We’re sorry, some parts of the Airbnb website don’t work properly without JavaScript enabled.

House vacation rentals in Alum Creek

Find and book unique houses on Airbnb

Top-rated house rentals in Alum Creek

Guests agree: these houses are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

A welcoming living area features a light-colored wall and an elegant chandelier. A sectional leather sofa and a minimalist coffee table are centered on a patterned area rug. Natural light filters through two large windows, complemented by sheer curtains.

Home in Westerville

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 178 reviews

Uptown Westerville - Otterbein University

This cozy home has been updated top to bottom and is located on Otterbein University Campus in the heart of Uptown Westerville, next to the historic Hanby House. Walkable to several Locally owned Restaurants, Coffee shops, Bars, unique shopping, Ice Cream, parks, 911 memorial. Under 20 mins to The Columbus Zoo and Zoombezi Bay waterpark, Downtown, Easton Town Center, The Columbus Convention Center, and The Ohio State University. Polaris Fashion Place, Costco, and high-end dining minutes away.

Top guest favorite

A cheerful kitchen features vibrant floral wallpaper and a striking red backsplash. Modern appliances are included, such as a microwave and dishwasher. A window allows natural light, while a small dining table is visible in the adjoining space. Decorative shelves enhance the visual appeal.

Home in Westerville

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 118 reviews

THE GOOD PLACE Uptown Westerville, Colorful & Cozy

Charming private home near the heart of Uptown Westerville shops, restaurants and bike path. Prime location with vibrant, happy interior. Easy access to 270 & 71. Ranch style. 1 mile from Otterbein University. Within 20 minutes: The Ohio State University, CMH Airport, Nationwide Children’s, Easton, Polaris, Short North, Downtown Columbus. Comfy premium beds sleep 6. Fully stocked kitchen and cozy screened-in porch. 3 bedrooms with great layout for families or small groups. Fenced-in back porch.

Top guest favorite

A spacious living area is highlighted by a cozy couch and a modern coffee table atop a patterned rug. A stone fireplace adds warmth, while natural light fills the space. A swivel TV is mounted on the wall, providing entertainment for guests.

Home in Columbus

5 out of 5 average rating, 114 reviews

The Bexley Abode: Modern + Cozy

The Bexley Abode is in a prime spot: mins from attractions & highways but tucked in a quaint part of Cbus. It is home-y and conducive to a family or solo visitor. My husband & I remodeled and designed it with thought and sentiment. Highlights: ranch, open layout, cozy couch w/ 50" TV that swivels towards kitchen, gas fireplace, natural light, simple modern design finishes, new appliances, Keurig, hotel- style master bath w/ heated floor, kids room w/ toys/games, USB ports, WiFi, private parking

Top guest favorite

A light blue house is presented with a welcoming pink front door. The porch features black railings, and decorative shutters frame the windows. Lush green grass and mature trees enhance the outdoor space, contributing to a pleasant curb appeal.

Home in Columbus

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 175 reviews

Welcome to The Fulton Cottage!

This two bedroom, one bath home, sleeps 6 and has a washer and dryer. All amenities provided. We are located in between High St. and Indianola Ave., giving you immediate access to Interstate 71 and OH-315. This is the place to stay! Short term or longer, we've got you covered. OSU games and graduation? We're 5 miles away! Transportation issues? We have access to COTA at High, Morse, and Indianola. Going to a game or event at Nationwide or Huntington Park? We're 8 miles away. Come enjoy!

The living room showcases high ceilings with exposed wooden beams and dramatic crown molding. Large leaded glass windows frame the space, allowing natural light to fill the room. A plush green sofa is paired with a cozy armchair, accented by a decorative rug and coffee table.

Home in Columbus

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 144 reviews

The Clintonville Casita | Walkable & Inspiring

⭐ Featured on Condé Nast's best of Columbus list, May 2025 ✔️ Unique 1930s home with elements of Spanish Revival architecture ✔️ Two bedrooms on main level (minimal steps); one queen bed (with en suite) and one full bed ✔️ Personally curated artwork, collected and handmade by the owner ✔️ Private driveway and off-street parking; EV charging w/ Tesla adapter ✔️ Central Clintonville location; walk to Weiland's grocery in 10 mins, Starbucks (High St.) in 11 mins, and more restaurants in 15 mins

Top guest favorite

An open dining and family room space is highlighted by warm wood floors. A large dining table is surrounded by white chairs, while a comfortable sofa is positioned across from a 58" 4K TV. Soft lighting enhances the inviting atmosphere near a window with light drapes.

