Vacation rentals in Otter Lake

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Otter Lake

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1
Guest favorite
An outdoor fire pit, surrounded by rustic chairs, provides a cozy gathering spot. Stacked firewood is neatly arranged nearby, and a cabin is visible in the background, nestled among the trees. The scene is illuminated by evening light, enhancing the natural beauty of the surroundings.
Cabin in Cresco
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 133 reviews

The Little Black Cabin - Sauna | Hot Tub | Firepit

The Little Black Cabin (LBC) offers the perfect balance between rustic and lux. We remodeled this cabin with the goal to create a space where you can reconnect with nature while simultaneously indulging in pure comfort. It's a space designed to inspire, and to revitalize your mind, body and spirit - A place where you can chop wood, take a walk, light a fire, sit and relax under the stars, or enjoy a hot tub, cold plunge, or Finnish-style handmade sauna - We welcome you to The Little Black Cabin.

Top guest favorite
A serene cabin is nestled among lush trees, with a gentle sunset casting a warm glow. A spacious front porch features comfortable seating, while a woodpile is neatly stacked nearby. A hammock sways subtly, inviting relaxation in this tranquil outdoor setting.
Cabin in East Stroudsburg
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 108 reviews

Private Retreat- Cozy Cabin in the Woods

Welcome to Rose Marie, this quiet retreat is a perfect match for Nature Lovers, Romantics & Small Families. This former hunting cabin has been completely remodeled adding modern amenities while retaining its history & charm. This 750 sq. ft. cabin features two bedrooms, one bath & a cozy living space with a wood burning stove. A fully stocked quaint kitchen has everything you need to prepare a home cooked meal. Did I mention the Delaware State Forest, 1,820 acres right outside the back door

Top guest favorite
The spacious living area features a large green sofa, two cozy accent chairs, and a rustic coffee table made from natural wood. A stone fireplace adds warmth, while soft lighting and large windows enhance the inviting atmosphere.
Home in East Stroudsburg
5 out of 5 average rating, 202 reviews

Themed| Lake | Pool | Hot Tub | Movie Screen

A truly unique stay in the Pocono Mountains, home to rolling mountain terrain, breathtakingly beautiful waterfalls, thriving woodlands, + 170 miles of winding river. Created with the “ultimate night in" experience in mind, guests can sip wine under the stars in a private hot tub, + enjoy movies on their own 135" movie screen equipped w/ the world's first LED 4K gaming projector. Enjoy themed bedrooms and experience a stay where the forest takes you away as you stay in ultimate comfort + luxury.

Superhost
The inviting living area features wooden beams and a stone fireplace, surrounded by comfortable seating arrangements. Large windows illuminate the space, showcasing rustic decor and a cozy sheepskin rug on warm-toned wooden floors. A dining table is visible in the background, enhancing the communal atmosphere.
Cabin in East Stroudsburg
4.93 out of 5 average rating, 380 reviews

Coziest Creek Cabin- Idyllic, Authentic, Poconos

Deep within our psyche lies a romantic image, that of a log cabin tucked into the woods perched above a babbling trout laden stream. Perhaps inside there's a sheepskin rug laid before a grand fireplace, a reading nook, and a child's dreamy hideaway loft. Or maybe you're out on the deck, a crisp morning bundled and sipping cocoa on a rocking chair, or nights soaking sore bones and soaking up the sounds of the stream & kids below roasting smores by the fire. Now make that dream a reality!

Top guest favorite
A rustic log cabin with a green metal roof is surrounded by trees and features a stone pathway leading to the entrance. A spacious yard includes two lounge chairs, a hot tub in the distance, and landscaped areas with blooming flowers.
Cabin in Canadensis
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 988 reviews

Pocono Log Cabin Getaway

Cute & Cozy One Bedroom Log Cabin tucked away in the Poconos. Embrace the simplicity & tranquility of the mountains. Perfect for a cozy retreat. Hot tub nestled in the trees, outdoor fireplace, hammock, & gas grill. The Poconos offer a range of activities & attractions, scenic hiking, ski slopes, lakes for boating & fishing, golf courses, water parks, charming towns w/shopping & dining options. Separate game room w/pool table, sauna, board games and shuffle board. Popcorn machine is a plus.

Top guest favorite
A castle-style retreat is showcased, featuring a whimsical dragon statue and a large chess set in the foreground. A tranquil pond with a fountain is visible, alongside a magnificent castle structure designed with classic stone elements and a welcoming entrance, all set amidst lush greenery.
Castle in East Stroudsburg
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 409 reviews

Pocono Castle w/ Dungeon Escape Room &Private Pond

Sleep in a Fairy Tale at Pocono Castle! Live the dream in this 2,300 sq. ft storybook retreat, where you’ll sleep like royalty in a real fairy tale castle. Unwind in luxury with a bubbling hot tub, a cedar sauna, and endless magical touches. Dress up as Kings, Queens, or Knights and explore the grounds, featuring a private one-acre pond & maybe you’ll catch a Golden Fish! With enchanting bedrooms, outdoor adventures, and unforgettable charm, this is the OMG getaway you’ve been waiting for!

