Become a host

Vacation rentals in New Holstein

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in New Holstein

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1
Top guest favorite
A rustic modern home is showcased, featuring a spacious wraparound deck surrounded by lush greenery. An inviting hot tub glistens in the sun, and an arcade room with various games is displayed, offering entertainment options for guests.
Home in Elkhart Lake

The LODGE in Elkhart Lake. —-Hot Tub & Arcade—-

Rustic modern home w/ hot tub, arcade & fireplace right on the edge of Elkhart Lake. Road America, great golf, The Ice Age Trail, & the Kettle Moraine are all at your doorstep. This cozy home is 4 blocks from the downtown of Elkhart lake. Yet it still has an acre to explore & enjoy nature. Only 4 miles from Road America. 2 bedroom w/ 2 extra sofa sleepers & 2 baths. Perfect for racers or romantic getaways. The arcade/Pinball room has over 10 games. Perfect base camp. We got your bases covered

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 301 reviews
Top guest favorite
The A-frame cabin is framed by lush greenery and colorful landscaping. A welcoming pathway leads to the entrance, featuring a spacious deck. The cabin's dark exterior contrasts with the surrounding trees, creating a serene and private atmosphere.
Cabin in Elkhart Lake

Elkhart A-Frame, Wooded Retreat near Road America

The Elkhart A-Frame is an ideal location for the adventure seeker who wants a unique and private experience that is still close to all the action. The home sits on a wooded three-acre private retreat only about a mile from the village of Elkhart Lake, Road America, and Golf Courses. This unique cabin was built in the 1970's but has been recently renovated with a fun Scandinavian modern flair. It has all the amenities for a memorable vacation stay that provides plenty of epic photo opportunities.

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 364 reviews
Top guest favorite
Home in Cleveland

Shoreline Serenity

Welcome to ''Shoreline Serenity''! 200 ft of Lake Michigan frontage w/unobstructed views that go on for miles and tucked away on a 2-acre lot offering peace & privacy. Inside the home, you will be drawn to the beautiful views through the full wall of east facing windows & patio doors. The interior is cozy, clean, and comfortable. Fully equipped kitchen w/coffee bar. Main level has (2) bedrooms including the primary bedroom w/fantastic views. The spacious upper level loft has a king & twin bed.

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 15 reviews
Top guest favorite
The two-story home features a beige exterior with multiple windows, surrounded by a grassy yard. Two chairs are positioned in front on a small patio area. Large trees provide shade, while a view of the countryside and other structures is visible in the background.
Home in Glenbeulah

Stay at Sunrise LLC, Like being at Grandma's

Welcome to Stay at Sunrise LLC. We offer a clean and comfortable home for your vacation enjoyment. We are in a rural area, recreation trail head is 3 miles east of us as is the Wade House, 7 miles from Road America. Large yard, Fire pit, picnic table, child swing set. Garage parking on site if arranged in advance. We do not have WIFI Phone reception for Internet is good. No Cable or Satellite TV, Over 32 antenna channels. Smoking is allowed outside of the home. No pets allowed.

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 152 reviews
Top guest favorite
A serene lakeside view features a setting sun casting warm hues over the water. A grassy area with neatly arranged seating faces the lake, while two trees provide a natural frame. Smooth stones and a pathway lead towards the water's edge.
Home in Fond du Lac

Spacious Lakefront 3Br 3Ba Home

Located directly on beautiful Lake Winnebago. Less than 15 minutes to Fond du Lac shops, bars, and restaurants. Conveniently only one hour from Milwaukee and Green Bay. Only 50 minutes to Whistling Straits, Kohler, and 30 minutes to Erin Hills! You'll enjoy a cozy three season room, a spacious patio with lots of seating, and large backyard with plenty of space for you and your family to enjoy! Nearby public golf courses include Whispering Springs, Rolling Meadows, and Far Vu Golf Course.

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 63 reviews
Top guest favorite
A remodeled kitchen and living area feature neutral tones and modern appliances. Bar stools are positioned at a counter, while a washer and dryer are present nearby. A dark brown armchair and a square ottoman are set on the soft carpet beside a small coffee table.
Cottage in Fond du Lac

Cozy Guest House with Lake views.

Our remodeled two bedroom Guest House is adjacent to our Cottage and offers beautiful lake views. Access to Lake Winnebago available at near by boat launches. Centrally located to many of Wisconsin's best attractions. Less than 1 hour from Milwaukee, Madison, Green Bay, Close to Oshkosh (EAA) and Elkhart Lake. Includes 2 bedrooms, with plush king and queen beds, 1 full bathroom, and a fully stocked newly remodeled kitchen. Perfect getaway for some R&R with family or friends.

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 321 reviews
Superhost
Home in New Holstein

Growe's Guest House - just like Grandma's!

Our beautiful private home is available for you! We'd love you to experience the peace and serenity we so much enjoy. We'll answer all requests AS SOON AS possible, hoping we can accommodate your needs. Come; be our guest; night, week, or month! Please note: there is NO overnight street parking Dec. 1- March 1. The private lot behind the house MAY provide permission on an as need basis. Please indicate # of cars and dates before reserving, so accommodations can be arranged.

4.85 out of 5 average rating, 155 reviews
Superhost
Home in Kiel

Fallon House in Kiel close to Road America

Nestled in the heart of Kiel, Fallon House offers a perfect blend of charm and convenience, mere moments from Road America. With 4 cozy bedrooms, 2 modern bathrooms, and essential amenities like WiFi, air conditioning, and a fully equipped kitchen, it's the ideal base for your adventures. Whether you're here for the racing thrills or to explore the local sights, come back to comfort and ease, making your stay truly unforgettable. Ideal for both families and groups.