Home in Columbus

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 115 reviews

The Polish House - Quiet - Central - 2BR - W/D

Nestled in the heart of Beechwold, this charming space is designed to make you feel right at home while exploring Columbus or just relaxing. Quiet neighborhood with easy access to 71 and 315. Go for a stroll in the friendly neighborhood, or hang out in the fenced backyard. Dining, grocery, bars, and shopping are quick trips 1.2mi for your convenience. Enjoy the full kitchen, large dining table, and 58" 4K tv during your stay. Ground floor bedroom has Queen bed, upstairs bedroom has 2 twins.

Top guest favorite

A spacious backyard is showcased, featuring a manicured lawn beneath tall trees and surrounded by lush greenery. A charming two-story structure with a balcony is visible, complemented by additional outdoor seating areas and a gazebo, inviting a peaceful outdoor experience.

Home in Westerville

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 557 reviews

Serene Private Space in the Heart of the Ville.

Feel at home in quaint uptown Westerville! This hotel-type space features a private patio (with therapeutic hot tub) leading to the entrance off the serene back yard. Stroll on nearby walk/bike paths or through beautiful Otterbein campus as you make your way to unique shops, coffee houses, ice cream parlors, or restaurants where you can enjoy an adult beverage in the historic town where prohibition began! Streaming TV and a spa-like bath adds to the R&R you'll need to complete your day.

Top guest favorite

A serene outdoor space features a large, heated saltwater pool surrounded by a stone patio. A covered seating area with draped curtains offers shade, while comfortable outdoor furniture provides relaxation options. A children's playground stands in the background, enhancing the family-friendly atmosphere.

Home in Columbus

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 141 reviews

This is it! Pool -2 King Bed Suites -Private oasis

Amazing Pool, Outdoor Oasis, 2 King bed suites, Workout room, Office/poker room, Kids Playground, Movie theater, Chefs kitchen, Washer/Dryer, Full Dining room, Sleeps 12, and a great location! -Bridge Park Dublin- 9 Minutes -The Horseshoe (Ohio Stadium/OSU)- 12 Minutes -Nationwide Arena (Blue Jackets)- 13 Minutes -Muirfield Village Golf Club (Memorial Tournament)- 17 Minutes -The Short North/Downtown/Convention center- 15 Minutes -Lower-dot-com Field (Columbus Crew)- 14 Minutes

Top guest favorite

A spacious open living area is highlighted by a large wooden dining table surrounded by light grey chairs. Two cozy armchairs with warm tones sit near a window, complemented by a modern light fixture above. A minimalist desk area with a computer is visible against a styled wall.

Home in Columbus

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 236 reviews

Quiet Clintonville Modern Charmer

Centrally located in a very quiet Columbus neighborhood - this updated mid century modern meets cozy cottage, combines updated features and design with the homes original charm. Perfect for resting, relaxing, and recharging. Just a couple of minutes from 315 and 71 .. 15 minutes to CMH .. 7 minutes to the short north .. 10 minutes to downtown. Walk to some wonderful local restaurants. * No Parties (strict) * No Events (strict) * Rarely host locals (inquire if interested)

A serene outdoor space features a private hot tub situated among warm string lights that create a cozy ambiance. The area is enclosed by wooden fencing and a brick pathway leads to the tub. An air conditioning unit is visible against the brick wall nearby.

Home in Columbus

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 376 reviews

Schumacher's Gem Historic Home wth Hot Tub & Study

Experience this cozy hideaway adjacent to the historic German Village! Once a carriage house, this rare find has been modernized and furnished to meet your every need — packed with amenities like dedicated office space, fast internet, and reserved parking for up to two vehicles. Perfect for those seeking relaxation in the outdoor hot tub or exploring all of the shops, dining, and recreation the neighborhood has to offer! Take it easy at this unique and tranquil getaway.

