Vacation rentals in Goodyear Lake

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Goodyear Lake

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Top guest favorite

A charming red wood cabin is pictured from the side, featuring a welcoming front porch and a well-kept grassy yard. Surrounding trees and a clear blue sky with scattered clouds add to the natural setting. A lamp post stands on the gravel pathway leading to the cabin.

Cabin in Oneonta

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 159 reviews

Romantic Cozy Cabin with a View of the Wetlands

12 minutes from both Dreams Park and All Star Village! Perfect for a couple's getaway, a writing retreat, or a cozy home base to explore the area! This cabin was built in the 18th century but has all the modern amenities. It has an adorable fully-equipped kitchen, a charming wood interior, a vaulted ceiling, and a spacious outside deck with a view of the birdlife and wetlands. Swimming, hiking, and fishing on Goodyear Lake, 5 minutes away! Minutes from live music, cafes, and antique shops!

Top guest favorite

The cabin features a gabled roof and a welcoming front porch with seating, surrounded by lush green grass. Tall trees frame the property, and an American flag is visible on a nearby pole, indicating a serene and private retreat in nature.

Home in Franklin

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 102 reviews

Bohemian Cabin with Epic Views

Retreat to this Unique, Private Cabin on 14 private acres. Enjoy the vast mountain views and endless stars from the cozy front porch or the screened private balcony off the master bedroom. Enjoy the meditation chapel and office space in heated guest house. Eat from apple and peach trees. Essentials include pellet stove, washer/dryer, fire pit BBQ and appliances. 13 mins to the Cooperstown Baseball All Star Village. 2 miles to the Historic Village of Franklin. Vibrant Oneonta is 12 mins away.

Top guest favorite

The A-frame cabin is surrounded by vibrant autumn foliage, showcasing hues of gold and orange. A welcoming red door stands out against the green exterior. A wooden deck extends from the cabin, providing an inviting entry point amidst the natural landscape.

Cabin in Margaretville

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 180 reviews

The Waterfall Casita: A-frame with 30ft Waterfall

Nestled among Hemlock trees & steps from a 30 ft waterfall is our cozy A-frame cabin. Sitting on 33 private acres connected to state land, enjoy waterfall views while sipping coffee in front of the fireplace. The casita was intentionally designed to feel like a home away from home. In summer, cool off in the waterfalls & private streams, in autumn take in the stunning foliage & in winter ski/snowboard at Belleayre (25 mins away). Alder Lake & the Pepacton Reservoir fishing are a 10 min drive.

Guest favorite

A private deck area features a wooden chair beside a neatly stacked pile of firewood. The entrance displays a large sliding glass door, illuminated from within, revealing a warm interior. Soft outdoor lighting complements the natural surroundings of greenery.

Tiny home in Livingston Manor

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 134 reviews

Element House - Off Grid Hideout

Unwind and reconnect with nature in this rustic and comfortable retreat nestled at the edge of a blueberry field. Surrounded by serene Catskills countryside, you’ll feel a world away, yet still be just minutes from outdoor activities, a thriving food scene, and Bethel Woods just 35 min away. Inside, you’ll stay cool with AC, a cozy queen bed, kitchenette, dining table, reliable wifi, and full bath. Outside, relax by the fire pit or cook on the charcoal grill. We are an LGBTQ+ inclusive space.

Top guest favorite

The exterior of the cabin is showcased, featuring a wooden facade with a steeply pitched roof. A welcoming porch with wooden railings surrounds the entrance, leading to a front door flanked by windows. Lush greenery surrounds the cabin, enhancing its secluded setting.

Guesthouse in Delhi

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 153 reviews

Catskills Peakes Brook Cabin-Creek, Pond & Privacy

Take a breath at Peakes Brook Cabin, our cozy and private cabin on a pond, with the brook steaming beside it. Our beloved property is perfect for couples needing to escape the city, decompress and deplug. You're minutes to charming Delhi and other Catskill villages, with nature all around. We are very excited to announce that our cabin has a huge upgrade as of Spring '25. We now have a full bathroom with running water! A project over 3 years in the making. (Stayed tuned for new pics)

Superhost

A rustic cabin with a green metal roof features a spacious front porch adorned with comfortable seating. Large windows provide ample natural light, and a well-maintained lawn with trees offers a scenic backdrop. The tranquil setting invites relaxation and outdoor enjoyment.

Home in Oneonta

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 101 reviews

Lakefront, family friendly home -Baseball campers!

- Lake/waterfront home on Goodyear Lake. - Conveniently located close to local baseball camps (Cooperstown All-Star Village and Dream Park, etc.), SUNY Oneonta and Hartwick college - Large lake view patio and yard for games or campfires and lakeside deck and dock. - Enjoy swimming, excellent fishing, and watersports. Canoe, row boat, and pedal boat on site for guests. - Updated spacious home, including a fireplace and air conditioning. - Away from it all, but close to all amenities!

