Vacation rentals in Butlerville

School Days

Sharpen your pencils and reminisce about your childhood school days in this beautifully reconstructed schoolhouse. Built in 1879, this gorgeous property is situated just minutes from local coffee shops, locally owned restaurants, antique shops and the second largest State Park in Indiana. Be entertained with live music, museums, and other attractions by visiting three conveniently located cities. Come enjoy the modern amenities as well as the historical features this schoolhouse has to offer.

Otter Ridge Retreat

Nestled in the trees atop a 70 ft ridge overlooking a fork of the Muscatatuck River, sits this charming cabin with expansive views from every room. This new home, completed in 2024, is an original design built with our own hands incorporating wood posts & beams milled using logs from our farm and large expansions of glass to magnify the experience of living in nature while enjoying the comforts of home. This stylish cabin has been described as "the perfect mix of rustic and elegant."

Cozy Private Lakehouse

Relax with the whole family at this peaceful place to stay. So much to do, The kids have their own dwelling (clubhouse) It has tv, WIFI, and a loft - The fish are monstrous- , We have kayaks and canoes with plenty of lifejackets all sizes - Enjoy a hot tub overlooking the lake , we have wildlife that we can feed- Enjoy a movie in the yard, we provide projector (WIFI). Can have a bonfire , roast marshmallows - and just read a book - We have a full kitchen all cabinets are stocked -

The Dibble Treehouse

Welcome to The Dibble Treehouse! This cozy haven accommodates 4 guests and boasts all the amenities for an unforgettable stay. Relax in the hot tub or sauna, gently swing in the suspended bed or hanging chairs, and savor meals at the outdoor picnic table. The full kitchen is equipped for your stay and the wrap around porch offers stunning views. Enjoy evenings by the fire pit or take in your favorite shows on the smart TV. Book this stay to fully recharge and reconnect with nature!

Cabin on the Ridge: The Sequel

Welcome to the area's first new construction short term rental tailored for you, the guest. This contemporary cabin is nestled in the woods right in the heart of Amish country. This is the perfect destination for those who want to getaway yet enjoy the unique beauty of Historic Downtown Madison (25 minutes) recognized as "The prettiest small town in the Midwest" or chase waterfalls at Clifty Falls State Park (25 minutes). •Fast wifi •Roku TV •Keurig (K-Cups Available)

The Cottage by the Woods

This small but newly renovated Cottage by the Woods offers a peaceful country alternative to an airbnb stay. The cottage is lightly decorated for seasonal transitions. It is located 15 minutes from downtown Madison, IN. A partial wrap around deck allows for a tranquil cup of coffee while bird watching. Free WiFi and Roku TV is provided along with other small amenities including various flavored coffee's for your morning cup of joe and a waffle making station.

Cabin on Versailles State Park Lake

Tucked along the lake at Versailles State Park, this cozy rustic cabin is perfect for individuals, couples, families and friends. It features 2 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, a full kitchen, and a comfortable living area with lake views. Enjoy a private deck for relaxing, plus easy nearby access to hiking, fishing, and kayaking. A peaceful, secluded, nature-filled getaway with all the comforts of home and yet within walking distance of town. This is a brand new listing!

Romantic & Private Retreat with hot tub

Escape to The Enchanted Cottage—a cozy, romantic retreat with a private hot tub, just 5 minutes from downtown Madison. Enjoy a king bed, rainfall shower, two 50” smart TVs, and a full-body massage chair. Sip from the coffee bar with flavored syrups or unwind with your cocktail setup. Relax on the covered deck or gather around the firepit (firewood available for purchase). Romantic add-ons available. ✨pls note: we provide one tank of propane during your stay

Nina's View

Experience the quiet of rural Indiana and gorgeous views of rolling fields at Nina’s View. This one story, three-bedroom home offers two full baths, a spacious living and dining area, a breakfast nook and a full functioning kitchen. A 15-minute drive from Seymour and North Vernon, and a 45-minute drive from Madison, this getaway is in close proximity to wonderful hiking, incredible historical sites and some great small-town shopping.

Hilltop Dome, 42 secluded acres in nature

Our Geodome is tucked away on 42 private acres exclusively for you and your guest Enjoy the stars at night, fire pit, hot tub, high speed internet, washer dryer, and smart TV . The Dome is equipped with a 2 ton mini split that will keep you warm in the winter and cool in the summer We are conveniently located within 15 miles of Madison, IN, Vevay, IN, Clifty Falls, Belterra Casino, also within 62 miles of Cincinnati and Louisville.

The Camp in Oxford (OH)

The Camp in Oxford includes3 private acres nestled right alongside the Indian Creek River and surrounded by sprawling farmland. Located just 5 miles from Miami University, 13 miles from Brookville Lake and short drives to Hamilton, Cincinnati or Dayton, this beautiful 2 bedroom modern cottage is waiting for your next visit. Fully furnished and equipped with every amenity you'd expect from a 5 star property.

Stoney Creek Cabin - Sit back and unwind

Welcome to Stoney Creek Cabin. This charming 2 bedroom cabin is nestled in the hills of Madison, IN. Situated far enough away to offer all the privacy you want, yet only 8 miles from historic downtown, where there are so many gems nearby to explore. Enjoy the HOT TUB, wrap around porch, and patio! There could not be a more relaxing place to unwind.