Vacation rentals in Cayuga Island

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Cayuga Island

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

The living area is furnished with a gray sofa adorned with decorative pillows, accompanied by a small wooden table. A sleek kitchenette features modern appliances, including a stove and refrigerator. Natural light filters through a nearby window, enhancing the bright and airy space.

Apartment in Niagara Falls

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 69 reviews

The Beverly Suites Unit 3, five mins from Falls

Welcome to comfort at The Beverly Suites, nestled in the tourism district of Niagara Falls. Our prime location is within a 5 minute walking distance of the OLG Stage, Casino, and Restaurants in the Fallsview District. You'll also be just a short 5 minute car ride from the awe-inspiring Niagara Falls, Clifton Hill, and all must-see tourist attractions. Whether you're here for a romantic getaway, family vacation, or a weekend adventure with friends, The Beverly Suites is an ideal choice for you!

Top guest favorite

An open living area features a dining table with flowers, a comfortable seating area, and a kitchen space equipped with appliances. Natural light illuminates the bamboo flooring, creating a bright and welcoming atmosphere. The layout allows for a sense of spaciousness and comfort.

Home in North Tonawanda

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 143 reviews

Mediterranean Style Suite 15 Min from the Falls!

Take a break and unwind at this peaceful previous in-law suite oasis. Located in a quiet very safe suburb of Wheatfield NY. This apartment is attached to our home but has its own private entrance and your own dedicated driveway the suite is not shared, only you! 15 Min away from well sought after wineries, such as: Honeymoon Trail, Freedom Run, Bella Rose Vine-Yard! 15 Min ride to the famous Niagara Falls, Uber and Lyft easily available. 10 Min from Fashion Outlets of Niagara Falls USA Mall.

Top guest favorite

A cozy living room showcases a textured brick wall, paired with a light gray sofa and two brown armchairs. A modern coffee table sits in front, accompanied by a small plant. Natural light enters through large windows with light-filtering shades.

Apartment in North Tonawanda

5 out of 5 average rating, 58 reviews

Downtown NT Webster St Chic & Cozy apt 2

"Welcome to Apartment #2 at 106 Webster Street, your perfect home away from home in the heart of downtown N. Tonawanda's vibrant entertainment district. This 2nd floor chic, cozy apartment is ideal for both foodies and explorers. Just one block from the historic Riviera Theatre and steps from local boutiques and the scenic waterfront, you’re perfectly positioned to enjoy all the city has to offer. Business travelers will appreciate the modern amenities, quiet atmosphere, and convenient location

Superhost

A comfortable living room is shown, featuring a gray sofa with patterned cushions and a side table with a warm lamp. The cozy space includes a large area rug and a television, while natural light filters through sheer curtains. An adjacent dining area is visible.

Home in Niagara Falls

4.84 out of 5 average rating, 502 reviews

Red Door - Niagara Falls USA

Welcome to the Red Door of Niagara Falls, NY USA. We offer a private, fully furnished, 3 queen beds/2 full baths home located just minutes from beautiful Niagara Falls USA and Canada. Our home is conveniently located in a nice neighborhood near Factory Outlet shopping, the Seneca Niagara Casino, hiking, biking, movie theaters, and a full array of dining choices. WE ARE PERMITTED BY THE CITY. Please read the rules and info below. We are looking forward to having you as our guests! -Jim and Colin

Guest favorite

A modern kitchen area features a granite countertop with stools positioned nearby. A stainless steel refrigerator and oven are visible, alongside a cozy living space with a large window and decorative curtains. Exposed brick accents complement the warm wood flooring.

Home in Niagara Falls

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 346 reviews

Little Niagara Bungalow-Minutes from Niagara Falls

The Little Niagara Bungalow is a newly remodeled home less than ten minutes from the Falls! Groceries and restaurants as well as a large outlet mall even closer! Blackout blinds in the bedrooms as well as TVs with Directv and Netflix on Roku. Comfortable queen beds with a couple pillow choices. Free off street parking for up to 4 cars plus free street parking. Full amenities including a brand new kitchen and on site laundry. Beautiful new bathroom with a large walk in shower. See you soon!.

Top guest favorite

A spacious sleeping area features a queen bed and two twin beds, complemented by natural light from multiple windows. A wooden dresser stands against the wall, and a large area rug adds texture beneath the furniture. Soft blue accents enhance the calming environment.

Apartment in Grand Island

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 111 reviews

The Blue Squirrel Inn (with boaters’ dock)

Dock your boat & relax in a spacious escape, tucked down a private drive, in a separate suite of our family house. Only a short drive to Niagara Falls, Beaver Island Beach or State Park, our retreat is steps from the Niagara River & bike path. Contact host for docking arrangements or just enjoy watching the boats glide into the marina or take a stroll to the pier. You will have plenty of space to yourself & find the break you deserve. Request an update regarding safe path from the boat dock.

