Vacation rentals in Compass Cay

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Compass Cay

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Top guest favorite

A serene view of a private garden is presented, featuring lush green grass and a stone wall lining the property. Palm trees sway gently, framing the turquoise sea in the background, with a clear sky above enhancing the tranquil atmosphere of the landscape.

Home in Exuma

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 78 reviews

The Tree House

A sweet one bedroom, one bath cottage with stunning view of the turquoise sea. All the comforts of home ...... with a private beach!Separate living area has satellite TV, books, cards, fully equipped kitchen, plus a lovely balcony with beautiful view for your morning coffee or evening cocktail. We have kayaks and a paddle board for your use from our private beach. Snorkeling just off shore. Hammock and a tree swing. We provide beach towels, a cooler and beach chairs. You just add the beer!

Guest favorite

An aerial view of a serene beach reveals soft, white sand meeting clear turquoise waters. Lush greenery lines the coast, while charming beach houses dot the shoreline, surrounded by palm trees. Gentle waves create a rhythmic pattern along the beach, enhancing the tranquil setting.

Apartment in Harts

4.78 out of 5 average rating, 9 reviews

Beachfront Beauty, 3 Min From Marina & Resort #5

Nestled on Exuma’s longest, most pristine beach, our rental offers the perfect escape. Enjoy a prime location near Sandals and Grande Isles, with four delightful restaurants and a convenience food & liquor store just a stone’s throw away. Located on the serene northwest side, we’re only 3.5 miles from the airport. As friendly locals, we provide complimentary snorkeling gear to explore the vibrant underwater world. Your dream vacation starts here—book now and make memories that last a lifetime!

Superhost

Condo in George Town

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 114 reviews

Beautiful Beachside Luxury Apartment, Mainfloor ✨

Bright, beautiful, well-appointed luxury apartment on the 1st floor... Enjoy sun, sand & surf right at your doorstep! This affordable luxury vacation home rental has central A/C, wifi, large tv in the main room and both bedrooms, beautiful master suite, very comfortable 2nd bedroom, deck overlooking the water, kitchen, wifi, washer/dryer, dishwasher, etc., etc. Everything you need to have an amazing tropical beach vacation in one of the most beautiful places on Earth! 7 minutes to the airport!!

Guest favorite

A panoramic view showcases turquoise waters of Elizabeth Harbor, framed by lush greenery and palm trees. In the foreground, a pastel blue building contrasts with the vibrant landscape, while a serene beach area is visible in the distance under a clear blue sky.

Apartment in George Town

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 12 reviews

Sea-View Hillside across from hideaways

Sit on the deck overlooking Elizebeth harbor feeling the warm breeze on your face is just one of the things you will love about the Sea-View! This spacious Villa will have all you need for your vacation and more. It has been updated to have all the amenities needed but still keeping that Bahamian feel. It is one of three Bahama Bound vacation rentals. The owner and operator and prides himself of customer service and 5 star review. Lets plan the perfect vacation together for you and your family.

Guest favorite

A modern beachfront house is positioned among lush palm trees and sandy shorelines. A wooden dock extends into the clear waters, complementing the serene atmosphere. The sky features soft clouds, creating a calm backdrop for this secluded retreat.

Home in Great Exuma Island

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 84 reviews

Beachfront Bliss For Your Ultimate Vacation

This beach house is a secluded + modern beachfront vacation rental property w/awesome views of the most beautiful waters in the world! *Listed rate is for access to TWO BEDROOMS ONLY. (King & Queen bdrm) 3rd Bdrm w/ the 2 twin beds is addl $100 per night. Select more than 4 guests for rate. Airbnb will not allow us to list separately* Disconnect from the world on a quiet beach. Check out the reviews Located across from pig beach.Local restaurant is short beach walk for buffet & rent kayaks.

Guest favorite

Bungalow in Great Exuma

4.85 out of 5 average rating, 72 reviews

Modern home with private yard & steps to the beach

Escape to our beautiful vacation home, perfectly situated on the stunning island of Great Exuma. Centrally located, just a short drive from the airport and a 2 minute walk to the beach, our home offers convenience, comfort, and proximity to the island's natural beauty. Whether you want to visit beach bars, explore cays, simply soak up the sun, our home offers the ideal starting point. Make your Great Exuma getaway unforgettable with a stay at our home. We can't wait to welcome you to paradise.

