Vacation rentals in Fair Haven

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 38 reviews

A cabin entrance is showcased, featuring a white door with a glass panel and two side windows framed by shutters. A small, decorative sign is mounted above the door. A white bench is positioned on the porch, complemented by a charcoal grill nearby. The surrounding area includes a green lawn.

Cabin in Sterling

The Chinook

This special place is close to everything, making it easy to plan your visit. A quaint cabin location on Main Street in Fair Haven is a great place to stay! Within walking distance of multiple restaurants, boat launch, stores and more! 2 miles to Colloca Winery & a 2 minute drive to Fair Haven State Park! Directly behind the cabin is a 6+ mile, well maintained trail that leads to neighboring towns!Perfect for walks or biking! Cabin is clean, comfortable and well equipped for a great stay!

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 28 reviews

The cabin's exterior showcases a light beige facade with white trim, complemented by a small porch area. A white bench offers seating near the entrance, which features a decorative sign. A pair of shutters frames the window, with a well-maintained lawn adding to the inviting appearance.

Cabin in Sterling

The Atlantic

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 23 reviews

A spacious garage structure is presented with a metal roof, featuring open parking space on a concrete slab. A Pepsi vending machine is visible to one side, with various vehicles parked within the garage area and outside, surrounded by trees.

Guesthouse in Red Creek

Hickory Woods

Our family welcomes you to our cozy loft located above our unused garage. Private entrance, place to yourselves, queen size bed with pull out couch that can sleep 2, Roku TV, extra linens, standup shower, heater and air conditioning and book nook. Note there is no stove, just a air fryer and griddle No pets allowed Minutes from Fair Haven and Chimney Bluffs. Gas stations and Dollar General in town Eats- Fullers Ice Cream shop, 104 Store Note- the garage is a metal roof, bad cell reception

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 116 reviews

An inviting living area features a sofa facing a wooden coffee table, with a full kitchen visible in the background. Natural light filters through the space, illuminating the comfortable king bed and the adjacent bathroom area.

Apartment in Oswego

Luxurious Private Apt 4 Best King Bed WiFi ROKU TV

Relax with the whole family, snuggle w a friend, or enjoy some time alone. This peaceful private apt suite is full of amenities you will love. Free 24hr parking, Most Comfortable King Bed EVER :), Sofa Queen Pullout bed, WiFi, 48 inch ROKU TV, Keurig, Full kitchen, Pots, Pans, 6 Place settings..., Dishwasher, Armoire, Chest of Drawers, USB ports on night stands, Huge Luxurious Shower w RGB lights - you can set the mood:), Bidet Toilet w Heated Seats, Dining area w 4 chairs Plus Much More

The spacious waterfront home is illuminated at dusk, with a sunroom featuring multiple large windows. A sandy beach area is visible in the foreground, accompanied by lounge chairs and a tree providing shade. The surrounding yard is lush and well-maintained.

5 out of 5 average rating, 28 reviews

4 King Bed Private Beach +Pet Friendly +Pickleball

Cherish family moments in our spacious 20’x30’ sunroom with 22 bay-view windows. Exclusive beach home with 180 degree stunning view, private 50' dock, walk-in beach, grass yard, movie room and campfire. Parking for 6+ vehicles. Sleeps 12-14 in 6 bedrooms, including 4 King beds, 1 Queen bed, 2 Twin beds. 3 full bathrooms and fully equipped kitchen. Create lasting memories at this tranquil Fair Haven Bay retreat, with private location offering bay views from 3 sides of the 3 story home.

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 157 reviews

A modern cottage exterior is presented, featuring a blue facade with white trim and a peaked roof. The property is surrounded by a well-maintained lawn, with a patio area equipped with outdoor seating. Flower beds add a touch of color near the entrance.

Cottage in Sodus Point

Jameson Bay Inn on Sodus Bay (Waterfront)

The Jameson Bay Inn is a completely remodeled cottage which sits on Sodus Bay. This upscale cottage has ample parking, all of the amenities your family may need while on vacation, and gorgeous views of Sodus Bay. The large master bedroom even has views of Lake Ontario! The Jameson Bay Inn includes dock space for a boat, jetskis, and/or kayaks - great for fishing! There is also a beautiful patio only steps away from the water where you can enjoy watching boats and wildlife.

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 40 reviews

Camper/RV in Sterling

Camp Galore - Sterling, NY

Come enjoy all of what Sterling & Fair Haven has to offer in a unique camping experience. Comfortably connect with nature in this OFF GRID experience with several amenities. Situated on 2 acres with Sterling Creek access. Enjoy s’mores by the fire or read a book by the creek. Fair Haven State Beach, Sterling Renaissance Festival, Sterling Nature Center, Colloca Winery and so much more only a few minutes away. Don’t let summer pass you by without staying at Camp Galore!

The exterior of the building features a large covered porch with several rocking chairs and a small table, providing a comfortable space to relax. A charcoal grill is positioned nearby, and large windows allow natural light into the interior. The surrounding gravel area is bordered by trees.

