Vacation rentals in Conewango

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Conewango

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1

Top guest favorite

A canoe glides across a calm pond, framed by trees showcasing autumn foliage. Two people paddle gently, surrounded by vibrant reflections of fall colors on the water's surface. A clear blue sky enhances the serene atmosphere, inviting exploration of the tranquil landscape.

Home in Randolph

Quiet Convenience

Quiet Convenience 1 mile from I-86 Enjoy the secluded comfort of this rustic retreat close to many area attractions. Nestled in the woods overlooking a large pond with nature at every turn. Enjoy a campfire, fishing, bird watching, snowmobile trails, and skiing. Close to the Amish Trail, and Chautauqua Lake, Allegheny State Park, National Comedy Center, Lucille Ball Museum, Chautauqua Institution, and more! We welcome Sewing/Quilting Retreats, Faith Based Retreats, etc. Come for a visit!

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 266 reviews

Top guest favorite

The exterior of a two-story apartment building is presented, featuring a welcoming front entrance flanked by manicured hedges and colorful flower beds. A pathway leads to the entrance, and a garage is visible in the background, surrounded by a well-maintained lawn.

Apartment in Randolph

The Empty Nest ...2nd floor

Qaintly named "The Empty Nest" ! Comfortable 2 bedroom upper apartment with private entrance and driveway. I gladly welcome well behaved pets (2 pet max) and offer a large partially fenced off backyard ( Tree limb damage). Come visit Randolph for a couple of days or an extended stay. Conveniently located close to Ellicottville, Jamestown and the Chautauqua Lake Region, Seneca Allegany Casino, Allegany State Park and the Amish trail. Popular wedding venues and golf courses right near by as well

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 200 reviews

Top guest favorite

A fire pit is surrounded by a gravel area, with two hanging chairs suspended above. Each chair is adorned with soft cushions, creating a serene spot for relaxation. Soft lighting illuminates the space, enhancing the tranquil outdoor setting at dusk.

Cottage in Conewango Valley

Private Romantic-cottage/cabin-Allegany St Park.

Comfy, cozy, romantic; Modern country cottage/cabin. 1 acre of lawn and wooded area. Seasonal outdoor deck/dinning, fire pit. Nestled amongst a quaint Old Order Amish community . Private secluded driveway. Allegany State park, Amish Shops, Jamestown's National Comedy Center, Lucy Desi Museum, Seneca/Allegany Casino, State land hiking trails, Ellicottville-30min. Public creeks, Lake Erie-Wineries, Chautauqua Institution, Chautauqua Lake. No city lights to obscure night skies. Seasonally decorated

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 207 reviews

Top guest favorite

The cabin's exterior is illuminated at dusk, reflecting beautifully on the calm surface of the pond. Surrounding tall trees offer a natural backdrop, enhancing the serene atmosphere of the retreat.

Home in Gerry

Forest Retreat, 90 miles to Niagara Falls.

Welcome to Forest Retreat! We are nestled in the hills of Western New York, 23 miles to Chautauqua Lake and 14 miles to Lily Dale. This unique home is near several wedding venues and the Earl Cardot Overland Trail, which is surrounded by 2,300 acres of state forest. We are located between 2 local ski resorts, and only 87 miles south of Niagara Falls State park. Relax by the fire, kayak, or fish in the 2 acre pond and just enjoy the scenery. We do require a signed waiver to utilize the pond.

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 130 reviews

Top guest favorite

Farm stay in Cattaraugus

The Guest House at Burdick Blueberries Farm

Share the peaceful beauty of our working family blueberry and flower farm with organic and sustainable practices. Located in East Otto, New York. During the blueberry season experience the joyful bustle of the pick-your-own blueberries and flowers, Mid-July - August. Private guest house attached to farmhouse. Enjoy our patio and spacious lawns plus in-ground pool. Walk along the blueberry bushes, farm roads and woodland trails. Guest space has a simple & natural aesthetic, a relaxing haven.

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 169 reviews

Top guest favorite

A spacious living room features blue carpet and natural light from a skylight. Comfortable seating includes a patterned couch, a rocking chair, and an accent chair. Soft yellow curtains frame the windows. Decorative plants and lamps add warmth, accompanied by a wooden coffee table at the center.

Home in Forestville

The Joy Of Life

This "Joy of Life" is a beautiful hide away on 13 acres of woods, babbling creek + waterfalls, conducive to re-connecting with yourself anyway you prefer. On Fishing and snowmobile trail; centrally located to many attractions inc Lily Dale NY, one of the worlds largest spiritual communities, Lucille Ball Comedy Center & museum, hospitals, Chautauqua Institution, Niagara Falls, Letchworth St Pk, Ski Cockaigne + more. You'll have your own space with as much or as little interaction as u prefer

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 138 reviews

Top guest favorite

The spacious living room features a high timber-vaulted ceiling with exposed beams. A stone gas fireplace serves as a focal point, surrounded by large windows that allow natural light. Two dark leather sofas are arranged for comfort, complemented by a decorative Christmas tree in the corner.

