Vacation rentals in Mystic Lake

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Mystic Lake

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1
Top guest favorite
An outdoor dining area features a black metal table with four decorative chairs and plates set for a meal. A grill is positioned nearby, surrounded by lush greenery, creating a peaceful setting for al fresco dining.
Cabin in Red Lodge
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 430 reviews

Mountain cabin on Rock Creek w/hot tub.

Welcome to romantic, rustic log cabin sanctuary. NO SMOKERS/PETS. Relax surrounded by rushing waters and nature. Inside, cozy warmth, fluffy robes, bottle of wine, & snack. Upstairs is open living with gas fireplace. Each of the lower bedrooms have views of creek and woods. Outdoor decks with comfortable seating, hot tub, and fire pit are just steps from the creek. The cabin feels secluded but is only 3 miles to town, surrounded by hiking trails, and close to ski mountain. RIVER DANGER FOR KIDS.

Top guest favorite
A rustic log cabin is nestled among vibrant autumn foliage, with golden leaves contrasting against the wooden structure. The cabin features a porch and is surrounded by tall trees, while a mountain peak rises in the background under a clear blue sky.
Cabin in Reed Point
5 out of 5 average rating, 110 reviews

Packsaddle Butte Guest Cabin Retreat

The perfect getaway to a charming and cozy log cabin in stunning landscape bordering Nat'l Forest. Hiking and 4-wheeler trails abound. Next to a running creek and pond. Electricity, wood stove, outside toilet, heated outdoor shower, 2 twin beds, TV, BluRay player, microwave, mini fridge, firepit with grill/griddle and picnic tables. Idyllic porch for sitting under trees, birdwatching, reading, or relaxing. Snowshoeing, sledding, & cross country skiing in winter. Ideal for 2 adults w/cot for 3.

Top guest favorite
The exterior of a charming two-story home is displayed, surrounded by greenery and landscaping. A covered porch is visible with two chairs and a small table, welcoming guests. The walkway is lined with low hedges and rocks, leading towards a well-maintained yard.
Apartment in Red Lodge
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 133 reviews

Zen Den, 1 block from downtown

This cozy 1-bedroom apartment one block from downtown Red Lodge is the perfect mountain getaway. Just 15 minutes from Red Lodge Mountain, it features a fully stocked kitchen, smart TV, WiFi, and in-unit washer/dryer. Relax by the fireplace or gather around the fire pit. The well-appointed bathroom includes towels and toiletries, and the apartment offers heating and air conditioning for year-round comfort. With great amenities and a prime location, it's an ideal base for your Red Lodge adventure.

Top guest favorite
A vibrant blue exterior is complemented by warm wood accents and a welcoming front door, adorned with a seasonal wreath. Planters with orange flowers add a pop of color, while a wooden porch provides a cozy entryway.
Home in Red Lodge
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 170 reviews

Stephanie's Cottage

Stephanie’s Cottage is a charming and cozy house located just 1/2 block off the mainstreet, making it the perfect basecamp for your adventure. There are two queen bedrooms, providing the perfect space for a family of four or two couples traveling together. The clawfoot tub in the bathroom adds a touch of luxury to your stay. The living room and kitchen are cozy and well-equipped, giving you the option of staying in. And the best part? Your furry friend is welcome to join you on your adventure!

Top guest favorite
A rustic log cabin is set against a mountainous backdrop, featuring a wooden deck with a railing and small charcoal grill. Snow covers the ground and stones are arranged near the entrance, enhancing the natural surroundings of the property.
Cabin in Red Lodge
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 302 reviews

ALPBACH: Alpine Living #2

Rustic log cabin, with TV and WIFI, 5 miles South of Red Lodge in the Beartooth Mountains. Kitchen is completely furnished with refrigerator, dishes and cookware. Cabin has queen size bed, separate bathroom with shower, and small charcoal grill on the deck. Historic Rock Creek is adjacent to the property. The cabin is a short distance from Red Lodge Ski Mountain and surrounding hiking trails. Dogs are acceptable upon inquiry @ $10/night per dog. Room Heater. Convenient parking by cabin.

