Vacation rentals in Elma

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Elma

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1

Guest favorite

The exterior of a renovated farmhouse from the 1870s is shown, featuring light-colored siding and green trim. A welcoming porch extends across the front, showcasing a sign with the address. Tall trees are visible in the background, contributing to the rural setting.

Apartment in East Aurora

The Farmhouse we call Genevieve

This circa 1870’s Farmhouse has been newly renovated including furnishings furnishes and utilities . The first floor rental space features a private entrance porch overlooking the park like property . Located just one mile from the Village of East Aurora this property features nature trails to the banks of Cazenovia creek . Ideal for family’s with children and also Pet Friendly. The living space is an easy 3 steps up to the private porch . Sleeps up to 5,Nice place to entertain or just relax

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 131 reviews

Top guest favorite

A modern kitchen showcases white cabinetry and a marble countertop. A central island features a wooden countertop with orange stools positioned around it. Stainless steel appliances, including a refrigerator and oven, are visible alongside a mosaic tile backsplash. Natural light fills the space.

Home in Orchard Park

Luxury Village Farmhouse

Welcome to our charming, old (but newly renovated!) Orchard Park Village Farmhouse! Large, but cozy, living and dining spaces and a huge kitchen with all the amenities. We have 2 large bedrooms, each is a "master suite" with bathroom and walk-in closets. In one bedroom, the king bed can be converted to 2 twins, if required. Queen sleeper sofa in living room. We're a short 1/4 mile walk to all the village shops, restaurants and coffee shops. 2 off-street parking spaces, wifi, AC, and laundry.

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 284 reviews

Top guest favorite

Place to stay in East Aurora

Large 2 bed 2 bathroom loft in East Aurora Village

Located in the heart of East Aurora, this 2nd floor loft is perfect and 1 of 1! The entire second floor is yours and there are no other units or shared entrances. It is like 2 spaces in one. 2 bedrooms (king and queen beds), 2 full bathrooms, and 2 living spaces. High end finishes and A+ views overlooking the village. Feels like 2 places in one if you’re traveling with others, you'll have your own space! Perfect for traveling in for a Bills game and walking distance to all things East Aurora!

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 162 reviews

Top guest favorite

A living room is showcased with Buffalo-themed decor, including a large mural of Highmark Stadium. Two sofas are draped with vibrant team blankets, positioned around a small table on a soft area rug under ambient lighting. Windows allow natural light, enhancing the cozy atmosphere.

Home in West Seneca

BuffaLove Family Freindly home w/ games & yard

The BuffaLove house is a tribute to all that is Buffalo. Enjoy our themed living areas complete with Bill's, Sabre's, Bandit's rooms, and a Buffalo Historical master suite. A fenced acre makes entertaining easy with a BBQ, firepit, a basketball court, parking for up to 6 cars, and a wide variety of yard games, as well as various indoor games to keep everyone entertained, even on the coldest Buffalo day. Across from Sunshine Park, which offers trails, a playground, sledding and more :)

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 92 reviews

Top guest favorite

The farmhouse is surrounded by greenery, featuring a large tree in the front yard. The building displays a classic design with a porch, and a sunroom is visible to the right. Lush grass and bushes encircle the house, enhancing its historic character.

Home in East Aurora

Hotel House at Knox

Nestled right outside the village of East Aurora, our historic 4-bedroom, 3-bath farmhouse is ready to accommodate your family and friends. Conveniently located near restaurants, shops and parks as well as only 15 minutes from the Buffalo Bills stadium and 20 minutes from downtown Buffalo. Our property has large communal areas perfect for big meals, game nights and quality time together. We look forward to providing you with a relaxing stay in the Western New York area.

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 29 reviews

Guest favorite

A bridal gown is elegantly displayed on a hanger in a well-lit room. A large vintage mirror reflects the space, which features a cozy seating area with a leather sofa and a decorative circular rug. Natural light filters through sheer curtains, enhancing the inviting ambiance.

Home in Elma Center

Full House Rental with a focus on Wedding Day Prep

Welcome to Blanc Silk! We are a house rental with a focus on Wedding Day Prep. 👰‍♀️ We also welcome Buffalo Bills and Football Fans! 🏈 Approximately 15 mins from the stadium! Our spacious and unique home is perfect for wedding day bridal preparations and Bill games! Our house Includes a bridal suite along with a separate beauty styling lounge. When staying with us, your rental includes, outdoor property, gardens and ground for fabulous photo opportunities.

