
Vacation rentals in Horseshoe Lake
Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb
Top-rated vacation rentals in Horseshoe Lake
Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

Lakeview Cozy Cottage w/ 2 bedrooms & 1 bath
Start your morning with a fresh cup of coffee while watching the sunrise over the lake. Less than 1 hour from NYC, enjoy your staycation in this updated cottage in a peaceful lake community. Relax on the patio while enjoying the tranquility of nature and creating wonderful memories. Less than 5 minute drive to swimming, watersports, boating, farms, wineries, and lots of great restaurants & bars. Less than 10 mins to Hopatcong State Park, 10 mins from Rockaway Mall, and 30 mins to Mountain Creek.

Adorable quiet & cozy lakefront studio on dead end
Welcome to your lakeside escape! This charming studio offers breathtaking views of the water- perfect for relaxing and peaceful sunsets. Tucked away at the end of a quiet dead end, you’ll enjoy the sounds of the lake. Whether you’re here for a weekend getaway or a longer stay, this is the perfect place to unwind, recharge, or work remotely in a serene setting. A short trip from NYC w/ great eateries, hiking, & shopping nearby. Enjoy the simple joys of lakefront living- you won’t be disappointed!

Ranch in the Woods | A Peaceful Designer Retreat
Welcome to @ranch_inthewoods No cleaning fee STR permit #34035 This newly built ranch-style home with thoughtfully designed wabi-sabi interiors sits in the woods of the Warwick Valley. It's located a short drive away from several lakes, hiking trails, breweries, and dining experiences. It features forest/creek views, designer furniture, modern appliances (dishwasher, washer/dryer, gas cooktop), smart 4k TV, gym & yoga studio, gas firepit, and ample deck with an outdoor kitchen & dining area.

Full Apartment near Hackettstown
Enjoy this private apartment connected to an 18th century stone house. It comes furnished with 1 1/2 bathrooms, a fully equipped kitchen, large living/dining room, and one bedroom with closet and a queen sized bed. We are located in the beautiful highlands of northwest NJ--about 60 miles from Lincoln Tunnel and 75 miles from Philadelphia. Nearby are historical sights, great hiking and skiing areas restaurants, brew pubs, and a train station. Private parking provided next to entrance.

Lakeside Home w/Lake Access, Dock & Water Views!
Enjoy amazing lake views from this absolutely gorgeous, modern lakeside home! Perfect destination for a mini-vacation, couples retreat or a family getaway. "La Vida Lago" is a completely furnished, single family lakeside ranch home featuring 2 bedrooms, 1.5 baths, deck, patio, private lake access and dock directly across the street. The property is perched up from the road and nestled into the mountain surrounded by trees! The ideal environment to connect w/nature, yourself and loved ones.

Contemporary Private Guest Studio close to NYC
Welcome to The Urban Guest Studio, a refined and modern retreat in vibrant Sayreville, NJ. Ideally located just off the Garden State Parkway and Routes 9 & 35, it’s a 40-minute drive to NYC and 30 minutes to Newark Airport. Enjoy quick access to the South Amboy Ferry, upscale shopping, top hospitals, Rutgers University, and New Brunswick’s cultural hub. Only 7 minutes from the iconic Starland Ballroom and 20 minutes to the PNC Bank Arts. Experience comfort, style, and effortless convenience.

Pocono Castle w/ Dungeon Escape Room &Private Pond
Sleep in a Fairy Tale at Pocono Castle! Live the dream in this 2,300 sq. ft storybook retreat, where you’ll sleep like royalty in a real fairy tale castle. Unwind in luxury with a bubbling hot tub, a cedar sauna, and endless magical touches. Dress up as Kings, Queens, or Knights and explore the grounds, featuring a private one-acre pond & maybe you’ll catch a Golden Fish! With enchanting bedrooms, outdoor adventures, and unforgettable charm, this is the OMG getaway you’ve been waiting for!