Cottage in Mansfield

Entire Chalet! Hot Tub! Vaulted Timber Ceiling! AC

Nestled 8 minutes from Ellicottville, this 4-bedroom, 4-bath chalet is a 3,600 sq. ft. retreat on 5.7 acres. Relax on the wraparound deck with stunning views, fish in the bass-filled pond, or enjoy an outdoor fire pond side . Inside stay cozy and relaxed while you enjoy a timber-vaulted great room, two stone gas fireplaces, a full kitchen, central air, propane heat, and a hot tub. With luxurious amenities and serene surroundings, it’s the perfect escape for unforgettable memories. Book now in !

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 108 reviews

Top guest favorite

Cottage in Cattaraugus

Quiet Creekside Escape in the Enchanted Mountains

A creekside oasis, nestled in the quaint hills of Amish country, 1 hour to Buffalo + 15 minutes to E-Ville awaits! Comfy bedrooms, stone hearth & wood-burning fireplace to keep you cozy. Beautiful waterfalls & flowing creek for exploring, fire areas, yoga deck & hammock to lounge. Unplug, reconnect + fall asleep to the sounds of the brook or connect to our hi-speed WiFi & make the chalet your office for the week! *NEW AIRBNB FEES ADDED TO OUR PRICING : They take an average of $150 a stay!*

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 126 reviews

Top guest favorite

A cozy living room features two grey sofas adorned with colorful cushions, complemented by a wooden coffee table. A decorative fireplace is centrally positioned against a green wall, while shelves holding books and art pieces are mounted beside it. Natural light is welcomed through large windows with patterned curtains.

Apartment in Jamestown

Thurston Terrace Apartment in Downtown Jamestown

Our 19th-century row house apartment has been thoughtfully designed to provide a comfortable stay and authentic local experience on your next visit to Jamestown. Perfectly located in the heart of downtown Jamestown, you can easily walk to excellent restaurants, pubs, and boutique shops, including a café and beer + wine lounge right downstairs. Explore the National Comedy Center, visit the Lucille Ball Desi Arnaz Museum, and head to Chautauqua Lake for scenic walks.

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 487 reviews

Top guest favorite

A cozy cabin exterior is surrounded by trees, illuminated by string lights at dusk. A hammock is strung between two trees, offering a comfortable space to relax. Several chairs and a fire pit are visible, inviting outdoor gatherings.

Guesthouse in Forestville

Forestville Studio Cabin (Rural Guest Home)

Reconnect with nature at our guest studio cabin on 5 acres, nestled beside a creek. Just 11 miles from Lake Erie and an hour from Niagara Falls. Only 528 yards to the snowmobile trail, 10 minutes to the Amish Trail, and 12 miles to Boutwell Hill State Forest. Enjoy nearby hiking, biking, swimming, fishing, tubing, kayaking, skiing, snowmobiling, hunting, and exploring Amish country and local wineries. Located on a quiet dirt road, yet close to main travel routes.

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 221 reviews

Top guest favorite

A newly constructed cabin is nestled among lush trees, showcasing a wooden exterior. Adjacent to the cabin is a picnic shelter that includes an Amish-made dining table. A circular fire pit is set on a stone patio, providing an inviting outdoor gathering space.

Cabin in Cattaraugus

Hot Tub BBQs Fire Pit Trails Birds New Build

Experience a modern cabin getaway at Breezy Hill Cabin in Cattaraugus, NY. Nestled on 10 wooded acres, this newly built, Amish-crafted retreat features rustic charm with luxury finishes, including black stainless steel appliances and open-concept living. NEW Hot Tub! Refilled 5-28-26 Fast WIFI Chef's Kitchen BBQs Fire Pit Firewood - cured and ready for purchase 10 Acres with hiking trails Birding Paradise Outdoor and indoor games

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 178 reviews

Guest favorite

Home in Little Valley

Farm at Enchanted Mountain • Hot Tub & Views

Wake up to sweeping views, quiet mornings, and wide-open skies—just 15 minutes from Ellicottville, NY. This 6-bedroom, 3-bath farmhouse sits on 45 private acres and blends rustic charm with modern comfort. Soak in the hot tub, gather around the fire pit, or simply take in the scenery. Whether you're traveling with family, friends, or coworkers, it's the perfect place to relax, reconnect, and enjoy the beauty of the countryside—together.

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 100 reviews