Vacation rentals in Lake Shelbyville

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Lake Shelbyville

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

A modern kitchen features sleek cabinetry and a spacious island with a marble-like countertop. Stainless steel appliances include a refrigerator and an oven, while a ceiling fan provides air circulation. A dining area with a wooden table is visible in the background, complemented by rich red curtains.

Home in Mattoon

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 219 reviews

Brickway Retreat

Newly Remodeled 2 Bed, 1.5 Bath home in quiet neighborhood. This modernized house features a large fully furnished kitchen that is open to the dining area. The large living room with 10 ft ceilings has a pull-out sofa. Big screen TVs equipped with Roku streaming service in the master bedroom and living room. Wi Fi throughout the house is included. Enjoy your mornings on the cozy front porch featuring cedar pillars and stamped concrete and enjoy your evenings on the back patio around the fire pit

Top guest favorite

A cozy sleeping area features a wooden four-poster bed adorned with white linens and a decorative pillow. Soft carpeting covers the floor, complemented by a window with sheer curtains, allowing natural light to illuminate the room. A small nightstand with a lamp and a chair are present.

Apartment in Shelbyville

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 100 reviews

Atop the Shop- Downtown Historic Charm

Atop the Shop is a newly restored 1800 sq ft space located in the heart of beautiful, downtown Shelbyville, IL. This apartment has all modern amenities with the historical character of the one- hundred year old building still intact. The spacious layout gives family or friends plenty of space to spread out and relax. The location is less than a block away from favorite restaurants and shops and just a mile away from the amazing Lake Shelbyville, popular for boating, beaches and hiking trails.

Top guest favorite

A cozy sleeping area features a spacious bed with multiple pillows in neutral tones. Wall sconces provide gentle lighting on either side. A decorative sign with the word 'welcome' is displayed above the headboard, adding a personal touch to the inviting space.

Apartment in Teutopolis

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 605 reviews

The Shoe Inn, a modern apt in downtown Teutopolis

Welcome to The Shoe Inn! You'll be at the center of town within walking distance to all the places you need to be: banquet halls, five bars, restaurants, Wessel's grocery store, ice cream shop, church, hardware store, and community parks. Smart lock, contactless entry is available for a convenient & safe stay. Enjoy the full size washer & dryer (no detergent provided) , fireplace, kitchenette (no stove), free parking, Samsung 50" smart TV w/ 100's of cable channels, Alexa device, & free WiFi

Guest favorite

The exterior of a spacious villa is presented under a clear blue sky. The building features a welcoming entrance with a covered porch and multiple windows. A gravel pathway leads to the front door, surrounded by well-maintained landscaping and green trees in the background.

Home in Sullivan

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 131 reviews

Lake Shelbyville-Lakeside Villas

Lake Shelbyville is the perfect place to spend your next vacation, reunion, weekend away you name it! Our property offers amenities shared among the villas; fully stocked pond, half basketball court, fire pits, playground, & backs up to a local popular camping ground, just minutes from the lake and marina! Inside our villas are fully equipped kitchens, washer and dryer, free WiFi, smart TVs, fully stocked with starter amenities to get your vacation started without rushing to the store!

Top guest favorite

The image captures a hot tub on a patio, framed by a wooden pergola. A round table with chairs is positioned nearby, with an expansive view of the sunset over open fields. The warm glow of dusk enhances the tranquil outdoor setting.

Cottage in Sullivan

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 199 reviews

Prairieview Cottage Retreat - Hot Tub Sunsets

REST, RELAX, RETREAT... Escape to tranquility at this picturesque, pet-friendly cottage, nestled in the serene countryside. Whether you're coming for a romantic retreat, family getaway, or a solo sanctuary, this charming haven offers a wonderful blend of comfort and serenity. Enjoy stunning sunsets from the hot tub, cozy up by the firepit on the patio, or simply unwind indoors in comfort. This retreat is ideally located in the heart of Illinois Amish country and near Lake Shelbyville.

Top guest favorite

An outdoor patio area features a square fire table surrounded by four wooden chairs. Lush green grass stretches out beyond the patio, with trees and open fields visible in the background, creating a serene setting for relaxation.

Home in Sullivan

5 out of 5 average rating, 238 reviews

3 Acres | Fire Table | Wildlife @ Lake Shelbyville

A completely renovated cottage, nestled in the country of Sullivan, just minutes from boating, camping, golf, theatre style shows, and more. If you are looking for peaceful nights, this place is for you! Surrounded by trees and nature where many days you will catch deer roaming the yard. Plenty of yard space for games, a fire table to converse around, and chairs on the porch to sit back, relax, and take in the tranquil sounds that surround you here at Lakewood Cottage.