DWG Mountain Oasis-Private Apt w/Frog Pond
Private family apartment built for relaxing comfort and views of nature 2 miles from Mount Tammany, Mount Minsi, and the Appalachian Trail Walk to a private brookside trail and a winery Private deck Includes: Bread, eggs, pancake mix, coffee, tea, milk, bananas, s'mores kit, and more AWARDS: Top 1% of all Airbnb & #1 "Most Hospitable NJ Host" in 2021 Little or no host interaction – your choice Host lives on-site and can provide customized recommendations for food and things to do

Lakeside Style and Luxury
Tastefully appointed home on highly desirable deep water Davis Cove with stunning views of Lake Hopatcong. Fully updated home offers spacious bedrooms, two bathrooms, premium furnishings, beautiful landscaping, 50 Ft dock, lakeside deck/seating, hot tub, wood burning fireplace, game room, fully equipped kitchen, large outdoor grill, swimming, fishing, boating. Quiet side-street neighborhood. Outstanding guest service from your host. Don't just stay anywhere... make it memorable!

Serene Surroundings: Guest Suite in Sparta
Discover a hidden gem for your stay! Enjoy a peaceful retreat in this private guest suite with its own entrance and relaxing pond views. It’s the perfect spot for a getaway, a quiet place to visit family, or a comfortable space to work remotely while soaking in all that Sparta has to offer. Just five minutes from Lake Mohawk and a short walk to Tomahawk Lake Water Park, you’ll be close to local restaurants, cozy pubs, boutique shops, wedding venues, and scenic hiking and biking.

Cozy guest cottage with indoor fireplace
Take it easy at this unique getaway in the Poconos! This vintage one room cottage is the perfect space for soaking in nature, getting creative, or exploring the attractions of the Pocono Mountains. The cozy cottage is within 20 minutes of ski resorts, Kalahari, and the Delaware Water Gap national recreation park. Reach downtown Stroudsburg and it’s restaurants and nightlife within 7 minutes.

Riverwood Cottage• borders Bucks County state park
Wake up to fresh bagels and quiet countryside views. This charming guest cottage sits in the heart of Bucks County, surrounded by picturesque river towns and rolling hills. Enjoy fresh bagels delivered to your door on your first morning. Take a 5 minute drive along the Delaware River into Frenchtown for a day of exploring and dining. Close to New Hope, Lambertville and Doylestown.
Popular amenities for Horseshoe Lake vacation rentals
Other great vacation rentals in Horseshoe Lake

C&J Signature Stays Historic Renovated Apartment

Quiet room, queen plus twin bunk

Rm #1 Cozy Rm by Rutgers/Jersey Shore

Amazing View Lake Retreat

Room 1-45 minutes from NYC. Near bus stop

Cozy Apartment Near Lake Hopatcong

Home away from home. private and quiet

Private Cottage 1 BR 1BA on a quiet farm in NJ
Destinations to explore
- Plainview Vacation rentals
- New York Vacation rentals
- Long Island Vacation rentals
- Boston Vacation rentals
- Washington Vacation rentals
- East River Vacation rentals
- Hudson Valley Vacation rentals
- Jersey Shore Vacation rentals
- Philadelphia Vacation rentals
- South Jersey Vacation rentals
- Pocono Mountains Vacation rentals
- The Hamptons Vacation rentals
- Times Square
- Rockefeller Center
- Madison Square Garden
- Bryant Park
- New York Public Library - Bloomingdale Library
- Grand Central Terminal
- Columbia University
- Central Park Zoo
- MetLife Stadium
- Camelback Resort & Waterpark
- Mountain Creek Resort
- Yankee Stadium
- United Nations Headquarters
- Sesame Place
- Citi Field
- Empire State Building
- Pocono Raceway
- Radio City Music Hall
- Statue of Liberty
- Canarsie Beach
- Bushkill Falls
- USTA Billie Jean King National Tennis Center
- Blue Mountain Resort
- McCarren Park




