Vacation rentals in Mayville

The Pike Lake Cottage House

Welcome to the Pike Lake House located Hartford WI with direct lake access to Pike Lake. Enjoy watching the sunrise, swimming, fishing and lazy days at our historic cottage that comfortly sleeps up to 6 guests. The Pike Lake House features a lakeside patio with table, charcoal grill, pier, campfire pit and gorgeous lake views right from our relaxing panoramic sun room. Local kayak, paddle board, paddle boat, canoe boat rental available. Make memories and enjoy lake life on beautiful Pike Lake.

Modern Lake Home: Family Fun & Memorable Getaway!

This newly renovated, private lakefront retreat on Beaver Dam Lake, just 45min from the Madison and 1hr Milwaukee airports! This spacious 4 bedroom, 2 bath home features a high-end kitchen, large living / dining area w/ fireplace, perfect for entertaining, and a large yard with 100 feet of lake frontage. Relax on your private dock, ideal for fishing or docking your boat. Nestled at the end of a quiet cul-de-sac, this home offers a peaceful stay. *No loud parties; respect for neighbors required*

The Cozy Country Farmhouse, Eisenbahn Suite

This 1865 COZY COUNRY FARMHOUSE is set only 1 mile out of Kewaskum. You get the best of both worlds county and a small town. There are 2 SUITES available. 1. The EISENBAUN SUITE is an apartment on the 2nd floor that is equipped with a laundry room and full kitchen and bathroom. Sleeps 2-4 2. The NEUMANN SUITE is an efficiency apartment with a queen bed, efficiency refrigerator, right next door. Has bath with shower. Sleeps 1-2 Larger groups, I recommend using both. Each has own private entrance.

Green Heron Cottage · King Beds · Horicon Marsh

Charming and cozy, this delightful 3-bedroom cottage sits in the heart of downtown Horicon, just moments from the scenic beauty of the Horicon Marsh with its peaceful trails and relaxing boat tours. Treat yourself to a nostalgic scoop at the beloved Ice Cream Station just two doors away, then unwind back at your private retreat. The backyard invites you to gather under the stars, where a crackling fire pit and grill set the stage for laid-back evenings, laughter, and lasting memories. Cheers!

Local Landmark CF / Artisan Coffeehouse

Wake up to the aroma of fresh coffee, stroll downstairs for breakfast, then spend the afternoon hiking the Kettle Moraine before returning to a luxurious bed. The iconic Coffee Corner Bistro (Est 1999) is steps from the Wisconsin 9/11 Memorial & Eisenbahn Bike Trail, and is the "Gateway to the Kettle Moraine" Proudly recognized by the Fond du Lac Reporter Travel Section in its June 13, 2026 feature: "Top Airbnb Stays Near Fond du Lac" Google CBS 58 story on our historical Coffeehouse.

Gorgeous Lakefront Retreat with Waterside Bar Area

Make all of those special memories at this beautifully updated lakeside retreat on stunning Lake Sinissippi. Relax around the fire, take a dip in the lake, or take in the breathtaking sunsets from our little "Sunset Shack." If watersports are more your speed, take out a couple of kayaks and explore Lake Sinissippi - a 2800 acre full rec lake! Ready to head inside? There is a large farmhouse table with seating for at least 10 and a family room on each level to wind down for the evening.

Beautifully Updated Lake House

Come relax in this beautiful lakefront home, fully renovated in 2025. A lawn leads to 110 feet of private lake access with a dock on Beaver Dam Lake. Fire pit with seating and complimentary firewood to enhance your outdoor experience. The main living area is open-concept, with the kitchen leading into a dining and living room. The upstairs and downstairs living room has gas fireplace. The home offers five bedrooms, including two with king-sized beds, and accommodates up to 14 guests.

Dogs Stay Free! Lakefront Bungalow with Dock

Corsa's Pillowfort — a waterfront bungalow on the 2,800-acre Lake Sinissippi in Dodge County, minutes from the famous Horicon Marsh and less than an hour from Madison or Milwaukee. Sleeps 3 with a king bed plus sofa bed, eat-in kitchen, and full bath. Private dock and 2 kayaks (summer season) right outside your door. Pet friendly with no pet fees — bring your dog along! At 600 sq. ft., it's the perfect lakeside getaway for couples, small families, or solo travelers looking to unplug.

hot tub and sauna on 5 private acres

Looking for a peaceful retreat? Experience 5 acres of tranquil, private woodland paradise. Cool nights are perfect for warming up in the hot tub or infrared sauna which overlook the meadow. Explore hiking trails and lakes that the scenic Kettle Moraine has to offer. Grill a delicious meal and later craft perfect s’mores by campfire as the crickets sing. Unwind at SoLu winery, just a minute down the road. Near Road America, Kettle Moraine State Forest, and Dundee. Your getaway awaits!

Firefly Cabin, a Unique Tranquil Space

Get ready for a relaxing getaway with your friends and family. Firefly Cabin has a lakehouse feel with all the comforts of home. This charming Cabin is only an hour drive from Milwaukee or Madison. It is the sister Cabin to Serenity Cottage, rent one or both! Please note Firefly Cabin does have stairs to main living area and areas of lower ceilings. This relaxing retreat won't disappoint and is a great option for a remote workers or a quick getaway from the city.

Countryside Ranch Home

Quiet Country Life. NO WIFI. Take a stroll down the lane, hike through the woods watch the wildlife on the ponds. 30 minute drive to AirVenture in Oshkosh. Just a short drive to Horicon Marsh, Hoffs Meat Market, Wild Wings Bird Hunts, Horicon Ledge Hiking and so much more all with the small town feel. 1890’s stone “house” on property with the original farm barn and grainery. In addition to this home there is a Hunting lodge also located on property separate AirBNB

Marsh Haven by Fieldview Estates

One of the few remaining private properties left on the edge of the Horicon Marsh, Marsh Haven provides a stunning view, great bird watching, and easy access to public hunting land, bike and hiking trails, and more. Stay in a spacious farmhouse for fun and relaxation. *Please be aware this home has hard surfaces and steep stairs that may not be suitable for children under 4 years of age* Private land is not available for hunting, please use public land nearby.