Vacation rentals in Otter Lake

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Otter Lake

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1
Top guest favorite
A charming cabin is set amidst lush greenery, featuring a sturdy wooden frame and a welcoming porch. Concrete steps lead to the entrance, while an outdoor seating area offers a comfortable spot to enjoy nature. The cabin's exterior is accentuated by natural wooden accents.
Cabin in Boonville
5 out of 5 average rating, 100 reviews

Canalside Cabin/Pet Friendly/On snowmobile trail

Relax and enjoy the outdoors at this unique and tranquil getaway. Located on the Black River Canal which offers trails for hiking, biking, canoeing, kayaking , and snowmobiling within steps from the cabin. Bring your side by side or snowmobiles and leave from the cabin to access miles of trails both locally and in the Tug Hill region. 3 mi. from the cabin is a superb 18 hole well maintained golf course. After a fun day of riding, hiking, biking or kayaking relax in the woods around a cozy fire.

Top guest favorite
A scenic view of a peaceful waterfront area, featuring a private dock painted in red. Two Adirondack chairs are placed around a stone fire pit, surrounded by lush greenery and tall grasses, with calm water reflecting the blue sky and clouds.
Apartment in Old Forge
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 165 reviews

Moose River cottage on the water in Old Forge

Soak in the Adirondacks from this rustic, newly remodeled one-bed apartment with a king size bed, full kitchen and bathroom. Start your day with a beautiful view of the sunrise over the Moose River. Feel free to launch one of our kayaks from our private dock, watch the stars from the hot tub or by the fire pit, take a bike ride on our bikes or just watch the amazing wild life and sunset from your private deck. Close to restaurants, shopping, hiking, and all of the summertime fun in Old Forge.

Top guest favorite
A wooden deck is set in front of the southwestern design home, surrounded by well-maintained greenery. An umbrella provides shade over outdoor seating. Brightly colored flowers are arranged along the edge of the deck, adding natural beauty to the outdoor space.
Guest suite in Newport
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 130 reviews

Herkimer Hideaway woodland retreat.

A woodland private drive and bubbling brook in front of this unique southwestern design home. Seasonally your senses will come alive with the sights & sounds of nature at its best! See wild flowers, attracting hummingbirds, butterflies, and deer from your deck. Enjoy morning coffee on the deck , a stroll on the private walking trail; or a beverage stargazing by the fire pit. For the adventurer, both the Adirondacks and many famous Herkimer Diamond mines are only a short drive away!

Superhost
A spacious living area is shown, featuring two dark leather sofas with decorative pillows. A rustic wooden coffee table occupies the center, resting on a soft area rug. Natural light pours in through nearby windows, enhancing the welcoming space.
Home in Forestport
4.88 out of 5 average rating, 129 reviews

Otter Lake Retreat

This is a 2 bedroom, one bath house with all the amenities! Sleeps 6 (1 king bed, 1 queen bed, 1 twin bed, 1 couch and 1 loveseat), has full kitchen, full bath, linens included, outdoor fire pit and BBQ. Only 10 miles south of Old Forge and Enchanted Forest Water Safari. Also direct access to fuel and major snowmobile trails, not far from nearby hiking trails, Adirondack Scenic Railroad, and McCauley Mountain ski resort. This is a great place to stay to relax and not have the traffic of town.

Guest favorite
A rustic cabin exterior is showcased with natural wooden logs and a welcoming porch. Two teal chairs are positioned on the deck, alongside potted plants and a decorative mat. A white door marks the entrance, complemented by large windows allowing plenty of natural light.
Cabin in Forestport
4.84 out of 5 average rating, 80 reviews

Cabin in Otter Lake

Studio cabin with one full bed and a full futon. Can sleep 4. Full kitchen and bath. Keurig and coffee pot. Small dining table. Linens included. TV and WiFi. AC and heat. Outdoor firepit and BBQ grill. Plenty of room for trucks and trailer parking. Walking distance from bar/restaurant and gas station/convenience store. Lake access to launch boat and/or kayak. Snowmobile trail located across street. 15 minutes south of Old Forge, 40 minutes north of Utica. Registration Number: STR-00112

Guest favorite
A rustic red cottage with a green metal roof is surrounded by neatly trimmed shrubs and small trees. The structure features a welcoming entrance with steps leading up to the porch. A gravel path runs alongside, maintaining a natural and serene setting.
Cottage in Forestport
4.86 out of 5 average rating, 154 reviews

Otter Lake Cottage- 10 miles south of Old Forge

This 3 bedroom, one bath cottage has everything you need! Has a screened in porch, sleeps 6, has full kitchen, full bath, linens included, WIFI, Smart TV with streaming, DVD player and DVD’s, BBQ grill, fire pit and wood on site for purchase. We also have a farm within walking distance of the cottage. Only 10 miles south of Old Forge. Not far from nearby hiking trails, and everything Old Forge has to offer. This is a great place to stay to relax and not have the traffic of town.

