch offers a welcoming entrance. Soft light emanates from the windows, creating a cozy ambiance among the surrounding trees.

Cabin in Piedmont

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 152 reviews

Lake-Top Cabin, Cozy & Romantic Getaway

We believe, you need to disconnect from your daily routines in order to connect with yourself and others. That’s why we’ve created this cozy and romantic getaway close to Piedmont Lake and want to share it now with you. Book our Lake-Top Cabin today and make memories to last a life time. Explore 38 miles of shoreline from the seat of a kayak or hike the Buckeye Trail along Piedmont Lake. It’s stunning landscapes and abundant wildlife make it a remarkable place to seek serenity and adventure.

Top guest favorite

A modern cabin is featured, surrounded by trees and bathed in golden light from the setting sun. A spacious deck extends from the cabin, providing seating areas, while steps lead down to the gravel path below amidst lush landscaping.

Place to stay in Sugarcreek

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 285 reviews

The Haven / Scenic Aframe cabin

The Haven is just that - a place of rest. Keep it simple at this peaceful and centrally-located place. The cabin is nestled in a wooded area with a pond view and rolling hills. In the heart of beautiful Amish country we are just minutes away from popular attractions. The living area includes a full kitchen, washer and dryer, and comfortable furniture to enjoy a smart tv and fireplace. A King bed and full bath on the main floor. The loft has a queen bed. We welcome you to come stay with us!

Top guest favorite

A rustic cabin features earthy stonework and large windows, surrounded by lush greenery. Stone steps lead to a patio area adorned with planters. A vibrant red door adds a pop of color, while trees provide a natural backdrop, creating a serene environment.

Home in Fresno

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 103 reviews

Romantic private cabin w hot tub in Amish Country

Retreat to this private cabin featuring a year-round hot tub, perfect for relaxation. Tucked among pines and rocks in the heart of Amish country, where the occasional clip-clop of horse and buggies adds charm. Styled like a railroad depot, the artistically furnished home displays intricate stonework, tile and custom stained glass. The kitchen includes appliances and cookware, with the outdoor area offering a propane grill & stake-grill. Complimentary firewood is provided for the firepit.

Guest favorite

A cabin is nestled in a winter landscape, surrounded by freshly fallen snow. Two evergreen trees are frosted with snow near the entrance. A covered porch is visible on one side. Snow-covered pathways lead into the tranquil wooded area, enhancing the serene atmosphere.

Tiny home in Scio

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 281 reviews

Cozy Cabin

SMK Cabin Rental is a cozy little cabin located 1.5 miles from Tappan Lake. 2 open loft style bedrooms upstairs. Kitchen, bathroom and living room downstairs. Central air and central heat. Dish tv. hot tub Gas grill and a firepit. Located on our own 12 wooded acres. Guests are more than welcome to enjoy a hike in our woods to enjoy the nature. We are not a 5 star resort nor do we try to be. We are a camping cabin. You may encounter wildlife deer, raccoon, bugs, etc on your trip..

Guest favorite

The inviting front porch features a swing and multiple potted plants, enhancing the charming yellow exterior of the historic home. Two large windows with sheer curtains allow natural light to fill the entryway, creating a warm and welcoming entrance.

Vacation home in Deersville

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 237 reviews

Hazel's House

Historic 1860’s home in quaint Deersville, Amish Country nearby, beautiful sport lakes, perfect for families, fishing, hunting. Parties and events are not allowed. Spacious, 1 hour from Pittsburg, WiFi, SmartTV, large gourmet kitchen, shower/steam sauna, soaking tub, outdoor hot tub, antiques mixed with contemporary art, and Appalachian Ohio country beauty year round. EBL-Everything but lace! Pets are permitted but must be kenneled when you’re away! Pet fee is $75, two maximum.

Top guest favorite

A rustic cabin is nestled among lush greenery, featuring a wood exterior with large windows. A hot tub is located on the deck, complementing the peaceful country setting. The gentle slope of the lawn enhances the serene atmosphere.

Cabin in Newcomerstown

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 153 reviews

Cozy 2 Bedroom Cabin with Hot Tub

Relax with the whole family at this peaceful cabin in the country. Surrounded by woods, rolling hills and plenty of wildlife to watch. A pond is a nice walk up the gradual hill behind the cabin. Located in the heart of Three Rivers Wine Trail, there are plenty of wineries to visit, as well as our favorite local brewery, the Wooly Pig. There’s a large hot tub to enjoy on the deck outside that is big enough for 8 people.

Top guest favorite

An elevated A-frame cabin is showcased, surrounded by vibrant autumn foliage. The structure features large glass doors that open to a spacious deck, extending out over the landscape. The design balances modern and natural elements, with a striking contrast of dark siding and light stone.

Treehouse in Sugarcreek

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 100 reviews

The Highland @ Brandywine Grove

The Highland is truly a masterpiece uniquely built treehouse feel with a creative touch. This A-frame is elevated 20ft in the air, overlooking a private pond with a neighboring elk farm and a beautiful golf course. And of course sunrises that won’t disappoint ! No pet policy. No parties or events. *NO elopements or weddings permitted on the property unless a contract is signed with the owner.

Guest favorite

A rustic log cabin is nestled in a lush wooded area, surrounded by greenery. Large windows allow natural light to fill the interior, while a stone fireplace enhances the exterior's charm. A spacious porch invites relaxation amidst the serene landscape.

Cabin in East Rochester

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 362 reviews

Cherry Ridge | Breezewood Cabins

This cabin is located in a 15-acre woods that is full of birds, deer, wild turkeys, and squirrels. This cabin is designed to be a perfect place to get away and find the rest and quietness we all need. It is intended to help you make memories, and reconnect with the person you love. We enjoy hosting and look forward to serving our guests in the best way possible!

Guest favorite

A rustic cabin with a wooden exterior is showcased under a cloudy sky. The structure features a covered wrap-around porch with a railing, offering views of the surrounding farmland. Large windows are visible on the sides, enhancing the cabin's connection to nature.

Cabin in Carrollton

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 114 reviews

Rustic Serenity

Located on 80+ acres of woods and farmland, this rustic cabin is perfect for getting away from it all. Enjoy an evening by the fire, watch the sunrise over the treetops, see the deer graze on the hillside, do some bird watching, or stargaze without city lights to hinder. This is a place to truly unwind and disconnect from the hustle and bustle of city life.

Guest favorite

An open-concept studio space includes a fully equipped kitchen with wooden cabinetry and a cozy living area. A gray couch and a light armchair are arranged around a decorative rug. Natural light enters through two small windows, complemented by neutral wall colors and exposed wooden beams.

Guesthouse in Cambridge

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 414 reviews

The Bunker House

This is a cozy studio concrete “bunker” house across the driveway from our residence. the Bunker has a private patio with a hot tub. It is located on an idyllic 35 acre property with two ponds that connects to Salt Fork State Park public land. We are located a few miles from the State Park entrance and Deerassic Park and close to I77 and I70.