Vacation rentals in New Castle

Riverfront Retreat

Have a quiet morning in the three season room or on the deck watching bald eagles soar or 5 foot tall herons hunt for breakfast in the river. Riverwood offers serenity in the country and stunning nature views. With private river access for kayaking, fishing, birdwatching or hiking this is the perfect place for your group to gather and recharge. Located 10 minutes from Pa Rt 79 and I-80, yet off the beaten path in the heart of Amish Country. Minutes from local farm stands, wineries and breweries

Michelle’s Cozy Cabin A/C &Heat &Walking trail

Cozy cabin w/ A/C tucked in the woods on my 9 acre farm. Overlooks pasture with horses. Horse treats provided. No running water but 2 five gallon jugs provided Showers available at main house. Also water available at spigot behind log cabin. Incinerator toilet. 1/2 mile hiking trail on property surrounding the pasture Great WI-FI/ cell svc, High speed internet and 32”TV with Netfix Heat and A/C Infrared sauna If bringing a pet, please check pet at booking and be mindful of cleanliness

Staycation Lake Cottage HUGE Year Round Swim Spa

This mid 1800's log cabin, built as humble servant's quarters, has been completely transformed. It's now a spacious lake home with multiple additions and an unexpectedly gigantic swim spa for year-round relaxation, romance or fun! Feel at peace, at home and pleasantly surprised by quality time connecting with loved ones in a tranquil natural setting. 8 Adults plus space for additional young kids! WIFI Smart Roku TVs Boardman and Youngstown attractions. Minutes from Turnpike

Charming Farm Cottage

Relax with the whole family at this peaceful homestead cottage nestled among mature pines. Scenic views and tasty natural treats abound on the guest house of this 6 acre homestead. Enjoy an evening by the wood stove or watch the sunrise from the pet friendly deck. Ask about lawn games or access to pool and spa attached at the owners' residence down the lane. Located minutes away from fishing lakes, colleges, state parks, game land, and Downtown Mercer. Easy access from I-79, I-80.

“The Thomas” House with Private Hot Tub

A picturesque countryside getaway with the convenience of shopping and restaurants nearby. If you love breweries, hot tubbing, golfing, cruising the neighborhood in a Model T golf cart, or just relaxing in a really cool house, this place is for you! Antiquing and open summer concerts minutes away. Comfort awaits in beautiful cozy interiors with vintage industrial vibe. With a touch of history and a lot of charm, your stay at “The Henry” will be a fun and welcome retreat.

Cozy Cottage nestled on the Slippery Rock Creek

Secluded along the banks of the Slippery Rock Creek is the 4th generation family cottage, fully renovated in 2017, originally built in 1940. Descend the 45 steps to the cottage and find “there’s no place like (a 2nd) home”. From the wraparound deck you may see geese, deer, bald eagles, osprey, beaver, great blue heron and ducks. You will find yourself just 15 minutes from Moraine and McConnells Mill State Parks. 15 minutes from Mines and Meadows, 10 minutes from Sunset Ranch.

Rainbow Bend

The home is situated on 13 acres of land bordering both sides of the Neshannock Creek. With towering old growth forest on all sides, you truly connect with nature. The property boasts exclusive access to the Neshannock Creek, including a creek side deck. A cascading waterfall borders us to the north. The log home is constructed with rough hewn timbers, granite countertop, and hardwood floors throughout. A towering buck stove stone hearth is the centerpiece of the great room.

Safe Haven - Modern Getaway in Amish Country

Come relax in our private 2 bedroom , full bath retreat. Your area is a separate downstairs apartment that has its own private entrance so you can come and go as you please. It includes a equipped kitchen and living room for your comfort. Located 0.8 mi. from Westminster College in the middle of Amish country. Start your day with complimentary Keurig or go for fresh local made Apple Castle donuts. You can also enjoy tax free shopping at the Grove City Outlets minutes away.

Lakeside Hideaway

Nestled in the scenic back roads of Pennsylvania, this charming two-bedroom bungalow exudes warmth and coziness. Surrounded by rolling hills, lush summer/spring time greenery and beautiful fall colors, the home welcomes you with a sense of tranquility the moment you step through the front door. Some notable features of this home are the large yard, handmade pergola and fire pit, and small lake with Bass and Catfish which provide the perfect setting for outdoor fun.

Amish Paradise

Amish Paradise has an open floor concept with the living room, dining room and kitchen on the first floor. There are 3 bedrooms on the second floor. Going up the stairs we have a side view looking out an arched window into the woods. However, our favorite part of this home is the view from the wrap around deck!! It has a knock out Vista over looking our property and beyond to Marti Park! Did I mention that this house was once a true Amish Home?😉

The Great Escape

As one of our guests noted: “This home is named perfectly. It was a great escape." We invite you to stay in our small but cozy house in the very quiet "Pittsburgh Circle" area of town. The property backs onto a greenbelt - down a sharp embankment you can see the Connoquenessing Creek - which you can enjoy from the covered patio or the breakfast table in front of the large window. We have seen deer, groundhogs, hawks, and even a bald eagle!

Schoolhouse~Amish Countryside~No Cleaning Fee!

Welcome to the No. 8 Schoolhouse! This converted school was originally built by artist, Ronald Garrett as an artist retreat. 2024 brought many changes to the Schoolhouse retreat. Owners, Michael and Christina decided the Schoolhouse deserved a revamp. And revamp they did! They remodeled top to bottom while also redesigning to give their guests a funky experience! It's one of a kind. You'll never see another like it!