Vacation rentals in Fairy Island

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Fairy Island

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1
Guest favorite
A welcoming living area is presented, featuring a spacious black sectional sofa and a cozy round chair. Natural light floods in through sliding glass doors, leading to an outside view. A subtle decor with plants and a table lamp adds to the inviting ambiance.
Home in Lake Geneva
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 157 reviews

Lake Geneva cottage with private beach access

This cute cottage for 6 is located just down the street from beautiful Lake Como that offers fishing, boating, and water sports. It is also just a short drive to Lake Geneva and all that it has to offer with its beautiful lake, shopping, historic buildings, and delicious restaurants. Along with the house you get access to the HOA covered private beaches and playgrounds nearby. There is also a bar and grill down the street with live music. Bring your family or your friends and welcome to my home.

Guest favorite
A wooden dock extends toward a calm lake, featuring a covered boat and a sunbathing area with a chair. A yellow floating mat lies nearby, and the water reflects the surrounding greenery. Swimmers can be seen enjoying the gentle waves in the distance.
Home in Mukwonago
4.93 out of 5 average rating, 14 reviews

Lake House Retreat on Phantom Lake

A cozy secluded retreat like being "up North" without having to go up North. Quiet private road, and quiet lake. Great swimming and fishing off the dock in this sandy bottom lake with clean spring fed water, and large grassy area for lawn games and relaxing. Great for families, ladies retreats, golf groups, or concert goers. Only 5 mins to grocery stores. Lots of space in the house, and lots of space for spending time outside on the deck or the dock or lawn by the lake. Feel free to inquire!

Top guest favorite
A historic home features a multi-gabled roof and intricate architectural details. The exterior showcases a blend of light and dark hues, complemented by well-maintained landscaping and a spacious lawn. A charming porch wraps around the front, providing an inviting entrance with rocking chairs nestled on one side.
Home in Wales
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 189 reviews

Beautifully Restored Historic Victorian

Whether this is for a single, couple, or small group, your stay at this historic home will truly be memorable. You’ll love the MBR suite featuring a gas fireplace, whirlpool tub, and double walk-in custom tile shower. There is an additional very nice full bath/shower on the main floor. The finished lower level has two separate rooms, each with a quality double futon with bedding available for your guests. For this attractive price, the upper 4 bedrooms are locked but may be opened for more

Top guest favorite
Home in Elkhorn
5 out of 5 average rating, 9 reviews

Farmhouse with Heated Pool on almost 160 Acres!

Set on almost 160 acres of rolling farmland, this unique retreat in Elkhorn, Wisconsin offers an immersive experience on a working regenerative farm in progress, where you can wake up to the sounds of farm animals and take in the peaceful countryside. Just a short drive away, you’ll find Lake Geneva’s stunning waterfront, quaint downtown shops, and outdoor adventures like hiking, boating, and local wineries, making Big Foot Valley Farmhouse an ideal destination for relaxation and exploration.

Top guest favorite
Adirondack chairs are arranged around a crushed stone fire pit, overlooking a serene lake at sunrise. The warm orange glow of the sun reflects on the water's surface, surrounded by a misty atmosphere and silhouetted trees.
Cottage in Mukwonago
5 out of 5 average rating, 50 reviews

Charming Phantom Lake Cottage

Come relax at our cottage located directly on Phantom Lake and not a channel. This 2 bedroom, 2 bath, plus sleeping loft area home is comfortably furnished and a perfect space to enjoy all lake life offers year round. Free public boat launch located nearby with our private pier/dock and anchored swim raft available for use on a seasonal basis along with multiple kayaks and paddle boat on site. Attached composite deck and crushed stone fire pit area are perfect spots to enjoy the outdoors.

Guest favorite
An A-frame structure is nestled among lush green trees, showcasing large glass windows that allow for ample natural light. The contrasting wood siding complements the surrounding foliage, creating a harmonious blend with nature. A raised deck leads to the entrance, enhancing accessibility to the home.
Cabin in Fontana-on-Geneva Lake
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 156 reviews

Exquisite Modern A-frame all WithInnReach

An amazing space that truly caters to the guest experience. We've built this art piece to have our guests immerse themselves in all the amenities, from heated floors to in-ceiling speakers - all whilst losing yourself in the wood burning fireplace. At WithInnReach the attention to detail was paramount - with an emphasis of what we enjoy...amazing food through a well balanced kitchen, beautiful sound through Klipsch speakers and relaxation with floor to ceiling showers...enjoy to the fullest.

