Vacation rentals in Starkey

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Starkey

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1
Guest favorite
A clear stream flows over smooth stones, with sunlight filtering through trees in the background. The tranquil water glistens as it meanders past a stone-lined bank, adjacent to a fenced area that leads to a cottage structure. The natural setting offers a serene ambiance.
Home in Dundee
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 126 reviews

Malthouse

Relax with the whole family at this peaceful place to stay. This creatively furnished cottage located just off ny state rte 14 which is seneca lake wine trail. It is only minutes from many wineries and only 15 minutes from watkins glen. The house has a full kitchen with cooking basics and a k-cup coffee maker 3 bedrooms with king size beds. A stream flowing right through the back yard. There are toys and games and a hot tub. There's some noise from the traffic on rte 14 but peaceful otherwise.

Guest favorite
The exterior view of the farmhouse displays a two-story white structure surrounded by vibrant autumn foliage. Large windows reflect the seasonal colors, while a covered porch invites relaxation. A spacious lawn lays before the house, with scattered leaves adding to the tranquil ambiance.
Home in Dundee
4.74 out of 5 average rating, 121 reviews

Farmhouse at Fulkerson Winery

An 1856 farmhouse re-finished to accommodate up to 10 people. 4 queen beds. Full kitchen, Living and Dining. Enjoy the beauty of Seneca Lake from the porch with your favorite Finger Lakes wine! Direct access to the Seneca Lake Wine Trail, lake access within 8 miles. Best view on the lake! 6 wineries within 2 miles. The outbuildings have a "working farm charm", and may be a little messy due to storage of articles from past generations. The house does sit on NY 14 and can have some road noise.

Top guest favorite
Guesthouse in Hector
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 118 reviews

Wolf Den Private Suite and Dock

Your stay here will be relaxing and peaceful in a private and spacious suite with a private dock & kayaks. Located in Hector, you’ll be surrounded by wineries, breweries and farm to table dining. The bnb is located on the second level of unoccupied storage space but your entry requires just two steps as seen in the photos. The path to the lake is well lit a 60-90 second walk. I live between the bnb and the lake so I’m available at all times. Please read “The space” below for all the amenities.

Top guest favorite
A circular fire pit is surrounded by four red Adirondack chairs, creating a comfortable seating area. The horizon showcases a vibrant sunset with shades of orange and purple, while a grill sits nearby on a grassy area, offering a great spot for outdoor gatherings.
Cabin in Hector
5.0 out of 5 average rating, 163 reviews

Sunset Paradise, Hector N.Y.

Come and enjoy the stunning sunsets and vista views from your private patio to “get away from it all”. ALL NEW CONSTRUCTION created from the ground up with every detail in mind. Enjoy the spacious 1 bedroom home with queen and additional queen sofa bed in the living room to allow for a more comfortable fit. Minutes to top winery’s and wonderful restaurants! Included is a stocked coffee bar for early mornings and a fire-pit for sunsets and late evenings. Great for 4 adults or a family getaway!

Top guest favorite
A view of a lakefront property illustrating a well-maintained yard with green grass and a dock extending into clear water. An American flag gently flutters near the house, while several outdoor chairs and loungers are arranged for relaxation. Lush trees form a backdrop against a clear sky.
Home in Dundee
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 160 reviews

Private Waterfront Home Wine Trail Hot Tub Dock

Welcome to Vineyard Views, your beautiful lakefront getaway! This year-round home on the FLX WINE TRAIL has 75' of LAKEFRONT and nice amenities. 3BR+sleeping loft/2BA+outdoor shower. The 4-SEASON covered PATIO/outdoor kitchen & dining enhances your experience any time of year! Enjoy the 4-person HOT TUB w/ TV. 60’ dock w/ electric BOAT LIFT, bar, seating area and fire pit. Steps to lake and ladder on dock. FAMILY VACATIONS, FRIENDS GATHERINGS and COUPLES GETAWAYS. Up to 2 dogs/$25 each/night.

Guest favorite
A simple dining area is highlighted by a rustic wooden table beneath a woven pendant light. Natural light filters through a large window, illuminating a potted plant and a bowl of fruit at the center, while two dark chairs are positioned on either side.
Home in Hector
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 194 reviews

Finger Lakes Winery Farmhouse

Experience the heart of Hector's wine country in our large, charming 3 bed, 2 bath farmhouse adjacent to Damiani Wine vineyards and an active wine production barn. This historic, 100+ year old home features a renovated kitchen and 2 full baths, with thoughtfully curated, eclectic modern farmhouse decor. Great for families or groups of friends, this cozy, well stocked home lets you catch a glimpse of the wine-making and grape growing process next door. Easy lake access is just down the road.

