Vacation rentals in Cincinnatus

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Cincinnatus

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1
Guest favorite
Cottage in Oxford
4.93 out of 5 average rating, 164 reviews

✨Lakeside Reflections

🚣‍♂️ Lakeside Reflections is a year-round lakeside cottage in the quiet upstate NY countryside with pristine views of Lake Gerry. 🌻 Come enjoy a peaceful nook of historic Oxford complete with gardens, decks, docks, boats, and modern amenities. ♨️ Grill out on the lakefront deck, or fish directly off the deck! 🛶 Jump in the lake, or take a kayak, paddle boat, or walk around the lake. 🔥 Have a campfire (BYO wood) 🎟️ Enjoy one of the many local attractions (see our Airbnb guidebook for ideas)

Guest favorite
Chalet in Willet
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 164 reviews

Lakefront Retreat: Hike, Fish, Campfires, Kayaks

Welcome to Sunset Chalet — your private lakeside escape. Set on peaceful waterfront property, this cozy retreat is perfect for relaxing and enjoying nature. Swim in the private pond, kayak on the lake, explore trails, or unwind around the fire pit under the stars. Enjoy: • Lake access • Private swimming pond • 2 kayaks + canoe • Fire pit • Private setting Close to Greek Peak, Ithaca, waterfalls, hiking, and Finger Lakes wine trails. Reserve early — summer and peak weekends book quickly.

Top guest favorite
A spacious living room features two comfortable gray sofas and a decorative coffee table, positioned around a large screen TV. Natural light filters in, enhancing the warm tones of the walls. A small side table with a lamp adds to the cozy ambiance.
Apartment in Greene
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 216 reviews

New Downtown Greene Apartment *no cleaning fee!*

This spacious one bedroom apartment overlooks peaceful downtown Greene. A quaint little village known for its unique shops and chic restaurants. This apartment gives you 1000+ sqft of a home away from home, equipped with all the amenities: washer/dryer, full kitchen, living room, bedroom, & off-street parking. This beautifully designed, modern apartment is perfect for the business traveler or family staying for recreational purposes. One bedroom with a pullout couch & air mattress, sleeps 6.

Superhost
Apartment in Cincinnatus
5.0 out of 5 average rating, 5 reviews

Cozy Apartment with Arcade & Games

Experience comfort, style, and fun in this beautifully renovated 2-bedroom apartment located in Cincinnatus, New York. Perfect for couples, families, or small groups, this cozy space blends modern living with shared, hotel-style entertainment amenities designed to make your stay relaxing, easy, and memorable. Whether you’re here to unwind, spend quality time together, or work remotely, this apartment offers a warm and welcoming atmosphere with unique features rarely found in a 2-bedroom stay.

Guest favorite
A vibrant red dock extends into a calm lake, framed by trees displaying autumn foliage in shades of orange, yellow, and green. The scene captures a peaceful lakeside setting, enhancing the natural beauty of the surroundings.
Cottage in Smyrna
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 103 reviews

Hidden LakeFront Retreat

A modern designed Cozy Cottage With a stunning mirror lake Surrounded by NYS lands! Cool off in the summer and snowmobile in the winter all the way to Canada! Hike all year round We provide two kayaks for use but no motor boating allowed. 100 acre lake! (Medium size is 10 to 100) No fishing license or fee required We also have two six person Rafts relax with family and friends! Make time for your weekend getaway! Get back to nature! Uncork Unwind and Unstress! An all season getaway!

Top guest favorite
A private fire pit area is set on lush green grass, surrounded by several light wooden chairs. In the background, Song Lake glistens under the sun, and a private dock extends into the water, providing access to the serene scenery.
Cottage in Tully
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 384 reviews

Lakefront Getaway - Relax & recharge on Song Lake!

Private lakefront getaway on Song Lake! Spectacular rural setting with room to roam. Enjoy views of autumn foliage by day, relax by the firepit at night! Private deck & dock - bring your kayak and fishing gear! Fully equipped kitchen. Outdoor gas grill. 5 min to Onco brewery. 2 min to Heuga's Alpine & Song Mountain. Ski/snowmobile in winter. Year round access to Finger Lakes wineries, breweries, spas. 25 min to charming Skaneateles dining & shopping. Near 6 colleges including Cornell & SU.