Guest favorite
An expansive wooden deck offers a welcoming outdoor space, featuring a dining table surrounded by chairs and a cozy rattan chair. A large umbrella stands in one corner, while lush greenery and blue skies create a serene backdrop.
Cabin in Elkhorn
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 309 reviews

The Retreat: 5 Acre Log Cabin

Escape to this beautiful 5-acre country retreat, located a short drive from Lauderdale Lakes, Alpine Valley, and Lake Geneva. The cabin features two kitchens, two family rooms, a year around outdoor hot tub, a game room, and five bedrooms with comfortable king-sized beds. The master suite also includes a steam room for added luxury. Spend your days enjoying the great outdoors with a game of beach volleyball or roasting marshmallows around a bonfire, while taking in the fresh midwestern air.

Top guest favorite
A living area features a stone fireplace and large windows providing views of Lake Beulah. Comfortable seating surrounds a wooden coffee table. A dining table is visible, alongside decor elements that create a cozy ambiance. Natural light floods the space, enhancing the connection to the outdoors.
Home in East Troy
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 118 reviews

Lakeside Getaway

Relax with the whole family at this peaceful, home on Lake Beulah. With the gorgeous lake and surrounding nature, you will feel you are hours up North, minus the long commute! Wake up and enjoy coffee on the deck. Bring your boat or grab a floaty and soak up the sun as you spend the day on the water. Wind down while you watch a stunning sunset from your own pier. Enjoy a show at the nearby Alpine Valley. Countless memories are just waiting to be made. Come play hard and relax even harder

Top guest favorite
An outdoor fire pit surrounded by wooden benches and chairs is visible in a spacious green area. The cabin in the background features a red exterior and large windows framed by trees, offering a serene spot for gathering.
Home in Elkhorn
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 163 reviews

Fall Specials at the Red Lodge-Game Room, Hot Tub!

Conveniently located amidst Southeast Wisconsin's best attractions, The Red Lodge is a contemporary-styled retreat that offers the space and family-friendly amenities to keep everyone entertained for hours. Enjoy an 👾 room, a secondary game room, hot tub, fire 🔥 pit, BBQ area, and more! Rent a boat right in the neighborhood at Lauderdale Lakes. Bike and hike Kettle Moraine State Forest. Visit Lake Geneva for golfing and shopping-a quick 20-25 min drive. Alpine Valley is minutes away!

Top guest favorite
A tranquil outdoor area features a wooden deck with comfortable seating and a small table. Lush greenery surrounds the space, leading to a serene lake visible in the background under a clear blue sky. A canoe rests on the shore near the water's edge.
Cottage in Burlington
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 82 reviews

The Butterfly Cottage

Your Fall get-away is perfect at The Butterfly Cottage on Honey Lake! Relax and enjoy the serenity of the lake and all the natural beauty of the season! This is a cozy cottage on Honey Lake, just 4 miles from downtown Burlington and 13 miles from Lake Geneva. Alpine Valley for concerts, fishing on Honey Lake or nearby Browns Lake as well as shopping in Lake Geneva are the highlights of the season! There are hiking/walking trails all around as well as rustic roads to explore.

Top guest favorite
The cottage features a charming facade with a combination of blue siding and stonework. Two sets of double doors are framed by large windows, allowing natural light to fill the entrance. Flower beds line the pathway leading to the front door, enhancing the welcoming appearance.
Home in Elkhorn
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 143 reviews

Cozy Country Cottage near Lake Geneva, WI

Our Cozy Cottage features 3 comfortable bedrooms and nightly magnificent sunsets. Nestled on a country road, the house offers plenty of space to rest after visiting Lake Geneva, Lauderdale lakes, biking at Kettle Moraine or site seeing in the area. It’s close to Walworth County fair grounds where the flea market, Das Fest and Rib Fest are held. This is country living with plenty of opportunity to enjoy the beautiful outdoors or the peace and quiet of the countryside.

Top guest favorite
The A-frame cabin is set amidst tall trees at dusk, featuring a spacious deck with railing and soft lighting. The vibrant red exterior contrasts with the natural surroundings, while large windows highlight the interior ambiance. A gravel path leads up to the entrance.
Cabin in Lake Geneva
5 out of 5 average rating, 34 reviews

A-Frame Retreat w/ Hot Tub, Sauna & Cold Plunge

Tucked in the woods near Lake Geneva, The Cozy Cardinal is a dreamy A-frame retreat with a hot tub, panoramic sauna, cold plunge, fire pit, and private forest trail. Watch birds and wildlife from the deck—this is a Certified Wildlife Habitat! Cozy up by the fireplace, sway in hammock swings, or enjoy s’mores under the stars. Dog-friendly and sleeps 4. Just minutes from downtown, hiking, and the lake—yet it feels a world away. Perfect for fall color and snowy escapes.

Popular amenities for Fairy Island vacation rentals

  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. Wisconsin
  4. Walworth County
  5. Troy
  6. Fairy Island