Top guest favorite
A log cabin exterior is shown, surrounded by snow-covered ground and trees. The porch features two wooden rocking chairs, creating a welcoming entry. Snowflakes fall gently, enhancing the serene winter atmosphere.
Cabin in Roberts
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 272 reviews

1865 Historic Cabin w/hot tub. Close to red lodge!

*Pls see other listing for winter bookings :) sleeps 2 in winter. Nestled in the town of Roberts, a short drive from Red Lodge, Kodow Kabin is a perfect retreat for a getaway. While the exterior is log, the inside is renovated & beautifully decorated. The cabin is 1 bed/1 bath for 2 guests w/ detached bunkhouse (may-Oct) for 2 more guests! The kitchen has a farmhouse sink, and cabinetry made from the siding that covered the logs. Use the private deck to BBQ or hot tub soak under the stars

Top guest favorite
A log cabin interior features a spacious bed with a patterned blanket, complemented by a cozy chair positioned near a large window. Exposed wooden beams and a rustic ceiling create an inviting atmosphere. Soft light is provided by a lamp beside the bed.
Cabin in Greycliff
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 198 reviews

The Buffalo Jump

Need a quiet place to celebrate your anniversary, have a night away from the hustle of work and life, or just passing through? You have found the right place. This restored historic log cabin is the perfect getaway. Conveniently located just off of I-90 in Greycliff. Enjoy a beautiful sunset in the hot tub or making memories around the fire pit! To top off your stay and make it the best experience, drive, 1/4 mile to the Greycliff Mill and enjoy a cup of coffee and a fresh cinnamon roll.

Guest favorite
A scenic view reveals a landscape of gently rolling hills and vibrant autumn foliage. Yellow aspen trees contrast with dark green pines, creating a colorful tapestry. The distant mountains provide a serene backdrop under a soft, cloudy sky.
Cabin in Nye
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 71 reviews

Quaint 1-Bedroom cabin, with sensational views.

Sitting in the shadow of the Beartooth mountains is our family cabin. The Cabin sits atop a bluff that overlooks the Westfork of the Stillwater river and next to a former art gallery. Riverfront access is a short walk down the bluff, with great trout fishing at your fingertips. Multiple national forest access points are a very short drive, that have great recreation opportunities and even better views. Wildlife sightings are a regular occurrence, but do watch for animals on the road.

Top guest favorite
Snow-capped mountains are prominently displayed in the background, framed by a picturesque landscape of residential homes and scattered trees. The clear blue sky contrasts with the mountain peaks, creating a serene and inviting scene.
Townhouse in Red Lodge
4.91 out of 5 average rating, 433 reviews

The Gem on Lazy M; Mountain Views, Hot Tub & A/C

This is truly a gem! Cozy, warm and inviting with uninterrupted views of the mountains, located on the golf course, just minutes from downtown. This home has A/C for the summertime months and a Hot Tub to soak in after a long day on the Ski Mountain. Enjoy the sun rise with a cup of coffee from the back patio and in the evening unwinding with a glass of wine as you watch the sunset from the front porch. This is the perfect place for your Red Lodge getaways. Truly home away from home!!!

Top guest favorite
A rustic cabin is nestled among tall trees, surrounded by lush green fields. A wooden fence encircles the grassy area, while mountains in the background provide a serene backdrop. The image conveys a sense of peacefulness and connection to nature.
Cabin in Mc Leod
5 out of 5 average rating, 227 reviews

Listen to the river!

Just amazing on the river. Quiet Your own private Montana . Jacuzzi with a view of the river and fire pit. Air conditioning. Tv -DISH local channels, movies, sports, music. DVD player. Golf course 22 miles away in big Timber good track great people . I have two sets of clubs here for you, camping gear also. Books and games! Restaurant and Bar 3 miles away, look up The West Boulder Roadkill Cafe a nice treat. Yellowstone National Park 1-1/2 hrs away.

Guest favorite
The living room features a red sofa, a patterned gray armchair, and a coffee table with a selection of books. A small dining area with high chairs is visible in the background. A map of the United States is displayed on the wall, complemented by modern decor.
Home in Absarokee
4.88 out of 5 average rating, 193 reviews

Absarokee - Cozy Cottage

This cottage is located in the heart of world-class fly-fishing, hiking, river rafting, and horse-back riding. At the base of the glorious Beartooth Mountains, we are 30 minutes from Red Lodge Ski Mountain, Tippet Rise Art Center and within two hours of Yellowstone National Park. Our property is within 100 feet of Main Street which features a local grocery store, laundromat, & restaurants plus the incredible nightlife is only a few feet away.

Top guest favorite
The front of a charming white house is showcased, featuring a wooden door and welcoming rocking chairs on the porch. A flower box adorned with white flowers hangs beside the window, and a flag can be seen in the background against a blue sky filled with clouds.
Home in Red Lodge
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 160 reviews

Home Sweet Home on Broadway

Less than a 5 minute walk to all that Red Lodge has to offer downtown. Whether you are here to enjoy the outdoors, drive the Beartooth Pass to Yellowstone or heading to Red Lodge Mountain to ski, Home Sweet Home on Broadway is your home away from home. Relax on the back deck, enjoy the hot tub and our fenced in yard. We are happy to welcome 2 dogs, but please remember to include them in your booking. We do ask a pet fee of $25.

Popular amenities for Mystic Lake vacation rentals

  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. Montana
  4. Stillwater County
  5. Mystic Lake