Top guest favorite

A spacious living area features a light gray sectional sofa and a tufted chaise lounge. A circular mirror hangs above the fireplace, enhancing the bright ambiance. A dining area with modern chairs is visible through an archway, complemented by natural light from large windows.

Home in Columbus

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 176 reviews

Beechwold Bungalow - Clean & Conveniently Located

Welcome to your home away from home in Columbus! This charming and cozy single-story house features two comfortable bedrooms (3 beds total) and one full bathroom, thoughtfully updated to offer modern convenience while preserving its original character and historic charm. Whether you're here for a weekend getaway, visiting OSU, or exploring the city, this comfy home offers a quiet escape with easy access to everything Columbus has to offer.

Top guest favorite

A colorful wall hanging features intricate designs of leaves and giraffes against a vibrant teal background. Artistic elements include wooden discs stacked vertically, with decorative embellishments at the base that highlight the creativity of the space.

Home in Columbus

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 106 reviews

Artist paradise by the River

An artists creative space, full of love. Near downtown, OSU, and all the best Columbus has to offer. on a lovely quiet street next to a park and a bike path . Expect the lovely sounds of children laughing, tennis and basketball playing at times. Please Note : Dogs are welcome with approval of breed and number of pets. An additional charge of $30 Pet cleaning fee for each additional pet. Sorry no cats!

Vacation rentals for every style

Get the amount of space that is right for you

Apartments

Convenient locations with everyday essentials

Hotels

Stylish accommodations with great services and amenities

Unique stays

Spaces that are more than just a place to sleep

Popular amenities for Alum Creek house rentals

Free parking on premises

Air conditioning

House rentals with a pool

The exterior of the home features natural stone walls and multiple large windows. A covered porch with seating is visible at the entrance, surrounded by landscaped areas of shrubs and a layer of fallen leaves. Tall trees create a serene backdrop in the wooded setting.

Home in Westerville

Close to city, far from ordinary

A cozy dining area is highlighted by a small table with a distinctive stone surface, surrounded by two upholstered chairs. Bright flowers in a vase sit at the center, while modern appliances and light cabinetry are visible in the background.

Home in Columbus

Grove City Private Room for Two!

Home in Westerville

5 out of 5 average rating, 7 reviews

Stunning, wooded, executive home

Home in Grove City

New place to stay

Modern Boho Retreat “The Perfect Pause”

A two-story home features a light-colored exterior with a symmetrical façade. A two-car garage is visible, along with a neatly landscaped front yard and mature trees lining the property. The bright sky adds a sense of openness to the setting.

Home in Pickerington

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 24 reviews

AG Family Vacation Home

The exterior of a two-story brick home is framed by a wrought iron fence. A driveway leads up to the entrance, with a well-maintained lawn and trees surrounding the property. The house features a sloped roof and a combination of brown and red brick.

Home in Columbus

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 16 reviews

Buckeye Palace Sleep 12 Game Day Ready Free Parkin

An aerial view captures the spacious property, featuring a well-maintained home surrounded by greenery. The large pool area is highlighted, with deck chairs arranged around the pool. The grounds provide ample outdoor space, enhancing the peaceful rural setting.

Home in Delaware

4.27 out of 5 average rating, 11 reviews

Delaware Farmstead Retreat

A freestanding bathtub is positioned in the corner of a light-filled bathroom, surrounded by large windows offering natural views. The flooring features a unique pebble design, complementing the elegant interior. Light reflects softly off the smooth surfaces, creating a serene atmosphere.

Home in Pickerington

Paradise, Vacation Retreat in OH

Weekly house rentals

A historic brick cottage is showcased, displaying a sloped roof and charming details. The front yard features low-maintenance landscaping with a fenced area and a pathway leading to the door. Surrounding greenery adds to the inviting exterior of the home.

Home in Columbus

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 386 reviews

The Pearl St Cottage | Parking & Patio

A bright living area features a leather sectional sofa and a blue accent chair. A large area rug with intricate patterns covers the hardwood floor. A coffee table is positioned in front of the seating. A flat-screen TV is mounted on the wall, complemented by framed artwork.

