Vacation rentals in Butlerville

Walnut Street Saloon BNB

Step back in time to enjoy a historic tavern-turned-getaway in downtown Madison, Indiana. This spacious home, once a bustling town staple, combines rich history with modern amenities. Immerse yourself in Madison's vibrant heritage while staying just blocks away from locally owned shops, bars, and restaurants, as well as the beautiful Ohio River. It's the perfect vacation spot, whether you're here to shop, explore Clifty Falls State Park, or check out one of Madison's many festivals and events.

Stablemaster’s Quarters/ Best downtown location!

Come see why the city awarded us with the “Stellar Award”, Best Place To Stay in Madison! The historic building was originally one of the city’s main livery stables circa 1886. New very comfortable furnishings, a spacious gathering area, 2 large bathrooms, laundry room & a furnished white kitchen will all be appreciated. Yet, historic charm remains. You will soon see why the entire building has won multiple awards. Come see why US Today awarded Madison “ Best Small Town in the Midwest”.

Backyard Barndominium

This memorable place is anything but ordinary. We’re a mile from I74 exit. This is a 2000 square foot house with a great room that towers to 14’ ceilings. Two large bedrooms with large walk in closets for extra dressing space. View from kitchen windows overlooks a forest of 100 trees. (And we’re in town!) Fully furnished kitchen to prepare your meals. You’ll find a beautiful park across the road with miles of wooded walking trails and a lot to explore. Lots of parking. Easy access.

Unwind Haven

This historical barn is nestled right in the heart of southeastern Indiana’s farmland. Enjoy the Crossroads of America by adventuring to local hometowns, State Parks, shops, and restaurants. Enjoy live music, museums, and other attractions by visiting three conveniently located cities. If it’s serenity that you’re searching for you’ll find that by watching our beautiful sunrises or sitting around the fire pit gazing up at the stars. You won’t forget the peacefulness of this destination.

Cabin on the Ridge: The Sequel

Welcome to the area's first new construction short term rental tailored for you, the guest. This contemporary cabin is nestled in the woods right in the heart of Amish country. This is the perfect destination for those who want to getaway yet enjoy the unique beauty of Historic Downtown Madison (25 minutes) recognized as "The prettiest small town in the Midwest" or chase waterfalls at Clifty Falls State Park (25 minutes). •Fast wifi •Roku TV •Keurig (K-Cups Available)

Secluded Country Home in Historic Hoosier Hills

You’ll love the property because of the private secluded location and the views. The property is good for couples, solo families (with kids), all girls/boys gatherings and big groups. The house has over 1900 square feet of living space plus a sunroom looking over the pond and woods. There are two TVs with cable connection and one tv with an antenna. One TV is in the common living area and the other tv's are in two bedrooms, Catch and release fishing is permitted.

The Cottage by the Woods

This small but newly renovated Cottage by the Woods offers a peaceful country alternative to an airbnb stay. The cottage is lightly decorated for seasonal transitions. It is located 15 minutes from downtown Madison, IN. A partial wrap around deck allows for a tranquil cup of coffee while bird watching. Free WiFi and Roku TV is provided along with other small amenities including various flavored coffee's for your morning cup of joe and a waffle making station.

Cozy Cottage downtown *Pets*Trails*firepit*Clean

Sue’s Cottage is a quaint two bedroom cottage with a porch over looking the Heritage Trail of Madison. It is perfect for pets. It is a home to many species of birds and wildlife. Relax on the deck bird watching or stroll through the heritage trail & scenic railroad tracks surrounding the cottage, which leads to the river walk and Clifty Park. We are walking distance to all historic Madison offers. We are less than a mile from Clifty Park.

Hilltop Dome, 42 secluded acres in nature

Our Geodome is tucked away on 42 private acres exclusively for you and your guest Enjoy the stars at night, fire pit, hot tub, high speed internet, washer dryer, and smart TV . The Dome is equipped with a 2 ton mini split that will keep you warm in the winter and cool in the summer We are conveniently located within 15 miles of Madison, IN, Vevay, IN, Clifty Falls, Belterra Casino, also within 62 miles of Cincinnati and Louisville.

Tranquil Terrace with King Bed Suite

Enjoy privacy on our sunrise terrace with a view to the trees of Haw Creek - yet you are still in a modern neighborhood in Columbus, Indiana. * New Ranch Home Built in 2016 * King Sleep Number Bed Master Suite * High Speed WiFi * Open Concept Living-Dining-Kitchen Area * Disney Channel Plus, Paramount Plus, Prime Video and More * Outdoor Fire Place on Private Patio * Coffee and Tea * Full Kitchen with all Cooking Needs * Laundry

Stoney Creek Cabin - Sit back and unwind

Welcome to Stoney Creek Cabin. This charming 2 bedroom cabin is nestled in the hills of Madison, IN. Situated far enough away to offer all the privacy you want, yet only 8 miles from historic downtown, where there are so many gems nearby to explore. Enjoy the HOT TUB, wrap around porch, and patio! There could not be a more relaxing place to unwind.

Campus Cottage: Cozy, Convenient, Captivating

Charming ranch home on the edge of Hanover College campus. This 2 bed, 1 bath home contains hardwood flooring throughout, an eat-in dining area, open-concept living, and brand new furnishings. Explore the beauty of Hanover, just blocks from breathtaking Ohio River views, and 6 miles from Historic Downtown Madison.