Vacation rentals in Schuyler Lake

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Schuyler Lake

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Top guest favorite

Four rustic wooden Adirondack chairs are arranged around a stone fire pit in a grassy area beside Oaks Creek. The lush greenery contrasts with the flowing water and dense trees in the background, providing a peaceful outdoor setting for relaxation.

Home in Fly Creek

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 241 reviews

*Oaks Creek Cottage*ON the Creek*3bd 2bath Sleeps6

*RENT FROM A LOCAL!* Welcome to Oaks Creek Cottage in Fly Creek!!! This adorable 3 bed 2 bath house is RIGHT on Oaks Creek! Go 1 mile down the road to the Fly Creek General Store and grab a fishing pole! Also included is a fire pit, outdoor charcoal grill, outdoor games like corn hole, Jenga, Connect 4 and ring toss. This place is made for the outdoors! 4.5 miles to the Baseball Hall of Fame 7.3 miles to Cooperstown Dreams Park 24 miles to All Star Village 12 miles to Glimmerglass Opera House

Guest favorite

The farmhouse stands gracefully on a gently sloping lawn, featuring a welcoming front porch with blue chairs and potted flowers. A charcoal grill is positioned nearby, surrounded by lush greenery, creating a serene outdoor space perfect for relaxation.

Home in Cooperstown

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 243 reviews

Oaks Creek Guest Cottage

This brand new country farmhouse overlooks Oaks Creek with stunning rural views, yet is only 2.5 miles from Cooperstown and 1.5 miles to Cooperstown Dreams Park. A cathedral ceiling first floor, open floor plan kitchen and common area (with gas fireplace and flatscreen TV) adjoins a full bath with tiled shower and two bedrooms, each with a queen bed. The upstairs loft boasts a queen bed, day bed, and writing desk. Downstairs you will enjoy our slate-bed billiards table, X-box, and game area.

Top guest favorite

The spacious living room features a neutral carpet and light-colored walls. A cozy seating area is provided by a brown sofa and a cream armchair. Natural light filters through two windows adorned with sheer curtains. A decorative fireplace adds character to the room.

Apartment in Ilion

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 227 reviews

Renovated 1BR unit near Herkimer Diamond Mines

This bright and sunny 1 BR apartment has plenty of space to spread out. Full eat-in kitchen including all cooking essentials. In addition to the queen bed in bedroom there is a twin daybed, queen size air mattress and pack’n play available for use. A small town off Exit 30 on I-90. Centrally located between Syracuse and Albany. 40 min to Cooperstown (1 hour to All Star Village). 15 min to Herkimer Diamond Mines. Also, nearby the home of the Utica Comets Hockey and Utica City Football Club!

Top guest favorite

A modern studio interior features a comfortable leather sofa paired with two armchairs, inviting relaxation. A wooden coffee table with woven placemats sits in front. Soft lighting illuminates the cozy sleeping area, which is set with a spacious bed and tasteful decor, creating a welcoming atmosphere.

Apartment in Cooperstown

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 298 reviews

Deer Meadow Farm Studio: spacious studio apartment

Deer Meadow Farm Studio is modern, spacious (24'x16') and includes many amenities to make your stay comfortable and relaxing! Including:WiFi • Spectrum/Apple TV • Radiant floor heat • A/C • Private patio w/ gas grill • All linens/towels • Kitchenette (microwave, mini-fridge, Keurig, toaster). PLEASE NOTE: There is NOT a full kitchen. Located near The Baseball Hall of Fame, Brewery Ommegang, Cooperstown Farmers' Market, Glimmerglass Festival as well as the many area shops and restaurants!

Top guest favorite

A spacious guesthouse and main house are visible, both surrounded by greenery. The guesthouse, featuring a peaked roof and front porch, is set beside the main house, which includes a symmetrical design and large garage doors. A gravel pathway leads to both structures.

Guesthouse in Fort Plain

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 573 reviews

Starhaven: Baseball HoF, Mineral Mining & More

Our guesthouse is minutes from the interstate, but you'll swear that you've traveled miles out in "God's country." Surrounded by many Amish neighbors, we are centrally located to Cooperstown, Howe Caverns, the Southern Adirondacks, Saratoga, Albany, Utica, and the Mohawk Valley (all within an hour's drive or less.) Enjoy a quiet retreat far off the road with authentic Amish furniture and decor and modern conveniences (washer & dryer, dishwasher, Keurig, AC/Heat, WiFi and streaming TV.)

Guest favorite

A two-story home is showcased with light blue siding and stone accents. The front features multiple large windows and two spacious balconies. Seating is arranged on the lower patio, complemented by a grill. Surrounding greenery and trees enhance the property’s natural setting.

Home in Richfield Springs

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 283 reviews

Luxury Cooperstown Area Lake Home with Amenities!!