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 41 reviews

Holly's Place at Fair Haven Entire house

Escape to our serene getaway, perfectly situated near Fair Haven State Park and The Barn restaurant. Enjoy the local charm of the Pleasant Beach Hotel, Sterling Cidery, Stick and Rudder, Colloca Winery, and Brandon's, each offering local music. Located near the Sterling Nature Center, the Sterling Renaissance Festival, several boat charters and public boat launches. Take a short drive to Oswego College and Oswego Speedway.

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 162 reviews

A two-story home is presented, featuring a covered patio with seating. The yard is spacious and green, bordered by trees for privacy. A glimpse of water is visible in the background, enhancing the natural setting and providing a serene environment.

Home in Fair Haven

Fair Haven White House

Newly renovated home with a nice bay view, covered back patio, large yard for games and campfires, and shared limited water access for relaxing by the water. We have now decided to stay open year-round. Welcome all who love the activities and beauty of our area during November to March. We are one of the few rentals that are pet-friendly (with a small extra cleaning fee) and also allow a single night stay.

A single-story home is shown, featuring a light blue exterior with red shutters on the windows. A bare tree stands in the foreground, while fallen leaves cover the ground, contributing to the serene outdoor setting.

4.82 out of 5 average rating, 51 reviews

Cozy home in scenic setting

Cozy home in a scenic setting close to Fair Haven (less than a 5 minute drive), Fair Haven State Park (less than a 15 minute drive) and the lake (with a boat launch less than 5 minutes away), come relax and enjoy this part of the Finger Lakes! In fall time the colors are absolutely beautiful. We are open year round for all occasions.

A serene view of Little Sodus Bay is presented from a wooden deck. The water reflects the sky's blue hues, while a dock extends into the bay. A small boathouse is visible nearby, and green grass borders the deck, offering a peaceful outdoor setting.

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 20 reviews

West Bay Retreat

Two Bedroom house on Little Sodus Bay in fair Haven with deep water dock. Come enjoy sunrises and relax at our West Bay Retreat and watch sunrises and make lasting family memories. Home is located close to the channel to Lake Ontario and minutes from the village, wineries, restaurants, and state parks.

Vacation rentals for every style

Get the amount of space that is right for you

Cottages

Quaint homes, peaceful surroundings

Hotels

Stylish accommodations with great services and amenities

Unique stays

Spaces that are more than just a place to sleep

Popular amenities for Fair Haven vacation rentals

Gym

BBQ grill

Laptop-friendly workspace

Wifi

Air conditioning

Other great vacation rentals in Fair Haven

5 out of 5 average rating, 8 reviews

A charming cottage is nestled under tall trees, featuring a welcoming front porch adorned with red seating and hanging planters. An American flag adds a touch of character to the exterior, while a gravel path leads up to the entrance, enhancing the outdoor setting.

Cabin in Wolcott

Port Bay Cottage

A view of the lush green yard features various shrubs and trees, providing a natural landscape. The lake is visible in the distance, framed by surrounding homes, with a patio and fire pit positioned on the grass for outdoor gatherings.

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 10 reviews

Little Sodus Bay House

A two-story cottage presents a modern exterior featuring dark siding and large windows. A welcoming porch is accessed by a set of wooden stairs. The outdoor deck is bordered by a sleek railing, surrounded by lush green grass and trees.

4.67 out of 5 average rating, 30 reviews

Best view on the bay

4.83 out of 5 average rating, 35 reviews

The cottage features a sloped roof and a white exterior with brown shutters, surrounded by lush greenery. A spacious porch with screens graces the front, providing a view of the lawn and trees that enhance the property’s semi-private feel.

Cottage in Fair Haven

Large Rustic Cottage- Walk to State Park!

A cozy upper deck features a stone fire pit surrounded by several chairs, inviting evening gatherings. The serene water view reflects the colorful hues of sunset, framed by lush trees and a flagpole. Soft lighting enhances the tranquil atmosphere.

5 out of 5 average rating, 5 reviews

Vineyard View Cottage

The exterior of a two-story cottage is shown, featuring blue shingle siding and multiple large windows reflecting the warm hues of sunset. A well-kept grassy lawn surrounds the house, creating a serene outdoor setting amidst trees in the background.

4.79 out of 5 average rating, 97 reviews

Large Cottage On 5+ Acres Of Private Property

A sandy beach stretches alongside the gentle waves of Lake Ontario. Lush greenery and flowering plants border the shore, contrasting with the clear blue sky. A smooth driftwood piece is positioned on the sand, adding a natural element to the tranquil scene.

Cottage in Sterling

4.58 out of 5 average rating, 31 reviews

Lake side cottage Sterling/ Fair Haven, NY

A spacious living area features a large sectional sofa, positioned to face a mounted television. Natural light enters through multiple windows adorned with patterned curtains. A coffee table and side tables complement the cozy setting, with a subtle decor arrangement visible in the background.