Home in Columbus

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 133 reviews

Worthington/Clintonville private backyard

Top guest favorite

A serene bedroom is highlighted by soft floral bedding and a large floral art piece on the wall. Natural light enters through a window adorned with light curtains, creating a calming atmosphere. A small, upholstered stool sits at the foot of the bed.

Home in Columbus

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 126 reviews

Cap City Cozy

Top guest favorite

Home in Columbus

5 out of 5 average rating, 92 reviews

The Carriage House at The Circus House

Top guest favorite

The exterior of the Pink Opal home features a vibrant pink facade contrasted by turquoise trim. Large windows allow natural light to flood the interior, while a landscaped rock garden accents the front yard. Lush greenery surrounds the property, providing a serene atmosphere.

Home in Columbus

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 44 reviews

Pink Opal MCM

A spacious dining area is presented with a large wooden table surrounded by eight wooden chairs. A modern light fixture adorns the ceiling, while wall-mounted shelves display various small plants and decorative items, enhancing the inviting environment.

Home in Columbus

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 496 reviews

Livingston Hideaway - Off Street Parking, 3 BR

Top guest favorite

A modern kitchen and dining area is featured, with a large island at its center surrounded by high stools. Two comfortable chairs are positioned by a window adorned with floral curtains, while a light-colored area rug complements the warm wooden flooring.

Home in Westerville

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 55 reviews

Lincoln House

Top guest favorite

An arched entryway leads into a charming dining nook featuring a round table surrounded by two black wicker chairs. Bright windows provide natural light, and a decorative shelf displays a few items. Soft wooden flooring adds warmth to the space.

Home in Columbus

5 out of 5 average rating, 50 reviews

The Little House - a 1910 cottage

Private house rentals

Top guest favorite

A modern kitchen is equipped with dark wooden cabinetry and black appliances, including a refrigerator and microwave. A small dining table stands in the center, accompanied by two stools. Warm wood flooring enhances the inviting atmosphere.

Home in Westerville

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 88 reviews

Ellie's Place

The vintage farmhouse is set on a grassy lawn surrounded by mature trees, featuring a welcoming porch and a sloped roof. Warm light emanates from the windows, creating an inviting atmosphere as twilight descends. A serene backdrop of lush greenery enhances the overall charm of the property.

Home in Lewis Center

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 21 reviews

Modern style farmhouse, huge backyard, pond & barn

A newly constructed multi-level residence features a modern exterior with a dark green facade and wooden accents. Large windows allow ample natural light, while a welcoming staircase leads to the entrance. A well-maintained lawn is present, accentuated by landscaping along the pathway.

Home in Columbus

4.67 out of 5 average rating, 3 reviews

New Build Hot Tub Dtown ShortNorth

Top guest favorite

A historic home is framed by lush greenery and colorful plants, offering a welcoming entrance. The porch features a black railing and steps leading to the front door. The brick pathway is bordered by manicured hedges, enhancing the home's charming exterior.

Home in Columbus

5 out of 5 average rating, 87 reviews

German Village Serenity, Steps to Schiller Park

Top guest favorite

The living room features two comfortable chairs positioned near a decorative fireplace with a white mantel. A 55” Smart TV is mounted above the fireplace, showcasing a beach landscape. A round coffee table sits in front, complemented by a patterned area rug.

Home in Columbus

5 out of 5 average rating, 86 reviews

Hot Tub, King Beds, Foosball, Firepit, Cornhole

Home in Columbus

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 59 reviews

Urban Stay w/Game Room | 15 Min to OSU Stadium

Top guest favorite

A contemporary living area with a vaulted ceiling showcases a striking black feature wall housing shelves filled with art objects and books. A sleek black chair is positioned next to a stylish coffee table, while a warm wooden side table complements the space. Soft lighting enhances the inviting atmosphere.

Home in Columbus

5 out of 5 average rating, 13 reviews

Curated German Village Retreat

An open living area includes a generous blue sectional sofa adorned with decorative cushions and an orange accent chair. A sleek glass dining table surrounded by plush blue and gray chairs offers a stylish space for meals. Modern lighting and light-toned walls highlight the area.

Home in Columbus

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 39 reviews

Luxury Stay Near Easton, Airport & OSU

Destinations to explore