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 34 reviews

Top guest favorite

The exterior of the timber-frame home is shown, featuring large two-story windows and wood accents. A covered veranda extends from the structure, offering seating. Surrounding greenery and manicured grass enhance the natural setting, inviting a peaceful retreat in the countryside.

Home in East Aurora

Timber-frame home on 12 wooded acres

Featured in Buffalo Spree and Artvoice, this timber-frame home features stunning hickory and black walnut interiors illuminated by two-story windows that face the morning sun. Radiant floor heating and earthen-plaster climate design. Wake up in queen and king beds, lounge under covered verandas, and shop right next door at Thorpe’s organic farm store. • 7 minutes from the Village of East Aurora • 24 minutes from Bills stadium • 1 hour from Niagara Falls

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 137 reviews

Top guest favorite

A friendly Akita is seen standing on a wooden porch, with two front doors visible in the background. Seasonal wreaths adorn the doors, and a potted plant adds a touch of greenery beside a decorative metal stand. A chair and cushion are also present on the porch.

Apartment in Buffalo

Bear’s Den

Quiet three bedroom apartment with new kitchen and all appliances. Off the main roads but still close to Bills Stadium and Downtown Buffalo/Canalside. 30 minutes from Niagara Falls. Lots of parks and nature trails nearby. Large backyard. We have included photos of Bear our Akita, so you will know to expect a large dog on site/in the backyard etc. He loves people and children and loves to say hello. We cannot allow other pets on site because of Bear.

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 108 reviews

Top guest favorite

The studio features an open layout with a cozy seating area including a gray sofa and matching chairs. A dining table accommodates four, and a spacious bed is present in the corner. Natural light filters through the window treatments, highlighting the neutral color scheme.

Guest suite in Lancaster

Work or Play this is your Home Away!

Newly remodeled private studio with private entrance. Lots of parking space. 700sq ft.of living space for you to enjoy! Private balcony overlooking stunning backyard views with a pond. Only 13 min away from Buffalo airport! Shopping centers within a mile. Downtown Buffalo- 20 min. drive Flix Movie Theater- 2 min. drive New Era field- 20 min. drive Niagara Falls- 40min. drive Galleria Mall- 12 min. drive

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 204 reviews

Top guest favorite

A serene outdoor view is presented, featuring a small pond surrounded by lush greenery. A wooden deck extends from the interior, equipped with two seating chairs, while a lantern is placed on a small table. The area invites relaxation amid a tranquil natural setting.

Apartment in East Aurora

Cozy apartment in a wooded country setting

Charming East Aurora Getaway Enjoy a peaceful stay in this private 1-bedroom apartment for 2 guests, located less than 2 miles from the quaint and historic village of East Aurora. Nestled in the woods, this retreat offers full privacy, off-street parking, and a cozy home base for exploring shops, restaurants, and local attractions. Perfect for a relaxing weekend or a quiet escape surrounded by nature.

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 74 reviews

Guest favorite

Apartment in East Aurora

Village Life

Cozy 2-bedroom East Aurora apartment, steps from Bar Bill Tavern, Knox Farm State Park, shops, and Roycroft Campus. Short drive to Highmark Stadium for Bills games. Sleeps 4, with modern kitchen, bathroom, Wi-Fi, smart TV, and laundry. Enjoy village charm, trails, and local eateries. Perfect for families or couples seeking comfort and convenience. Book now for a memorable getaway! *New sofas 2026*

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 58 reviews

Top guest favorite

A charming cottage is set against a vibrant sunset sky, with soft hues illuminating the surrounding trees. The front entrance is framed by a welcoming porch, leading to a grassy area that gradually slopes away from the building.

Cottage in East Aurora

Charming 2 bedroom cottage on the EA golf course

Welcome to The JerBnb! Relax at this quiet and quaint 100 year old 2 bedroom/1 bathroom guest cottage located right on the East Aurora Country Club less than a mile outside of the village. 15 minutes from Bills games. 20 minutes from downtown Buffalo. 20 minutes from skiing. Private off street parking. Self check-in anytime after 3pm. (Sorry. No pets.)

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 236 reviews