Guest favorite

The exterior of The Mill House is framed by lush greenery, featuring a welcoming dark wood door and two warm lights illuminating the entrance. A rustic mailbox stands nearby, surrounded by a tranquil natural setting.

Cabin in Walton

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 162 reviews

The Mill House: Creekside Catskills Summer Escape

Nestled in the heart of the Catskills and just a 2.5-hour drive from NYC, escape to a winter retreat where you can reconnect with nature and enjoy the serene beauty of the season. This historic gem underwent a meticulous restoration in 2021, marrying its saw mill heritage with contemporary luxuries, including a Nest thermostat, smart speakers, keyless entry, and fast wifi. Original exposed post and beam construction and Scandinavian-inspired design make for a unique and cozy atmosphere.

Guest favorite

A charming house is surrounded by vibrant autumn foliage. Large glass windows invite natural light, while a wooden deck extends from the structure. The lush green lawn enhances the inviting atmosphere, with a rustic fence bordering the property.

Cabin in East Meredith

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 116 reviews

Creekside rustic-modern A-frame in the Catskills

Our house is tucked into a quiet valley, perched above a creek and South-facing for all day sun! 21 acres of rushing creek, mixed evergreen and deciduous forest to explore. Firepits next to the house, and beside the creek. Nearby swimming, fishing, hiking, national parks. You’ll love our place because of the sound of rushing water, peace and solitude, and being able to truly get away from it all! The house is good for couples, groups, and pets. House insta account: hollow_cabin

Guest favorite

The log cabin features a sloped metal roof and large windows, surrounded by trees. A spacious wooden deck with a railing offers outdoor seating options. The area is adorned with fallen leaves, enhancing the natural setting.

Cabin in Margaretville

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 171 reviews

Catskills log cabin in the sky with mountain views

Welcome to Cabin in the Sky! At 1,671 ft elevation, Cabin in the Sky is a newly renovated log cabin nestled in the mountainside with tranquil views. The home offers the perfect combination of seclusion and convenience. In the mornings/evenings, enjoy a cup of coffee or glass of wine from the private deck which overlooks pure nature (not a car, street or building in sight). During the day, take advantage of the local hiking, skiing, farmer's markets, restaurants and shopping.

Superhost

A rustic cabin is nestled among lush trees, featuring a metal roof and warm, inviting windows. Soft lighting from the windows enhances the natural surroundings, while a stone walkway leads to the entrance, blending harmoniously with the forest landscape.

Place to stay in Downsville

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 185 reviews

Half Moon: Fairytale Catskills Retreat

Enjoy nature in style at this fairytale in the forest. This idyllic escape combines whimsical structures, curated gathering spaces and a private wooded hillside surrounded by hiking trails and quaint towns. Disclaimer: This is a rustic cabin. Heating is from a wood-burning stove, there is no AC. The bath house is a separate structure from the cabin, up a hillside with stone steps. Cooking is via charcoal grills, small outdoor kitchenette or fire.

Top guest favorite

A covered patio area features two turquoise chairs and a round table positioned on a wooden deck. A small refrigerator and microwave are visible in the background. A decorative rug adds texture to the space, while a nearby hammock invites relaxation.

Guesthouse in East Meredith

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 137 reviews

Lily Pad by the Ponds

If you want to experience nature, our homestead has a one room king bed cottage between 2 ponds. A private full bath is 25 steps away. Enjoy the serenity of the water. The cottage is insulated, heated, has electricity,Wi-Fi, and a smart tv to be used with your own accounts. The cottage is separated from our home by a garage. We leave guests uninterrupted unless they want/need anything. Guests have full use of the ponds and acres to enjoy!

Top guest favorite

The exterior of the A-frame glamp is shown, surrounded by lush greenery and tall trees under a blue sky filled with gentle clouds. A large window reflects the natural scenery, enhancing the connection to nature. The interior view captures a distinctive moon-shaped light fixture suspended from the high ceiling, complementing the triangular architecture.

Place to stay in Oneonta

5 out of 5 average rating, 216 reviews

Creekside of the Moon A-frame Cabin

Creekside of the moon A-frame glamp. Float, fish and play in the Catskills. Glamp on the Charlotte Creek in a newly built modern tiny a-frame. Sleep under the full moon. A giant moon light hangs over the bed(s) with a stunning reflection in the window at night over the creekview. Perfect for a romantic getaway, fishing trip, or glamping spot in the Catskills. Close to Cooperstown, NY IG @aframe_moon