Skip to content

Lake side house rentals in Buckeye Lake

Book unique cabins, vacation rentals, and more on Airbnb

Top-rated house rentals in Buckeye Lake

Guests agree: these vacation rentals are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

SUPERHOST
  1. Entire home
  2. Thornville
Main Lake Cottage on Buckeye Lake

Welcome to Duck Inn Too! Duck Inn Too is completely renovated with all new appliances and is a perfect place to relax and enjoy all seasons. There is no better way to relax than sitting on the deck and enjoying the amazing views of the lake. Even though Buckeye Lake is known for summer fun, the off-season vibe and relaxing and quiet atmosphere make Duck Inn Too a great place to recharge! Special off-season rates are now available!

  1. Entire home
  2. Buckeye Lake
Cozy Home by the Lake

Cozy Home by the Lake is your home away from home. This home is close to everything Buckeye Lake has to offer. Quiet and safe neighborhood. You will be within short walking distance to the lake, and some of Buckeye Lake’s most notorious restaurants such as; the Brewery, the Boat Yard, the Yacht Club, Chef Shack, Our Lakeside Diner, and many more. We hope you choose to stay with us.

SUPERHOST
  1. Entire home
  2. Thornville
Lakefront Buckeye Lake Family Retreat

This comfortable three bedroom, two bath home sits right on Buckeye Lake with more than 75 feet of water frontage. It's an easy 45 minute drive from Columbus but feels like you're far away. The kitchen is well stocked for all of your cooking needs. The view is breathtaking from the deck or inside while sitting on the huge sectional couch in the family room. Explore the lake on the kayaks or the paddle board provided or sit back on the deck and sip your favorite beverage while taking in the view.

Vacation rentals for every style

Get the amount of space that is right for you

  • Cabins
  • Houses
  • Unique stays

Buckeye Lake house rentals

SUPERHOST
  1. Entire home
  2. Buckeye Lake
New Home - "See More" at the lake
  1. Entire home
  2. Thornville
2 BR ranch w/boat slip and big yard
SUPERHOST
  1. Entire home
  2. Buckeye Lake
Beautiful Lake House in Buckeye Lake, Ohio.
SUPERHOST
  1. Entire home
  2. Buckeye Lake
Buckeye Lake Getaway
  1. Entire home
  2. Buckeye Lake
NEW! Lakefront Home w/ Rooftop Deck, Grill, Games!
SUPERHOST
  1. Entire home
  2. Buckeye Lake
Adorable Buckeye Lake Cottage
SUPERHOST
  1. Entire home
  2. Hebron
Home away from home - fenced yard a block to lake
  1. Entire home
  2. Millersport
Buckeye Lake Waterfront on Bike Path - Sleeps 10
  1. Entire home
  2. Buckeye Lake
NEW! Spacious Buckeye Lake Home w/ Fire Pit + Deck
  1. Entire home
  2. Thornville
Modern & spacious 5-bedroom home near the lake
  1. Entire home
  2. Buckeye Lake
Beautiful 2-Bedroom lake house with hot tub
  1. Entire home
  2. Buckeye Lake
Newly updated....North Bank.....1 min walk to Lake

Buckeye Lake cabin rentals

  1. Entire cabin
  2. Buckeye Lake
Little Red Cabin @ Buckeye Lake
SUPERHOST
  1. Entire cabin
  2. Glenford
Hopewell Springs Farm and Racquet(ish) Club
  1. Entire cabin
  2. Rushville
The Kennedy Cabin, Est. 7/7/77
SUPERHOST
  1. Entire cabin
  2. Newark
Rustic Cabin Hideaway, Hikers Retreat & Homestead
SUPERHOST
  1. Entire cabin
  2. Newark
All American Cabin
SUPERHOST
  1. Entire cabin
  2. Nashport
Sunset Fields Cabin
  1. Entire cabin
  2. Alexandria
Log Cabin close to Denison. Beautiful farm views.

Your guide to Buckeye Lake

All About Buckeye Lake

Just east of Columbus you’ll find the village of Buckeye Lake, where summer cottages surround the shore of the tranquil lake that shares its name. Family-owned businesses line the town’s quiet streets, and near the town’s center you may come across microbreweries and the Buckeye Lake Historical Society Museum, whose collection of memorabilia invites visitors to take a journey through the area’s past.

Buckeye Lake itself was constructed in 1826 to serve as a feeder canal for the famous Erie Canal. Among the countless islands that dot the narrow reservoir are the Cranberry Bog State Nature Preserve, a floating island created when the surrounding swamp was flooded in the 19th century. Buckeye is a popular place for boating and fishing for perch, catfish, and largemouth bass. Around the lake, you’ll also find a few smaller villages, a winery, and Buckeye Lake State Park, Ohio’s oldest state park.


How do I get around Buckeye Lake?

The closest airport to Buckeye Lake is the John Glenn Columbus International Airport (CMH). From there, it is about a 30-minute drive to Buckeye Lake. No public transport options are available, but you can take a taxi into town. Since there are limited transportation options at Buckeye Lake itself, the most convenient way to get around is by renting a car at the airport. Once you’re in town, it is possible to walk or cycle around downtown. You’ll also find many boat launches, docks, and marinas along the lakefront, making it easy to rent a boat, kayak, or paddleboard to take onto the water.


When is the best time to stay in a vacation rental in Buckeye Lake?

Summer is unsurprisingly the busiest time of year, especially on weekends due to the lake’s proximity to Columbus, so it is a good idea to secure your Buckeye Lake rental with that in mind. The weather is hot and sunny then, making it a great time to be out on the water. With fall, the leaves surrounding the lake begin to change, creating a kaleidoscope of colors, and although it is starting to get chilly, you may be able to still get out on the water until mid-October. During the Annual Buckeye Lake Singer-Songwriter’s Festival takes place in early October, many concerts are held on the lakeshores.

By the end of November, you may begin to see the first flakes of snow as the temperature continues to drop, and some local businesses close for the winter. Although January through late March can be extremely cold, you may have a chance to see the lake covered with ice, as well as ice fishermen trying to catch saugeye and crappie.


What are the top things to do in Buckeye Lake?

The Dawes Arboretum

With nearly 2,000 acres of themed gardens as well as wilder natural areas, this tranquil arboretum is an attractive place for nature-spotting and picnicking. Twelve miles of gently sloped hiking trails wend their way through the park, and as you meander along the crisscrossing pathways, you can visit the Japanese garden, azalea garden, and one of the country’s northernmost cypress swamps.

Buckeye Lake State Park

The Buckeye Lake State Park, which encompasses the 3,100-acre Buckeye Lake and 400 acres of surrounding shorelines, is perhaps the main draw for visitors. You’ll find three swimming areas and picnic spots around the park, as well as the paved, four-mile Buckeye Lake Dam Trail. This trail takes you from the village along the shoreline to the Leibs Island Trailhead, passing by cottages and boat docks as you take in sweeping views of the lake and its islands.

Great Circle Museum

Built by a people now known as the Hopewell culture between 100 B.C. and 500 A.D., the Great Circle Earthworks has been a sacred site for Native Americans for more than two millennia. A site for ceremonies honoring the dead or social gatherings, the Earthworks are the world’s largest set of geometric earthen enclosures. The four-square-mile complex also once served as a cathedral, cemetery, and astronomical observatory. This fascinating outdoor museum is located just 20 minutes from Buckeye Lake.