Vacation rentals in New Haven

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in New Haven

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1
Top guest favorite
The front view of the Federal-style house features white siding with black shutters and a welcoming entryway. A sign displaying 'Muckley House' is positioned in the well-maintained lawn, complemented by neatly trimmed shrubs and pathway lighting.
Home in Eldorado
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 107 reviews

The Muckley House- Vintage 1917 Landmark

You will be enjoying a 1917 Federal Style House that has been completely renovated. Your reservation includes the whole house. Price is 129.00 a night for 2 guests and 45.00 a night for each additional guest. Located within walking distance to sister Airbnbs, "The Choisser Burnett House" and "The Paddock". There are 2 twin beds and a 1/2 bath downstairs.Great outdoor courtyard. Perfect for entertaining. Reach out if you are planning a small event and we will be happy to provide you with pricing.

Guest favorite
An aerial view captures a serene swimming pool surrounded by a spacious patio. A separate guest house is visible near the pool, featuring a sloped roof and multiple windows. Lush landscaping offers privacy, while a clear pathway leads from the pool area to the nearby road.
Guesthouse in Evansville
4.87 out of 5 average rating, 238 reviews

Private Guest House close to everything!

The Private Guest House is set on our property which is located on a corner (1.5 acre lot) close to the east side of Evansville. The convenient large circle drive makes it easy to enter and exit. The east side of Evansville offers Malls, Shopping, Restaurants, Bars, Entertainment, Gyms, Starbucks, and Theaters. The property is located only 10 minutes from Downtown and the Ford Center due to close proximity to Lloyd Expressway. Check out the Casino and Riverfront if you’re in the Downtown Area!

Top guest favorite
Cottage in Eddyville
4.93 out of 5 average rating, 165 reviews

Cozy one bedroom cottage on a horse farm

This special space is in the middle of the Shawnee National Forest, just a short drive to beautiful hiking, waterfalls, rock climbing, kayaking, and equestrian trails. -Guided horseback rides to Shawnee trails available through host, Sue -Corrals available for own horses -Sleeps 4-queen bed and pull out sofa -Washer and dryer -Fiber Optic WiFi -Gas grill, outdoor seating, large fire pit, and free firewood on site -Garden of the Gods, Jackson Falls, Bell Smith Springs Burden Falls nearby

Top guest favorite
A charming carriage house features textured red siding and a spacious driveway. Lush flower gardens with colorful blooms line the front, complemented by well-maintained landscaping. A single-car garage is visible, showcasing a clean and inviting exterior that blends harmoniously with the surroundings.
Home in New Harmony
5 out of 5 average rating, 163 reviews

The Angel Carriage House in New Harmony

Cozy and elegant, located in the heart of historic New Harmony, this 1920's carriage house was reimagined, expanded, and tastefully furnished as a stand-alone guest house in 2016. It includes a fully equipped kitchen, roomy bedroom plus queen-sized sofa bed in the living room, two full baths, hi-speed WIFI, three HD TVs, a private back porch with one of the best views in New Harmony, and heated & A/Ced garage. Relax and recharge, just one or two blocks from the town's key attractions.

Guest favorite
A bright and spacious living area features an orange couch, a neutral ottoman, and a dark leather chair. Two windows provide natural light, while a chandelier with antlers adds a rustic touch. A television is mounted on the wall above a wooden console.
Tiny home in Harrisburg
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 120 reviews

Tiny Cabin in the Big Woods

Kick back and relax in this calm, stylish space. Enjoy being a few short minutes from Garden of the Gods and the Shawnee National Forest at this gated home. Adventure during the day and enjoy a calm evening at night in this well appointed cabin. This newly finished cabin contains all new furnishings and high end finishes. The kitchen is equipped to cook any meal of your choice. The home features a small loft bedroom. Prefer not to climb the ladder? A queen size air mattress is included

Top guest favorite
A serene lakeside view captures a quaint cabin reflected in calm waters. Lush green grass surrounds the water's edge, while trees frame the background under a blue sky dotted with clouds.
Cabin in Dixon
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 314 reviews

Crouse’s North Ninety Lake House

If you want a place where you can be socially distanced, this is the place! (discounts for weekly or monthly stays.) The cabin is set in a 90 acre area surrounded by woods with two small lakes (fishing, walking trails and paddle boating available at no extra charge). There is only one other cabin on the 90 acres. Nearest town, Dixon (3 miles), Madisonville (20 miles, Henderson 21 miles), Evansville, IN (has a regional airport about 35 miles). Truly a relaxing getaway place.