Guest favorite

Apartment in Great Exuma

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 145 reviews

Beautiful Exuma Vacation on a Budget!

Located in beautiful Harts, Great Exuma, this newly renovated and furnished apartment comfortably accommodates 4 guests (2 couples). Our fully equipped kitchen offers a great way to eat in when desired. Only a five minute walk or one minute drive to a beautiful stretch of beach... It's yours to discover!! Mid sized car rental can be INCLUDED in your rental for only $50usd more a day! A phenomenal deal that will save you about $30/day when compared to car rental companies on the island!

Top guest favorite

Villa in George Town

5 out of 5 average rating, 20 reviews

Beach front- Ideal Quest Exuma, #19 Hideaways

Imagine relaxing on your spacious beachfront deck. Or unwinding over coffee or cocktails in your screened porch overlooking beautiful blue water. This well-kept beach villa is oceanfront with a sandy beach. Enjoy a large living area in this 2-bed, 2-bath villa. Amenities include use of the resort pool, shuttle to Georgetown, workout room, game room and front desk services. The Villa is located central on the island and includes free parking. On site restaurant Splash Bar and Grill.

Top guest favorite

A wooden staircase leads down through lush greenery to a sparkling blue ocean. Tall trees and shrubs frame the steps, creating a serene pathway that highlights the natural beauty of the tropical surroundings.

Cottage in Rolleville

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 83 reviews

Point of View - new, cozy cottage on quiet beach

The name, "Point of View," says it all. Nestled on a quiet beach with the most spectacular views of the Atlantic Ocean is this tropical home away from home. Enjoy tranquility with the exception of the waves crashing against the shore away from the usual sounds of the city. This 1 bedroom 1 bath, fully furnished piece of paradise is ideally located for the guest looking for pure comfort and relaxation. It is situated at Exuma Point located on the northern end of Great Exuma Island.

Top guest favorite

A serene stretch of sandy beach is framed by lush greenery and adorned with two blue adirondack chairs. The calm ocean can be seen in the distance, with gentle waves lapping at the shore under a softly glowing sky.

Townhouse in Moss Town

5 out of 5 average rating, 43 reviews

Jimmy Hill Beach villas,a perfect vacation getaway

Whether you're looking for a romantic getaway or planning a trip for the entire family, our amazing beach villas are just what you're looking for. Surrounded by a private beach, you can wake up to the sound of therapeutic waves. The bedrooms are equipped with king/queen sized beds on the second floor and a queen-size pull-out couch downstairs. The villas are equipped with A/C, WIFI, Netflix, a fully equipped kitchen, along with a patio area with grill for outside dining.

Superhost

A beachfront view is captured, showcasing a clear blue ocean and sandy shore. Lush palms frame the scene, while a paved area with seating invites relaxation. A cart is positioned nearby, suggesting convenient access to beach essentials.

Bungalow in George Town

4.61 out of 5 average rating, 18 reviews

Beautiful Villa just steps away from the beach!

This great vacation home with beach front view right off the ocean! One bedroom 2 full bath with pullout couch will easily sleep 4 and has all the amenities you need to have a great vacation!! Also available is a pool and exercise room on site. Super convenient is Splash restaurant right within the same area! Also take advantage of the free paddle boards and beach accessories included! Check out the pictures of the amazing getaway place!!

Superhost

The image captures a serene beach scene, with soft white sand leading to clear turquoise waters. A gentle breeze rustles the leaves of nearby trees, while a bright blue sky adds to the tranquil atmosphere.

Apartment in Rolleville

4.69 out of 5 average rating, 29 reviews

Rolleville Darling House 2-Bedroom Unit

Tucked away down a winding path off the main road in the historic settlement of Rolleville, Exuma, the Rolleville Darling House is the perfect secluded getaway. If you’re craving my favorite P’s – peace and privacy – then this hidden gem is just what you’re looking for. Offering a serene escape from the hustle and bustle, the house invites you to disconnect, recharge, and soak in the tranquil beauty of Exuma.