
Vacation rentals in New Haven
Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb
Top-rated vacation rentals in New Haven
Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

The O'Neal Homestead
Welcome to our lovingly renovated family home. This 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom house was originally built by my parents. It has been thoughtfully updated for a comfortable stay. You will find a kitchen and dining area that’s perfect for cooking,sharing meals or gathering over coffee. The kitchen is stocked with everything you need for a comfortable stay . Bedrooms designed to feel cozy. fresh linens, cooling blanket and unique touches. Bathrooms 1 with tub 2nd one with shower, washer and dryer

Premium Stay - 9 miles from Garden of The Gods
Welcome to our ultra-private, 9-acre hideaway located on a hill between Garden of The Gods and Highway 13. Overlooking the peaks of Shawnee National Forest near Garden of the Gods, Cave-in-Rock, and the most popular hikes, Equality Hill House is truly the best base to experience Southern Illinois. Explore all day, then come home to endless views of Shawnee National Forest. Host Guidebook of Top Attractions, Restaurants, and Directions provided when you book. Born & raised here, Your Hosts

Blackberry Hill—Welcome Hunters, Hikers, Bikers
Nestled on a wooded hill on the eastern edge of the Shawneetown National Forest, this fully furnished four bedroom/three bathroom home offers a wonderfully quiet space to unwind and disconnect. This is a great spot for hunters, hikers, and bikers, as it’s within a short driving distance of the Shawnee National Forest’s most popular attractions. If seclusion and privacy are what you’re looking for, this is the spot! The area also has plenty of options for food, exploring, and shopping.

Spurlock Place- Shawnee National Forest (HOT TUB)
Hike, explore, work, or relax on our 2 country acres. Just 15 minutes from the Garden of the Gods, our home features a game room, high speed Internet, and plenty of space to spread out and enjoy nature. There’s a large gas station and DG store 1/2 mile away for anything you need, and Harrisburg is just a short drive further. If you’re looking to explore or hunt in the Shawnee National Forest, this is the perfect place to be! Guests have full access to the home, hot tub and all amenities.

Choisser Burnett House - Vintage Charm & Comfort
The historic Choisser Burnett House is located at 1201 Organ Street in Eldorado, Illinois. A revival style home built in the 1880's, it was home to several prominent families who were responsible for business development in the area. Twenty minutes minutes south is the Shawnee National Forest whose terrain spans woodlands, hills and lakes and it's wildlife includes bald eagles. There is a sister house across the street, The Paddock at 1208 which sleeps 6 and is also on Airbnb.com.

Crouse’s North Ninety Lake House
If you want a place where you can be socially distanced, this is the place! (discounts for weekly or monthly stays.) The cabin is set in a 90 acre area surrounded by woods with two small lakes (fishing, walking trails and paddle boating available at no extra charge). There is only one other cabin on the 90 acres. Nearest town, Dixon (3 miles), Madisonville (20 miles, Henderson 21 miles), Evansville, IN (has a regional airport about 35 miles). Truly a relaxing getaway place.

Modern Dome in Shawnee Forest with Hot Tub
Old Colorado Glamping Dome is nestled deep into the woods surrounded by beautiful tall pines. It is heated and cooled and has all the necessities as a typical house. We also packed as many amenities as we could into this property including an oversized 6-Person hot tub, 500 MBPS fiber internet, outdoor tv, fire pit table, Weber grill, hammock swings, custom bathroom with rainfall shower, full kitchen, coffee bar, king & queen sized beds, bean bag toss, board games and much more!

The Creekside by Davis Properties MTV
Welcome to The Creekside by Davis Properties MTV! A comfortable and convenient apartment in Mount Vernon, IN. You'll enjoy reliable wi-fi, a fully equipped kitchen, self check in, TV in each room, off street free parking with plenty of room for a bigger vehicle or trailer. Whether you're working at one of the local plants, attending a family gathering or simply here for a relaxing getaway, The Creekside offers a clean, welcoming place to call home! Come Stay With Us!!

The Geneva Cabin
The Geneva Cabin is one of a kind (not in the woods) and has everything you need to enjoy whatever occasion brings you to the area. Located less than 2 miles from the wildlife refuge, 10 min to downtown Henderson, 7 mi to I-69 the property sits in the middle of a quiet dead-end street. Right in the middle of anywhere anyway your journey takes you. 55” TV, sofa bed and recliner in living room, WIFI, washer & dryer. Fully equipped kitchen. Large parking area.

The Harmony Inn
Welcome to The HARMONY INN,owned and hosted by Jane and Tom Harmon. I am a retired teacher. My husband ,Tom Harmon, is a retired real estate broker/ appraiser. We have been been married and lived in Shawneetown for the past 50 years. We saw a need in our little town for a stylish, comfortable home to accommodate guests for weddings, funerals and other special events. We also welcome seasonal employees along with hunters looking for a local mancave.

The Main St Carriage House - a charming cottage
This is a charming 1 bedroom 1.5 bath cottage located in the heart of Carmi. Enjoy the fully stocked kitchen, dining table for 4, high speed Wi-Fi, two smart TVs, 1 queen bed upstairs with a half bath, with a full Bath on the main floor, and a private parking spot. We also have a 25amp Level 2 charger available upon request for anyone needing to charge their EV while they stay!

JACS COUNTRY CABINS SHAWNEE 2
COZY 1 BEDROOM, 1 BATH CABIN AT THE EDGE OF THE SHAWNEE NATIONAL FOREST. LOCATED 10 MILES FROM GARDEN OF THE GODS AND & 1 MILE FROM GLENN O JONES LAKE. IT SITS BEHIND JACS PLACE (A BAR/CONVENIENCE STORE) AND 2 MILES FROM A LAUNDRY MAT IN EQUALITY. WE PROVIDE COFFEE BUT THE CLOSEST GROCERY STORE IS ROUGHLY 10 MINS AWAY IN ELDORADO, SO PLAN, PACK SNACKS/FOOD ACCORDINGLY.
Popular amenities for New Haven vacation rentals
Other great vacation rentals in New Haven

Spacious Country Home | Pool Table | Sleeps 11

Welcome to The Farm

Cozy Garden Home in New Harmony for 6

Hunters Haven

Shawnee Hideaway

The Yellow House

Kennedy's Place

Secluded Shawnee Forest Cabin Creek View | Hot tub
Destinations to explore
- Nashville Vacation rentals
- Chicago Vacation rentals
- Gatlinburg Vacation rentals
- Indianapolis Vacation rentals
- Pigeon Forge Vacation rentals
- St. Louis Vacation rentals
- Louisville Vacation rentals
- Cincinnati Vacation rentals
- Memphis Vacation rentals
- Branson Vacation rentals
- Chattanooga Vacation rentals
- Knoxville Vacation rentals