Guest favorite

An open interior showcases a spiral staircase leading to a loft area. A wooden table with seating for four is located in the foreground, complemented by a small kitchen featuring appliances and exposed brick. Natural light enters through the windows, enhancing the warm tones of the space.

Home in Teutopolis

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 233 reviews

Wooden Shoe Factory, Historic, w/ Bar & Breakfast

Historic 1880 Wooden Shoe Factory by Wooden Shoe Maker Gerhard Deymann. A great getaway Tiny House from the past with a Bar & Books. Please take some & leave some :-) Fully furnished. Tons of charm. It has a loft, luggage lift, exposed brick/beams, fireplace, bikes, antiques, front sitting area, swing, grill, back patio, yard, private parking, appliances, vaulted ceilings. 6 minutes to I57, I70, Effingham, & dozens of restaurants. 1 block to 7 Teutopolis Bars, & diners.

Top guest favorite

The cottage exterior features a light-colored facade with wooden shutters framing the windows. A welcoming front door is complemented by a porch light. A small fountain is positioned on a stone pathway, with potted plants adding greenery to the front yard.

Cottage in Arthur

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 289 reviews

Sisters Cottage

A recently renovated Cottage, nestled in the heart of the small, quaint town of Arthur. Located next to the Arthur Park. Enjoy the clip clop of the horse & buggies going by as you relax out front on a swing, or enjoy the back porch with table & seating as you enjoy the perennial garden out back. Plenty of back yard for playing games. A fire pit is located close to porch for roasting marshmallows at night. Arthur is a very innovative town with lots of shops to explore.

Superhost

The home's exterior features a welcoming porch with red chairs, an American flag, and a landscaped front yard. The architectural design exhibits a combination of traditional elements with a pitched roof and wood siding. A concrete driveway leads to the front steps.

Home in Decatur

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 113 reviews

Cozy Cottage

Beautiful two bedroom one bath home. Finished basement. Full two car garage. Three car driveway. Gas oven with full size kitchen. Full size washer and dryer. Screened in back porch. Outdoor dining area. Queen bed and full size in bedrooms. Fold out sofa in basement. High speed WiFi with two smart TVs. Two blocks from Millikin University. 5 minutes to downtown Decatur. Quiet street across from elementary school. Come stay at our lovely little piece of Decatur.

Guest favorite

The entrance features a white door framed by blue and white siding. A welcome sign is prominently displayed beside the door, complemented by a potted plant at the base of the steps. Sunlight brightens the area, highlighting the welcoming ambiance.

Apartment in Arthur

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 267 reviews

The Hideaway - Charming apartment in Arthur IL

Enjoy exploring Illinois' largest Amish settlement while relaxing in this one-bedroom apartment one block from downtown Arthur, a village of 2200. Country charm abounds in this gem which sleeps three (full bed plus fold-out love seat). There is a private entrance, access to laundry facilities, and private parking off the street. We are 9 miles west of I-57 on Route 133 (take exit 203 at Arcola) and 40 miles from Champaign.

Top guest favorite

The exterior of Paradise Cottage features vibrant red wood paneling, with a stone path leading to a welcoming front door. Large windows allow natural light and views of the surrounding trees, enhancing the cottage's connection to its lakeside environment.

Cabin in Mattoon

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 169 reviews

Cottage on Lake Paradise,

Welcome to Paradise Cottage nestled on Lake Paradise! Cozy and warm with wood finishes throughout. Includes three-tiered deck/patio, with the lowest level sitting over the water. Perfect for fishing (this lake hosts an annual fishing tournament), canoeing/kayaking, or just relaxing. Great for bird watching, with great blue herons, egrets, ducks, bald eagles, plovers, cormorants, woodpeckers and other species seen daily.

Superhost

The exterior of a single-story house is shown, featuring a beige façade and a sloped roof. Front windows allow natural light, while a small porch is visible. A well-maintained yard includes green grass and neatly placed flower borders, offering a welcoming appearance.

Home in Arthur

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 275 reviews

Sojourners' Abode

Our family has enjoyed good experiences staying at AirBnb houses when traveling, so we decided to provide a place for others coming to our community. Arthur often has lots of activity, but this home away from home will be a peaceful spot for you to unwind. Just half a dozen blocks from downtown, but on a quiet dead end street. Round up a few friends & come enjoy your stay.