Cottage vacation rentals in Casey Key

Find and book unique cottages on Airbnb

Top-rated cottage rentals in Casey Key

Guests agree: these cottages are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1
Top guest favorite
The view from the dock features calm waters reflecting sunlight, with a backdrop of palm trees and charming homes lining the canal. Wooden posts mark the dock, while boats are visible along the shore, enhancing the peaceful coastal atmosphere.
Cottage in Matlacha
4.9 out of 5 average rating, 166 reviews

Mojito Island Cottage

Update: In September 2022 we were affected by Hurricane Ian. We had just over 5 feet of flooding in our treasured cottage. We have worked tirelessly to put everything back together. All new tile, walls, electric, lighting, furniture, and we even improved the bathroom! Spacious tropical home with water view from our back yard lanai. Boat Dock with Cleaning Fish Station, BBQ beautiful sunsets with fish jumping in our canal. New large kitchen and one block from art galleries, restaurants and bars.

Top guest favorite
An open living area features tiled flooring and soft lighting, with comfortable seating arrangements including a sofa and armchairs. A dining area is visible, showcasing a wooden table with chairs. Decorative touches such as artwork and a side cabinet enhance the space's charm.
Cottage in Sarasota
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 101 reviews

Quaint Cottage,150 steps away from Crescent Beach!

Nestled on the serene Crescent Street, this classic 1969 cottage, is just a short walk to the ground quartz sands of Siesta Key. The 500 sq foot private brick paver and stone backyard off the screened in lanai is fully fenced with custom built stainless outdoor kitchen, featuring a large grill, refrigerator, custom built stone bar with seating for 8 . Nearby is a blue glass gas fire pit with a seating area, over sized (9 ft. diameter) in ground "spool", loungers and a large circular daybed.

Guest favorite
A vibrant outdoor area features a swimming pool surrounded by lounge chairs and tropical plants. A separate upper level apartment is visible, showcasing a light blue exterior. The enclosed patio area provides shaded seating, enhancing the inviting space for relaxation.
Cottage in Siesta Key
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 130 reviews

The Mermaid: Heated Pool, 4 Houses to Beach

This apartment is a first-floor unit with an open floor plan that sleeps 2 with a maximum of 4 people. The bed makeup in this rental is a king bed in the master and a queen size sofa sleeper. This rental is great for longer stays or guests who like to cook since you have a full kitchen and all the items to cook any meal. There is a washer/dryer in the apartment. Beach chairs and umbrellas are supplied to you at no charge. This is a duplex and has another 1 bedroom 1 bath apartment above you.

Top guest favorite
An aerial view captures the coastline of Manasota Key, showcasing the blue-green waters and sandy beach. The surrounding area features a mix of residential buildings and green spaces, with multiple boats visible in the water and a bridge connecting to nearby islands.
Cottage in Englewood
4.9 out of 5 average rating, 168 reviews

Unit #1 Free kayak/bikes/walk to beach/fullcottage

Unit #1 Beach cottage very private and quiet, has a full kitchen, King bed in the master and queen sofa bed in the tv room, very comfortable, fast WiFi, AC & heat. All you need to relax and just have fun. Outdoor shower and laundry area, Private parking, Enjoy amazing sunsets/fishing/and restaurants and bars, all walking distance to the beach and bay. Kayaks/snorkel gear/beach toys are included. So start enjoying the beautiful sandy beach on Manasota Key, Lots of sea life and turtles.

Superhost
The cottage features a welcoming exterior with a screened-in lanai, framed by decorative beams and charming window boxes. Lush greenery surrounds the property, and a large tree adds to the tranquil setting. A pathway leads to the front door, enhancing the inviting atmosphere.
Cottage in Sarasota
4.8 out of 5 average rating, 280 reviews

Cozy Cottage by the Bay

Charming and historic decorator cottage near Downtown Sarasota. Located in the highly desirable, quiet, and safe neighborhood of Indian Beach - Sapphire Shores. Just a short drive to some of the nations top rated beaches like Siesta Key Beach. One of the best features of the home is the enclosed lanai at the front of the house. Perfect for enjoying Florida's coveted indoor/outdoor living. It has a private fenced in backyard, with a fire pit. Off street parking for 2 cars in the driveway.

