Vacation rentals in Sutton Lake

Fun Mothman Themed House w/ Whole House Escape Rm

Come explore this Mothman themed AirBnb and solve the whole house escape room! (You're never locked in, it's just a bunch of puzzles!) Upstairs is creepy, funny, and cozy all at the same time. Downstairs is Mothman Cave with air hockey, PS5, T2 arcade game, and more! Outside has a nice fire pit with swings and a hammock under the deck. We'd rate it PG for scariness, so 5-10 year olds might get nervous unless they dig scary movies. It's ~1 mile of Fayetteville and the New River Gorge Bridge.

Historic Secluded Log Cabin near Snowshoe Mountain

Bushwhacker Cabin offers a rare combination of historic authenticity and elevated comfort. This restored pre–Civil War log cabin delivers privacy, acreage, and mountain views, amenities typically reserved for high-end mountain estates. The Viking chef’s kitchen, private hot tub, forest setting, and proximity to Snowshoe and the Greenbrier make this an ideal retreat for travelers who value space, serenity, and understated luxury. This is not just a cabin stay —it’s a private mountain experience.

Hot Tub • Sunset Views • Near NRG

Welcome to Sunset Ridge, located in the heart of the Gauley River National Recreation Area, just 3 miles from Summersville Lake and minutes from world-class whitewater rafting, rock climbing, hiking, and swimming. Fayetteville and the New River Gorge National Park are only 15 minutes away. After a day of adventure, unwind at the fire pit with sweeping sunset views or soak in the hot tub as the sun dips behind the mountains. Endless outdoor experiences by day, unforgettable sunsets by night.

Bend of River Cabin In Hacker Valley West Virginia

This two bedroom cabin sits on the bank of the Little Kanawha River. Kick back on the covered front porch or build a fire in the nearby fire ring. The cabin also has a fireplace for chillier days and nights. Enjoy the abundant natural resources offering exceptional fishing and hunting. Explore the pristine beauty of the area with excellent access to horse trails, four-wheeler trails, hiking and biking. Or - simply kick back and read a book. Cabin is 5 miles from Holly River State Park.

Mystic Pond Cabin-Dark History!

👻Tiny house/big personality! Stay on our 350 acre farm where Bigfoot sightings & dark history have occurred. Intriqued by the paranormal? We provide ghosthunting gear for your visit. Cozy, custom cabin is nestled privately under old trees in a mountain valley on a reclaimed coal mine site. 30 mins to New River Gorge NATIONAL Park. 20 mins to WV Bigfoot museum. 10 mins to Summersville Lake. 5 mins to Winery & Distillery. 40 mins to TALA. Or, walk our farm trails, relax & stargaze.

Studio apartment on the Buckhannon River

Welcome to your private studio apartment located along "Country Roads" near Sago, WV on the scenic Buckhannon River. We are just 5 miles from Buckhannon, WV and WV Wesleyan University. Nearby recreational areas include Stonecoal Lake and Stonewall Jackson Lake. This property is our only property listed on airbnb. There is no management company, no outside cleaning company, no cleaning fee. When you contact us through airbnb you are speaking to the owners, not a management company.

Loggers Cabin With a Hot Tub (Top Only)

The Loggers Cabin is just that, owned by a local Logger. Recently restored & Hand Crafted with timber right off this very property. This is a 150 AC farm & bird hunting preserve. Relax in the hot tub, hike, Bring your ATV’s/UTV’s - ride for miles down local backroads. Plenty of space to park your boat or trailer. Public lands nearby offer fishing, hunting, hiking, kayaking, etc. 20 minutes from the popular Stonewall Resort. (NO WIFI, AT&T & Some other providers do have service

The Gauley River Treehouse

Enjoy your time in the trees! Hear the white water rapids of the Gauley from our front deck as you take in the scenic views of the forest. Truly, a one of a kind experience. Our treehouse is located in Boulder Trail, which is on over 100 acres of private land. It also includes a common area with a covered shelter, with an outdoor Fireplace that’s a short walk away. We are located 5 minutes from Summersville Lake and 15 minutes from New River Gorge National Park!

Foxtail Retreat

***brand new hot tub*** A little two bedroom wooden cabin. Enjoy a crisp, cool morning with a cup of coffee. Enjoy the views of color changing mountains. Warm up in the hot tub under the stars. Have a nice warm cup of apple cider by the bonfire overlooking the mountains. Bring your atv and enjoy adventure riding in the back country of Wirt county. After a long day, cuddle up on the couch and watch a move in front of the fireplace. 4wd required a steep driveway.

Lambert’s Winery “Hang-over” Treehouse

This playful treehouse cabin provides amazing views with a cantilevered design and large windows overlooking the grounds of Lambert's Winery. Taste, tour and explore the winery grounds in this playful & unforgettable loft! The "Hang-over" is one of three rental cabins on the property and features a spiral tree staircase built from naturally resourced materials on the winery grounds, a loft bedroom, covered outdoor space, interior swings and amazing views!

Gorgeous Guesthouse at Five Springs Farm

This charming farmhouse is the perfect retreat from which to stage your New River Gorge adventure. Built in 1860, this newly renovated farmhouse sits on a 171 acre working farm with stunning views. This is the only farm stay on a working farm in the Fayetteville area, is 10 minutes to town, and very close to all the area's amenities. It offers a quiet peaceful retreat to unwind and relax at the end of your busy day!

Whitewater Chalet: A-Frame on a Mountain Farm

Enjoy the mountain breeze in this rustic and cozy A-Frame chalet. Hike through the woods, cozy up to an outdoor fire, or just relax on the porch and listen to the sounds of nature. The chalet is conveniently located one mile from Summersville Lake (Battle Run Recreation Area), 22-miles from the New River Gorge National Park, and four miles from the Upper Gauley River rafting and kayaking put-in.