Top guest favorite
Dome in Stonefort
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 104 reviews

Modern Dome in Shawnee Forest with Hot Tub

Old Colorado Glamping Dome is nestled deep into the woods surrounded by beautiful tall pines. It is heated and cooled and has all the necessities as a typical house. We also packed as many amenities as we could into this property including an oversized 6-Person hot tub, 500 MBPS fiber internet, outdoor tv, fire pit table, Weber grill, hammock swings, custom bathroom with rainfall shower, full kitchen, coffee bar, king & queen sized beds, bean bag toss, board games and much more!

Top guest favorite
The front of the cottage features a welcoming dark blue exterior with a bright red door, flanked by well-maintained gardens. Potted plants and colorful flowers enhance the entrance, providing a charming first impression. A small walkway leads to the door, completing the inviting atmosphere.
Cottage in New Harmony
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 422 reviews

New Harmony Cottage

Open concept cottage w lots of space for one or two located in the Historic District of New Harmony. Free street parking, a sitting area and comfortable queen bed. Washer/Dryer and a small kitchenette (no stove or cooktop.) WiFi and and a Smart TV for your convenience. Bring your Netflix or Hulu passwords. Be our guest in your own space. Easy no contact checkin & checkout. Coffee/Tea bar or Black Lodge Coffee! *FYI check hours for shops & restaurants that you plan on visiting.

Top guest favorite
The front exterior of the vibrant yellow cottage is framed by a white picket fence. A welcoming red door is centered beneath the front porch, which is supported by white columns. Lush green grass lays in the yard, with two hanging planters on either side of the door.
Cottage in New Harmony
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 108 reviews

Honeycomb Hideaway

Welcome to Honeycomb Hideaway, a vibrant yellow cottage nestled in the heart of historic New Harmony, Indiana. Our cozy one-bedroom retreat offers a peaceful and exciting escape, just steps away from Murphy Park, fantastic restaurants, and captivating tourist activities. Immerse yourself in New Harmony's rich heritage, exploring charming streets, unique shops, and art galleries. Indulge in local cuisine or embark on outdoor adventures in parks and walking trails.

Guest favorite
A historic brick building stands on a cobblestone street, framed by mature trees and shrubs. The entrance features a set of stairs leading to double doors adorned with decorative glass. A lamppost adds charm to the inviting outdoor space.
Apartment in Evansville
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 233 reviews

Victorian 1 Bedroom Guesthouse Apt on 1st Street

This one-bedroom / one-bathroom apartment features high ceilings and exposed brick and is attached to your host’s home - a Victorian townhouse on one of Evansville’s historic cobblestone streets. Enjoy easy self-check-in and a location that is centrally located near the Ohio River, Downtown Evansville, and Haynie’s Corner neighborhoods. The Ford Center, Bally’s Casino, and many of Evansville’s best restaurants and bars are all a short walk away.

Guest favorite
A white single-story house is framed by lush green landscaping. Two windows with gray shutters are visible on either side of the front door, which is painted in teal. A pathway leads to the entrance, surrounded by tall grass and leafy plants.
Apartment in Evansville
4.78 out of 5 average rating, 345 reviews

Best Value/Sleeps 4/ Cozy/Center Town /Pets ok!

This is a private unit, but There is a GUEST SUITE attached to this listing (also available on Air BNB.) However, there are NO shared spaces. Each listing has a separate entrance. Near shopping, restaurants. 1Bedroom-2 queen beds-1bath cable/wifi, stocked wi/ snacks & amenities. Key lock box entry, Washer/Dryer. Couch folds down with a pull out feature on the base see pics or contact us to operate.

Guest favorite
A cozy living area features a light-colored sectional sofa facing a round coffee table. The space is adorned with wooden ceiling panels and warm brown walls. A staircase at the back leads to additional levels, while a small kitchenette is visible in the background.
Guesthouse in Carmi
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 100 reviews

The Main St Carriage House - a charming cottage

This is a charming 1 bedroom 1.5 bath cottage located in the heart of Carmi. Enjoy the fully stocked kitchen, dining table for 4, high speed Wi-Fi, two smart TVs, 1 queen bed upstairs with a half bath, with a full Bath on the main floor, and a private parking spot. We also have a 25amp Level 2 charger available upon request for anyone needing to charge their EV while they stay!

Popular amenities for New Haven vacation rentals

  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. Illinois
  4. Gallatin County
  5. New Haven