Top guest favorite
A warmly decorated bedroom features a spacious bed covered with contrasting orange and dark gray linens. Bright decorative pillows, including one with a fox design, add a playful touch. Natural light filters through a small window, complementing the dark wall color and framed artwork.
Cabin in Woodgate
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 44 reviews

Swaying Pines Cabin: ADKs king bed coziness for 2

Cozy Studio Cabin For One or Two In The Adirondack Foothills: Escape to Swaying Pines Cabin, where rustic meets modern. A perfect couple's retreat nestled among swaying Adirondack pines. Pull up an Adirondack chair, take a deep breath, and let the pines do the rest. Features: King bed w/100% Cotton Sheets Kitchen and bathroom Large screened-in porch Outdoor Grill Area Fire Pit Hammock Minutes from trails/outdoor activities Centrally located to Old Forge, Boonville, Foresport

Top guest favorite
A spacious living area is highlighted by a high cathedral ceiling and a brick fireplace. Natural light pours in from large windows, complementing the cozy seating arrangement and wooden accents. A colorful area rug with moose patterns adds a touch of warmth to the hardwood floor.
Home in Forestport
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 175 reviews

Spacious Adirondack house in Otter Lake

Appreciate the beauty of the Adirondacks and enjoy the comfort of a carefully decorated home that promotes relaxation. The first floor has an open concept and includes a spacious kitchen, dining area, and a welcoming living area with a high cathedral ceiling and a fireplace insert. Cozy up and read by the fire, watch TV, or play some board games. As the sun sets, enjoy a relaxing soak in an oversized whirlpool tub and then retire to one of the four bedrooms upstairs.

Guest favorite
The exterior of a cozy country cottage is shown, featuring gray siding and a welcoming front porch. Large windows provide natural light, and the porch is equipped with an ample seating area. Surrounding greenery adds to the serene environment.
Cabin in Boonville
4.88 out of 5 average rating, 176 reviews

Boonville outdoor getaway!

Looking for Relaxation? That is just what you'll find in this cozy country cottage. You will enjoy your stay at this newly constructed country cottage. Whether your looking for just a getaway or a family trip the amenities nearby will entice everyone. From hiking, four wheeling, area events, local attractions and eateries. Awesome place for cookouts and camping. Come and make your own memories! :) has great WiFi if you have work to get done or just to browse the web.

Top guest favorite
A welcoming living area is presented with wooden walls and floors, featuring a pair of rocking chairs positioned around a small table. A dark wooden cabinet is visible, while a large window allows natural light to illuminate the space, offering a view of the outside landscape.
Cabin in Constableville
4.91 out of 5 average rating, 252 reviews

Summer and winter paradise getaway

Quiet, private, on atv trail. With a large pond. Close to Snow ridge for skiing. Old forge a short drive away approximately 30 min. Steak and brew restaurant only miles away. Fishing , hiking also close.Beautiful perennial gardens. Large yard. Secluded on 5 acres. The cabin is approximately 150 ft from the rd. We are dog friendly. Come stay. You won't be disappointed.

Guest favorite
The cabin features a distinctive A-frame structure with a welcoming porch and wooden steps. Lush greenery surrounds the entrance, complemented by flower beds. A light blue metal roof contrasts with the warm wooden exterior, offering a charming and rustic appeal.
Home in Forestport
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 780 reviews

"Pine Away" - Lifetime Memories!

Charming cabin! Woods of Forestport, NY. Open floor plan - 10 acres of land - Sounds of the melodic creek from your bedroom window - Just 5 miles from the ADK State Park - Full size basement with Ping Pong and Foosball tables - Outdoor adventures! Special request events available - "Wedding parties, Birthdays Parties, etc. Additional fee required - Minimum $100 - $1000"

Top guest favorite
The interior of a rustic cabin features two queen beds with patterned bedding in the foreground. A dining area with a wooden table and chairs is visible, along with a kitchenette. A small bathroom is accessible through an open doorway, illuminated by warm lighting.
Cabin in Woodgate
4.86 out of 5 average rating, 200 reviews

Matteson's Cabins

Our three cabins are located just inside the Adirondack Park boundary line. Each cabin is 400 square feet with a full kitchen, full bathroom, and 2 queen beds. For summer fun, we are located close to many state lakes, rivers and ponds. Winter time we are located directly on the snowmobile trail and within 15 minutes from cross country and downhill skiing trails.

Popular amenities for Otter Lake vacation rentals

  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. New York
  4. Oneida County
  5. Otter Lake