Top guest favorite
A charming cabin is positioned on a grassy knoll, showcasing a wraparound porch with wicker chairs and decorative elements. The structure features a combination of stone and wood materials, with a sloped roof and large windows allowing for natural light.
Cottage in Oxford
5.0 out of 5 average rating, 412 reviews

Beaver Palace Studios and Estates relaxing getaway

Your total getaway from the city and/or hectic life. We offer a very private and personal space for you to unwind and relax Everything on the property is handmade/built by owners. The grounds are very private. There is an abundance of wildlife and 50+ acres of private grounds to explore. Both owners are artists and world travelers. This stay is casual, relaxing and a real get away from it all. Hosts just down the lane for any assistance. Please book accurately # of people and # of pets.

Top guest favorite
A two-story white house is framed by green shutters and a welcoming front porch. The yard features a light dusting of snow, with patches of grass visible. Trees provide shade while a driveway leads to a parked blue vehicle in the background.
Guest suite in Cortland
4.86 out of 5 average rating, 178 reviews

Conveniently located private suite in Central NY

Clean, comfortable, one-bedroom suite located in one of the best areas of Cortland! Only a 5-min walk to Yaman park where you can sit down for a nice picnic, swim in the beach area, fish, or kayak in the Tioughnioga river. Easy commute to Syracuse 40 mins or Ithaca. Located 40mins to 8 golf courses, and 4 ski resorts. Walking distance to grocery stores, laundromat, coffee shop, restaurants, a fitness center, bus route, and city owned rental bikes all located within just a few minutes.

Guest favorite
The riverfront cabin is set amidst tall trees, with warm exterior lighting illuminating its entrance. A wooden deck leads to the front door, while the surrounding landscape features serene greenery and gravel pathways, capturing the tranquil evening ambiance.
Cabin in Greene
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 158 reviews

"Wilma" - Riverfront Cabin

This recently improved riverfront cabin, has a style all its own. Open entertainment space extends on to the 40 ft long deck. The many windows and doors allow nature in, complementing the locally sourced live edge countertops in the kitchen. Beautiful views are seen of the lush landscaping, river and distant mountain, from every room. The kitchen offers all ammenities, such as a dishwasher, large french door style refrigerator, and a ton of storage along with ample countertops.

Top guest favorite
Cabin in Hancock
5.0 out of 5 average rating, 65 reviews

Lakefront A-Frame | Hot Tub, Sauna, Fire Pit

Escape to Hancock A-Frame, a romantic lakefront hideaway tucked into the woods of Hancock, New York. Designed for couples, this serene retreat offers direct lake access just steps from the back deck—perfect for swimming, paddleboarding, or launching the canoe right into the water. Relax on the deck with a hot tub, lakeside sauna, grill, and intimate outdoor dining overlooking the lake. Very cozy and surrounded by nature, it’s a perfect year-round escape for two.

Top guest favorite
The cabin is positioned on a grassy area, with a serene pond visible nearby. The structure features a sloped roof and wooden siding, surrounded by lush green hills. A clear sky at dusk displays the moon, creating a peaceful ambiance.
Cabin in Newark Valley
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 31 reviews

Cozy cabin with pictureous views

Relax at this unique and tranquil getaway. Sit on the deck and watch the Scottish Highlander cows graze (or even feed them by the fence) to watching the Koi fish by the pond u will enjoy the peacefulness of the country. The position of the cabin is ideal for Sunrises and Sunsets that brighten the sky. State Game Lands 1/2 mile away. Also wine trails and waterfalls around an hour away. 20 minutes to Binghamton area, 30 minutes to a casino, 45 minutes to Ithaca

Guest favorite
A white farmhouse with classic black accents is set against a backdrop of lush green grass and trees. The two-story building features a welcoming front porch and large windows, while a distant church spire can be seen through the trees.
Farm stay in Cortland
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 182 reviews

1820's Quaint Rustic Farmhouse

Beautiful, spacious, two-bedroom private suite. The Farmhouse is located on 50 acres of farmland in our beautiful river valley. We are directly off the Cortland I-81 exit and are 30 minutes to Cornell, Ithaca and Syracuse. We are conveniently located near Greek Peak and other local ski areas. Great location for professors, parents, students, outdoor enthusiast and anyone exploring the Finger lakes! We hope you enjoy your stay and come back again.

Popular amenities for Cincinnatus vacation rentals