Summer Bookings, we only accept 6 night stays aligned with “Cooperstown Dreams Park” schedule, see their site for the schedule. If you’re going to “Allstar Village” their schedule does not align with this. The 2026 season is 5/31-8/23/26. Beautiful 3 bedroom on Canadarago Lake, 15 min. drive to Cooperstown. We now have 6 kayaks, a pedal boat, & a paddle board! Enjoy coffee viewing the peacefulness of the lake, if mornings aren’t for you, It is as beautiful at sunset with wine.

Guest favorite

A sunlit open field is displayed, featuring lush green grass under a clear blue sky. A gentle fence runs along the perimeter, blending with the natural landscape of distant trees and rolling hills in the background.

Home in West Winfield

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 181 reviews

"Just an Ol' Farm House"

Charming COUNTRY farm house dates back to pre-civil war times, this evident by the beautiful wood work, beautiful wide plank floors. Large yard that is perfect for the kids or dog to run & play. This house is in the perfect central location of the NY COUNRY side. THERE ARE ZERO STREET LIGHTS. We are short drive to many attractions around NY. You have the entire house to yourself & your party. We are close if you need us but we value your privacy! *Please read pet policy carefully*

Guest favorite

A rustic barn with a weathered wooden exterior is framed by lush greenery and vibrant blue skies. The barn features an open front, providing a glimpse of the inviting indoor space, while a small yellow structure with a sloped roof is visible to the side.

Home in Schuyler Lake

5 out of 5 average rating, 21 reviews

Historic home, barn life and great views!

Pack up your family and come stay in our charming 1835 Federal-style stone home located just 9 miles outside of Cooperstown, 1/2 hour to Cooperstown All Star Field and 20 minutes to Cooperstown Dream Park. The home boasts 4 large bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, 2 living rooms, kitchen and a dining room. The property sits on 70 acres and has a 1/2 acre of the yard fully groomed for the perfect baseball game. It also features a beautiful barn outfitted with a dining area, pool table and TV.

Top guest favorite

The kitchen features modern cabinetry in white, complemented by a contrasting dark island with three wooden stools. Bright pendant lighting illuminates the space, and a window adorned with checked curtains provides natural light. Stainless steel appliances are neatly integrated throughout.

Home in Cooperstown

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 106 reviews

Welcome To Turner Ranch

Entire home on 20 acres of land in Cooperstown, NY. 3 bedrooms all with queen size beds. 4 minute drive to the National Baseball Hall of Fame and a 10 minute drive to the local breweries. 3 miles to Otsego lake for boating kayaking and swimming with lifeguards on duty. Clark sports center for any fitness needs. Dreams park is only 10 miles away! Winter months: snowshoes provided with stay! pet friendly and all new baby equipment if needed.

Top guest favorite

The entrance to a rustic cabin is framed by logs, featuring a welcome sign and a seasonal wreath on the door. A pair of wooden rocking chairs sits on a spacious porch, accompanied by a decorative pumpkin and a carved wooden stump.

Cabin in Cooperstown

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 113 reviews

An Upstate NY getaway treasure!

Take it easy at this unique and tranquil getaway. For several hundred years our family has been a part of the Cooperstown community and we look forward to sharing it with you! On over 20 acres of land , you can explore the beautiful landscape of water and woods. Just over the hill from Otsego Lake. Only 3.9 miles (8 min) to Cooperstown’s Main Street in the spring, summer and fall and 5.7 miles (10 min) in winter.

The kitchen features modern cabinetry in a honey tone, complemented by a dark granite countertop. A coffee maker is placed above the sink, and a drying rack is positioned nearby. Subtle mosaic tiles add a decorative touch under the cabinets.

Guest suite in Cooperstown

4.8 out of 5 average rating, 287 reviews

Village Suite Walking Distance to Everything

This guest suite has all the comforts of home. It's a comfortable walk or bike ride to the Hall of Fame, historic downtown, the Farmer's Museum and beautiful Otsego Lake. A 24-hour grocery store is around the corner and we're close to the trolley that will take you all over Cooperstown in the summer. And it's only a 10 minute drive to Brewery Ommegang. Please note, there is no TV or cable in the suite. Just Wi-Fi.

Top guest favorite

The exterior of the A-frame glamp is shown, surrounded by lush greenery and tall trees under a blue sky filled with gentle clouds. A large window reflects the natural scenery, enhancing the connection to nature. The interior view captures a distinctive moon-shaped light fixture suspended from the high ceiling, complementing the triangular architecture.

Place to stay in Oneonta

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 246 reviews

Creekside of the Moon A-frame Cabin

Creekside of the moon A-frame glamp. Float, fish and play in the Catskills. Glamp on the Charlotte Creek in a newly built modern tiny a-frame. Sleep under the full moon. A giant moon light hangs over the bed(s) with a stunning reflection in the window at night over the creekview. Perfect for a romantic getaway, fishing trip, or glamping spot in the Catskills. Close to Cooperstown, NY IG @aframe_moon