4.5 out of 5 average rating, 4 reviews
Top guest favorite
A welcoming entrance features a spacious porch with a red accent wall and decorative flower boxes. Steps lead up to the front door, flanked by a laid concrete pathway and well-maintained grassy areas, providing access to the farmhouse.
Home in Malone

Blue Sky Country Living

Escape to our beautiful working family farm located in Wisconsin. You will feel at home in our completely renovated 100 year old two story farm house. Whether you want to take a walk through the woods, or just sit back and enjoy the view from the family porch, you'll have plenty of room to relax. Our home is a spacious & comfortable retreat, perfect for families or groups of up to 6 people. Your Friendly Family dog is welcome, ($35) fee. Sorry no CATS.

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 27 reviews
Top guest favorite
Earthen home in Elkhart Lake

Secluded Elkhart Retreat | Pool, Hot Tub & Sunset

Nestled just minutes from Downtown Elkhart Lake, this custom-built cordwood home offers a secluded sanctuary experience. Perched atop a hill, the unique 16-sided house provides breathtaking views of the state forest and surrounding farmland. Despite its remote feel, you’re only a 5-minute drive from the charming Elkhart Lake business district. Day hikes on the ice age trail are just steps away from the home. Tap the ❤️ to save this listing!

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 158 reviews
Top guest favorite
Home in Elkhart Lake

Holyland Hideaway

Relax in this cozy, remodeled two-bedroom home nestled in nature. Enjoy countryside views, new carpet, and a fully equipped kitchen. Located just 15 mins from Elkhart Lake/Road America and Kettle Moraine State Park, and under an hour to Lambeau, Milwaukee, and EAA. Local dining, including Schwarz’s Supper Club, Blanck’s Supper Club, and Roepke’s Village Inn. The owner lives nearby and is happy to help during your stay.

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 15 reviews
Top guest favorite
The sign for Red Willow Guest House is prominently displayed, featuring bold red letters against a white background. The surrounding landscape includes green grass and trees, with a hint of a barn visible in the background, creating a rural setting.
Home in Kiel

Red Willow Guest House

Renovated farmhouse located just 48 miles south of Lambeau Field and 50 miles north of Milwaukee. This guesthouse is the perfect vacation home for large family/group gatherings. The property is a retired dairy farm with acres of trees and grasslands to explore. The farmhouse is three miles east of Kiel, nine miles from Elkhart Lake, home of Road America race track and 18 miles to Blackwolf Run golf course in Kohler.

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 233 reviews

Popular amenities for New Holstein vacation rentals

KitchenWifiPoolFree parking on premisesAir conditioning

Other great vacation rentals in New Holstein

Guest favorite
The front exterior of a ranch-style home is shown, featuring a central entrance with an awning and windows framed in dark shutters. Lush green grass surrounds the home, and trees provide a natural backdrop. A driveway leads up to a garage on the left.
Home in Elkhart Lake

Elkhart Lake Village house

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 86 reviews
Top guest favorite
The exterior of a two-story house is showcased, featuring a light-colored facade and a spacious deck. The driveway is bordered by vibrant purple flowers and lush greenery, contributing to the welcoming atmosphere. A garage is visible, enhancing the home's functionality.
Home in Plymouth

Kettle Breeze

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 45 reviews
Top guest favorite
A sunlit sunroom features a cozy seating arrangement with two wicker armchairs and a spacious sofa adorned with blue and white cushions. Large windows provide multiple views of the surrounding greenery and the lake, allowing natural light to fill the space.
Home in Plymouth

Lake House-Kayaks/Paddle Boards/Private Pier

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 17 reviews
Top guest favorite
An aerial view showcases the expansive green fields of The Farm, framed by a large red barn and the homestead structure. The nearby farmland stretches towards Lake Winnebago, with patches of seasonal crops and scattered trees offering depth to the serene landscape.
Farm stay in Chilton

The Farm Unique Rural Lodging

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 54 reviews
Top guest favorite
Large windows draw in natural light, offering a view of the lake and dock below. The open living area features a comfortable seating arrangement and a central coffee table. Light-colored furnishings enhance the airy feel, with decorative accents placed around the space.
Home in St. Cloud

3-bedroom home on beautiful Wolf Lake!

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 13 reviews
Superhost
A rustic cabin exterior is featured, showcasing dark wood siding and a sloped roof. A small front porch is visible, and flower pots adorn the entrance. Lush greenery surrounds the cabin, with a low wooden fence providing an inviting boundary.
Cabin in Plymouth

Cabin moments away from Road America and Lakes

4.71 out of 5 average rating, 99 reviews
Guest favorite
The image displays a charming lakeside retreat with a well-manicured path leading from a private pier to the house. Two lounge chairs are positioned on the shore, surrounded by trees. The house features large windows reflecting sunlight, enhancing the serene lakeside view.
Home in Chilton

Family lake retreat w/ hot tub! Amazing sunsets!

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 66 reviews
Top guest favorite
An open concept kitchen and living area features a large island with seating for four, complemented by modern bar stools. Dark cabinetry contrasts against a brick wall, and stainless-steel appliances are visible, enhancing the functional design of the space.
Condo in Elkhart Lake

Car Condo Rental in Elkhart Lake

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 45 reviews

Destinations to explore