Top guest favorite
A log cabin is shown nestled among trees, with a gravel area in front and a natural stone border. A deer is visible nearby, highlighting the serene natural surroundings. The sky features a gradient of warm colors, creating a peaceful ambiance.
Cabin in East Stroudsburg
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 189 reviews

Creekfront Poconos Cabin w/ Hot Tub & Fire Pit

Welcome to Split Creek Cabin, a private creekfront retreat nestled down a quiet dirt road along Marshall’s Creek. This cozy 2-bedroom, 1.5-bath log cabin offers a one-of-a-kind Poconos experience combining rustic charm with modern comfort. Unwind in the hot tub as the soothing sounds of the creek flow by, roast s’mores around the fire pit under starry skies, and enjoy a relaxing escape where your only neighbors are towering trees and wandering deer. A cozy, Creekside stay you won’t forget

Guest favorite
A modern cabin is elevated on a sturdy foundation, surrounded by trees showcasing autumn foliage. The large deck extends from the front, offering a spacious outdoor area. Natural light illuminates the exterior, highlighting the dark wooden siding and structure's welcoming design.
Cabin in Monroe County
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 120 reviews

Pocono cabin and wild trout creek

NEW EARLY CHECK IN 9 AM ! We welcome people from all walks of life to visit us and enjoy this beautiful property and all that the Poconos has to offer. Set back in the woodlands, the cabin overlooks a designated class A wild trout creek that flows through a small ravine of indigenous flora and old growth trees. The cabins’ large deck offers a tree house view of it all! Our guests enjoy this cozy cabin and its’ long list of amenities, including basic spices and cooking essentials.

Guest favorite
A cozy living area features warm wooden paneling and a plush sofa with light-colored cushions. A wooden coffee table holds two water bottles and a binder, while a stone fireplace adds character. Natural light streams in through large windows, enhancing the inviting atmosphere.
Farm stay in Cresco
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 171 reviews

The Thoroughbred Cottage at Pleasant Ridge Farm

The Thoroughbred Cottage is the quintessential, early 1900s Pocono vacation cottage. Located on our commercial horse farm, the cottage has been entirely renovated but has kept its unique original details. Views include our upper pastures and wooded hillside of the state game lands beyond. The cottage is set back on our private lane, but is close to all major Pocono attractions and wedding venues. A perfect, cozy little getaway for couples. Not suitable for infants or children

Guest favorite
Cottage in East Stroudsburg
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 211 reviews

Charming Cottage | Peaceful Escape in the Poconos

Woodland charm & luxe comfort make the Cottage in the Woods a must-stay escape! Retreat to this forest hideaway for total peace & privacy. Watch deer wander past and enjoy woodland views from the four-season sunroom. Gather under the stars at the fire pit and share memories. Our Cottage blends cozy cabin vibes with stylish touches. Only 90min from NYC & 2hrs from Philadelphia. Experience the magic of the Pocono Mountains today.

Guest favorite
The exterior of the rustic cottage features a wooden facade and two sets of French doors. Chairs are positioned on a stone path leading to the entrance, surrounded by a manicured garden area with pebbles and greenery. Nearby trees provide a natural backdrop.
Guesthouse in Stroudsburg
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 221 reviews

Cozy guest cottage with indoor fireplace

Take it easy at this unique getaway in the Poconos! This vintage one room cottage is the perfect space for soaking in nature, getting creative, or exploring the attractions of the Pocono Mountains. The cozy cottage is within 20 minutes of ski resorts, Kalahari, and the Delaware Water Gap national recreation park. Reach downtown Stroudsburg and it’s restaurants and nightlife within 7 minutes.

Guest favorite
A wooden dining table is surrounded by three chairs and a bench, set against a backdrop of large sliding doors leading to a deck. Natural light filters in through sheer white curtains, highlighting the tree views outside. Framed art decorates the wall beside a window.
Cabin in East Stroudsburg
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 130 reviews

Nature serene Cabin near popular hiking/waterfalls

Your trailhead starts here. Experience a unique stay surrounded by nature and sunset serenity. Thoughtfully remodeled and furnished for coziness and comfort in mind, this place is perfect for gatherings with family and friends, or a mere relaxing stay with a partner. The highlight of this place is the sunroom, accompanied by an entertainment room, providing the essentials for your enjoyment.

Popular amenities for Otter Lake vacation rentals