Top guest favorite
Home in Dundee
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 101 reviews

2 King Beds, Wineries + Watkins Glen at VineHaus

VineHaus is a bright, historic lake house with vineyard views, two king bedrooms, and an unbeatable location near Watkins Glen and the Seneca Lake Wine Trail. Spend your days tasting at nearby wineries, breweries, and distilleries, hiking the gorges and waterfalls at Watkins Glen State Park, and visiting the Windmill. End the day with a farm to table dinner and Finger Lakes wine on the deck. Relaxed, comfortable, and ideal for a couples getaway or friends weekend, April through December!

Top guest favorite
A spacious building is set against a backdrop of lush green fields and vineyards. The exterior features a blue metal roof and arched windows. A patio with seating options is visible in the foreground, surrounded by landscaped areas and open spaces, enhancing the outdoor environment.
Cabin in Lodi
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 379 reviews

Winery Cabin- Sunset Lakeview

Experience comfort and convenience catered to your needs. This property was built specifically to mirror the requests of past guests. We want families to have plenty of space to relax and take in the stunning views of Seneca Lake. You will be located right on the Seneca Lake wine trail. Whether you are interested in outdoor activities like hiking, or you want to try local beer, wine, cheeses, or eateries, our unique location makes it easy for you!! We look forward to your stay with us!!!

Guest favorite
A spacious dining area is illuminated by natural light through tall windows, showcasing lake views. A wooden table, set with a neutral runner, is surrounded by black chairs. A decorative vase and a bottle are placed at the center, adding a simple yet elegant touch.
Home in Dundee
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 54 reviews

Seneca lake home w/soaring views & private dock

Scenic home w/ private dock on 4 acres. 3 BR home in the heart of Finger Lakes Wine Country located on the western shore of Seneca lake. 10 minutes from Watkins Glen. Our home is on a 4 acre wooded oasis, w/ private lake access & a newer dock. Enjoy the wrap around deck with beautiful lake views. Perfect setting for family & friends. The walk to the lake is downhill on a private road (1/10 mi). Parking also avail near lake. 3 BRs\ King, queen & queen (BR 2&3 semi-private)

Top guest favorite
A serene lakeside home is positioned on a gently sloping green hill, featuring a spacious deck that overlooks the water. Surrounding trees provide a natural setting. The structure showcases large windows, allowing for abundant natural light and expansive views of the lake.
Home in Penn Yan
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 291 reviews

Beautiful Keuka Lake home close to Penn Yan.

Welcome to Keuka lake in this beautiful home that boasts 3 master suites. The living room has a panoramic view of Keuka Lake. There is a deck off the top floor and a patio off the first floor to sit and enjoy the lake view as well. From the downstairs patio you are only a few steps to the beach. At the end of the dock the lake is only 3 feet deep so it’s excellent for swimming. Everything in this house is new and very clean. We are a mile from downtown Penn Yan.

Guest favorite
The cottage features a charming yellow exterior with a green metal roof. A stone chimney adds character, while flower boxes adorn the front windows. A well-maintained lawn surrounds the home, and the entrance is framed by a glass-paned door, inviting guests into a welcoming atmosphere.
Cottage in Dundee
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 185 reviews

A Historic cottage in gorgeous Glenora.

With amazing views of Seneca Lake, the Cottage at Glenora is going to be your new favorite home away from home. Once a child's playhouse, the large cottage sits on 5 acres and overlooks the Glenora cliffs, the cottage is ready to welcome you for years to come. Historic but updated with the creature comforts you desire. The entire estate is a restoration in progress. We will always notify guests if any work on the main house, well in advance.

Guest favorite
A living room is showcased with a brown tufted sofa and a wooden coffee table. Tall lamps provide ambient lighting beside the sofa, while a vibrant tropical leaf wallpaper adds a lush backdrop. A decorative plant sits on the side table, enhancing the inviting setting.
Home in Dundee
4.9 out of 5 average rating, 83 reviews

Casa Ceylon in The Finger Lakes

Listen to the sound of a creek in the backyard while you enjoy Lake Seneca views. Located centrally among the Lake Seneca wineries, breweries, distilleries and restaurants, Just a 10 mins drive to Watkins Glen. 20 mins to Geneva. Located by State Route 14. Great place to enjoy with friends or family. Short drive to many beautiful waterfalls and hikes. The house can accommodate 6 adults. We hope you would enjoy our little home as much as we do.

Popular amenities for Starkey vacation rentals