Guest favorite

A spacious bed with a decorative blue cover is positioned in a well-lit room. Decorative wall art is displayed above the bed. A small wooden table with a lamp is nearby, and a doorway leads to an area beyond the bed.

Guest suite in North Tonawanda

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 38 reviews

Totally Private Suite 15 Minutes to Niagara Falls

You'll Love: 0 cleaning fees, private entrance, private bathroom, in-unit remote-control AC and heat, stocked coffee/tea bar, free parking, mini-fridge, microwave 5 minutes to N Tonawanda's cute downtown (4/5-star dining, boutiques, theater), 10 to Niagara Airport, 20 to downtown Buffalo, 25 to Canada Relax in my calm, stylish, large space. Walk to waterfront, lush parks, and corner store. Perfect blend of comfort and convenience. Accessible first-floor unit. Unwind peacefully by the water.

Superhost

A modern kitchen features a wooden countertop with two place settings, including plates and glasses. A stainless steel sink is paired with a silver refrigerator. Shelves hold potted plants and glassware, while a wall clock adds a practical touch to the light-colored walls.

Home in Niagara Falls

4.81 out of 5 average rating, 479 reviews

Blue 74 Niagara Falls USA(3 beds/1.5 baths)

Welcome to Blue 74 of Niagara Falls, NY USA! We offer a private, fully furnished home that sleeps 7 total ( 2 queen beds, trundle and a sofa. We're located 6-8 minutes from the US side of the Falls. Conveniently located in nice, quiet neighborhood near Outlet shopping, Seneca Casino, hiking, biking, movie theaters, and a full array of dining choices. WE ARE LEGALLY PERMITTED BY THE CITY. Please see rules and info below. We are looking forward to having you as our guests! - Colin and Jim

Top guest favorite

The cottage exterior showcases a charming façade with a peaked roof and large front windows. A small wooden deck features a red umbrella sheltering a bistro set, offering a welcoming entryway surrounded by greenery.

Cottage in Niagara Falls

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 202 reviews

Waterfront Niagara River Cottage

Listed since November 2020. Completely remodeled cozy cottage on the Niagara River! Quick 15minute drive down the river to Niagara Falls! Also easy access by car to surrounding Buffalo and all that it has to offer. Or relax, secluded away with full access to the entire cottage and amenities during your stay. Sleeps up to 4 people, two beds, washer/dryer, electric stove, oven, and microwave, complimentary internet access, Smart TV, and a private river-front backyard with sweeping views!!

Top guest favorite

A spacious living area is furnished with a large sectional sofa adorned with decorative pillows. A coffee table sits in front, accompanied by two remote controls. In the background, a dining table with chairs is visible, against a light-filled wall with a window.

Apartment in Niagara Falls

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 142 reviews

The Gianna 1 bedroom UPPER close to Falls & Casino

Come stay in our beautiful, completely remodeled one bedroom upper. We put in A LOT of work and we are so proud to share it with you! We are located on a quiet residential street. Niagara Falls Sate Park is a 6 minute drive. TONS of great restaurants close by. Hyde Park is a two minute walk out your front door. We will be available by text, to help with anything you need :)

Guest favorite

A light-filled bedroom features a spacious bed with decorative pillows. Two windows provide natural light, while a ceiling fan offers ventilation. A cozy chair and bedside tables with lamps complement the soft color palette and polished wooden floors.

Apartment in Niagara Falls

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 161 reviews

Cozy 2 bedroom Unit, 15 Minutes to Niagara Falls

Enjoy the waterfront view from this centrally located home, just 15 minutes from one of the most famous waterfalls in the world, Niagara Falls, and 25 minutes away from the City of Buffalo! **Located 26 miles from Highmark Stadium (Home of the Buffalo Bills). Go BILLS! **Located 17 miles from the Key Bank Center (Home of the Buffalo Sabres).

Top guest favorite

A single-story house is shown with a light exterior and a brown roof. The driveway leads to a two-car garage with closed doors. Green grass and small bushes are visible in the front yard, with a walkway leading to the entrance of the home.

Home in Grand Island

5 out of 5 average rating, 17 reviews

Home in Grand Island, NY! 4 mi from Niagara Falls!

Welcome to beautiful Grand Island, NY! Our home has 2 private bedrooms, living room, 1 full bath and laundry room located on the main floor. We also have a basement game room—the perfect space for fun, laughs, and making memories.! Your family will be close to everything when you stay at this centrally-located place!