Vacation rentals with a fireplace in Cortland County

Find and book unique fireplace rentals on Airbnb

Top-rated fireplace rentals in Cortland County

Guests agree: these fireplace rentals are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

Home in Homer

5 out of 5 average rating, 13 reviews

Monthly, Weekly Specials Little York Lake Home

Kick back and relax on this quaint Upstate New York Lake.YEAR ROUND. Stylish cottage fully equipped for your stay. Conveniently located between Syracuse and Cortland. Close to breweries, wineries, many great events and venues. Close to SU and Cornell and many other CNY colleges. Half hr to State Fair. But first enjoy boating, kayaking and swimming out the back door. This cottage is available for year round recreation. Including, snowmobiling and hiking. Walk to Little York Theatre Pavillion.

Superhost

Home in Cortland

4.67 out of 5 average rating, 3 reviews

Station House

This is an 1890 house, with a train station theme. You'll enjoy the comfort of large spaces and plenty of seating everywhere. Enjoy a mini games table. Every seat in the living room has a clear view of a 65" TV. The dining room has a train station diner vibe, with a menu and vending signs. The kitchen is fully stocked with plenty of dishes and a large refrigerator. Upstairs there are 3 spacious bedrooms with room darkening curtains and soothing decor for restful nights. There's also an office.

Top guest favorite

Chalet in Cortland

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 142 reviews

Cozy Hillside Chalet - Greek Peak/Cortland/Ithaca

*Hot Tub in 6/12/25* Hello there and thank you for considering a stay at my peaceful, hillside getaway! You'll find that this home is conveniently located just seconds from Greek Peak Mountain Resort, 10-minutes away from downtown Cortland, and 25-minutes from downtown Ithaca. Enjoy amazing views of the surrounding hills and two-acres of yard from the 360 sq. ft. back porch which runs the length of the home. The grill is ready for cooking and don't leave without a hang around the fire pit!

Guest favorite

Cottage in Homer

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 99 reviews

All Seasons All Reasons Lake house

Wonderful lake house! Clean sheets and beds are made!Kitchen is fully stocked with blender, gas grill, coffee pot, & dishwasher. Sleeping areas- 2 bedrooms on main level-each has a double bed, a loft w/double mattress(wooden ladder), downstairs a bedroom with bunk bed set and a futon. Excellent walk out swim area or jump off the dock with swim up ladder. Included firewood, use of kayaks. Great fishing. Come make great family vacation memories! SUNY Cortland is 8 and SU is 17 miles away.

Superhost

Home in Cincinnatus

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 50 reviews

Cozy chalet, at Unwine Vineyards.

Unwind at Unwine Vineyards is on 50 acres in central NY wine region. Joel and Mary have over 3000 young grapes and are owners of a wine and art gallery in PA. This cozy chalet is close to many attractions including Greek Peak, and the central NY wine tours. The home is spacious and sleeps 6 people, with all the modern amenities. Explore our beautiful property with trails that lead to a pond and through the vineyard with vistas. You will find everything you need for your home away from home.

Top guest favorite

Home in Cortland

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 115 reviews

Adorable 2-bedroom home

Adorable home built in 1890 and renovated in 2019. Easy on/off from I-81, centrally located in New York- making it a great location to stay while visiting multiple colleges in one trip. Including SUNY Cortland, TC3 (~15min), Syracuse University(~30 min), Cornell (~30 min) & Ithaca College (~40 min) *Walking distance to: SUNY Cortland Downtown/Mainstreet Cortland Starbucks Several amazing local restaurants & a grocery store. Great local ski options including Greek Peak and Labrador Mtn.

Top guest favorite

Cottage in Tully

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 62 reviews

Lakeside Retreat

This secluded Central New York cottage is perfect for lake lovers and nature enthusiasts looking for a cozy retreat! This 2-bedroom, 1-bath Tully Lake home boasts all the comforts of home, plus a screened porch, electric fireplace, and private dock for all of your boating desires. Laptop-friendly space includes excellent WiFi and plenty of areas to take meetings and focus. Be sure to ski at Song Mountain Resort, grab a delicious fritter at a nearby apple orchard, or just enjoy Tully Lake!

Guest favorite

Cabin in Truxton

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 34 reviews

Secluded Log Cabin in Pine Forest

Rustic 20 x 20 log cabin. Serenity abounds with no human noises anywhere. Borders 5500 acres of little-traveled Cuyler Hill State Forest. The cabin is next to a creek. Brand new deck on the babbling creek. Miles of untapped state forest surround the cabin. The Finger Lakes hiking trail is 0.5 miles through the forest and goes for 100 miles in either direction. New outhouse, deck, outdoor kitchen, and lean to. Off-grid and secluded. Fully private! No other structures around. Serene!

Top guest favorite

Cottage in Little York

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 86 reviews

Lakefront Cottage -Firepit, King BR, Lake Views

Escape to this cozy lakefront cottage on Little York Lake! This charming retreat offers a perfect blend of tranquility, adventure and picturesque views no matter the season. Enjoy direct lake access for swimming, kayaking, and serene moments. In winter, hit nearby slopes for skiing, or go ice fishing on the lake, returning to our charming cottage for a fireside retreat. This ultimate lakeside getaway for all seasons is an ideal choice for a couple, family or a group of friends.

Guest favorite

Guest suite in Cortland

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 114 reviews

Private Studio in Virgil NY

Private Studio with bathroom, kitchenette, WiFi, Fireplace, and Tv located on the lower level of a single-family home dating back to 1856. Shared access to the fenced-in yard with outdoor seating and fireplace. Centrally located in the heart of Virgil, NY, making your travels easily accessible to: Greek Peak Mountain Resort - 2 mi TC3 - 5 mi Cortland State University - 5.4 mi Cornell University - 15 mi Ithaca College - 17 mi Ithaca Hiking - 19 mi smoke-free environment

Top guest favorite

Farm stay in Virgil

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 81 reviews

Country Chic B&B near Ski Resort. Spacious 2br3bth

This stylish place is close to must-see destinations. Greek Peak ski resort with all season attractions, Suny State and Cornell University, Fingerlakes wine trails. This property boasts 2 large bedrooms with a spacious open concept living and dining area. Spectacular views from indoors and around the 6 acre grounds. Full renovation underway with all new floors, appliances, bathrooms, state of the art lighting and country chic decor. Pet friendly!

Top guest favorite

Farm stay in Cortlandville

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 130 reviews

1820's Quaint Rustic Farmhouse

Beautiful, spacious, two-bedroom private suite. The Farmhouse is located on 50 acres of farmland in our beautiful river valley. We are directly off the Cortland I-81 exit and are 30 minutes to Cornell, Ithaca and Syracuse. We are conveniently located near Greek Peak and other local ski areas. Great location for professors, parents, students, outdoor enthusiast and anyone exploring the Finger lakes! We hope you enjoy your stay and come back again.