Guest favorite
An aerial view captures the expansive Siesta Key coastline, showcasing a stretch of sandy beach meeting calm blue waters. Nearby buildings and lush greenery punctuate the landscape, highlighting the serene environment just minutes away from the cottages.
Cottage in Sarasota
4.79 out of 5 average rating, 149 reviews

Siesta Key Cottages Crescent 1B Beach/Pool/Hot Tub

4 separate BRAND NEW inside (renovated 12/24) 2 bedroom/2 bath (+Queen Sofa Bed+ Chair/Bed) pool homes (Each sleeps 7) ONLY A 4 MINUTE WALK TO SIESTA KEY BEACH #1 in USA (no major streets to cross): First Class! 2 Heated Pools, 2 hot tubs,2 gyms, Smart TV’s in all rooms, fine linens, towels, bikes, beach equipment, private porch, grill, fire pit, outdoor shower, private parking: Great restaurants / nightlife in walking distance. Running/Walking: You have miles of beach to take in!

Guest favorite
A private pool is surrounded by a paved area, featuring two lounge chairs positioned near the water. Green foliage adds a natural touch, while a white fence encloses the space, creating a secluded atmosphere. The clear blue water reflects the sky, inviting relaxation.
Cottage in Sarasota
4.93 out of 5 average rating, 137 reviews

Private Heated Pool Casita Near Downtown & Beaches

Built in 1925, Our Casaita Verde 2 Bedroom, 1 Bath home still retains its vintage charm but with modern touches. Enjoy watching the 55 inch flat screen TV with HD cable and stay in touch with the world with WI-FI internet. Lounge by the private pool or take in the beautiful evenings on the deck with your favorite beverage. Pet Friendly! Conveniently located near Downtown Sarasota on Bahia Vista with easy drive to Lido Key, our World Famous Siesta Key or I-75 for longer adventures.

Superhost
An open living space features a fully equipped kitchen with wooden cabinetry, a dining table, and seating area. A flat-screen TV is mounted on the wall. Light-colored flooring enhances the spacious feel, while natural light brightens the room through multiple windows.
Cottage in Siesta Key
4.87 out of 5 average rating, 282 reviews

Siesta Key Sanctuary -Pool-Kayaks-TikiHut-King bed

*Siesta Key elevated villa at Solitude Suites on Siesta Key. *Your own detached private villa, located in a small resort. *Waterfront resort w/ heated pool, kayaks, table tennis & Tiki Hut. * Just a 10-12 min walk to award winning beach. *1 Bedroom w/King bed. *1 full bathroom w/shower. *Large kitchen, open living room, fully furnished inc towels & linens. *Private lanai w/ table & chairs. *Beautiful shared pool w/ sun shelf & waterfall. *2 min car ride to beach. *Updated!

Guest favorite
A cozy porch area features a hanging swing adorned with colorful cushions, complemented by a small dining table and chairs. The entrance is framed by green lattice work, creating a welcoming space. A sign with the text 'WELCOME' is mounted on the wall.
Cottage in Siesta Key
4.86 out of 5 average rating, 176 reviews

Adorable Cozy Silver Sands Cottage on Siesta Key!!

Adorable one bedroom "Old Florida Cottage" on the intracoastal bay side of Siesta Key. This is a stand alone cottage, ground floor, no elevators or flights of stairs to mess with. New Pool with a tiki hut, fishing dock, boat basin (up to 24'), beach access 4 min. walk across Midnight Pass Rd. to the #1 beach with the whitest, softest sand you'll ever see! Hi Def TV in LR , Wifi, TV in BR, Keurig in the kitchen, stocked with everything but your clothes and toothbrush.

Top guest favorite
Cottage in Bradenton Beach
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 159 reviews

Darling Old Florida Beach Cottage Steps From Gulf!

Fully Renovated Coastal Gem! Welcome to Cottage By The Sea — a beautifully updated retreat just steps from the sugar-white sands and turquoise waters of the Gulf of Mexico on Anna Maria Island. Tucked away in the peaceful community of Bradenton Beach, this charming escape is one of the few remaining “Old Florida” cottages, lovingly restored with modern touches and cheerful, sun-filled décor. Leave your worries behind and unwind in your own slice of island paradise!

Top guest favorite
A vibrant yellow cottage is surrounded by a sandy area with palm trees. Colorful adirondack chairs in pink, blue, and green are positioned on the white gravel. A covered outdoor seating area is visible to the side, enhancing the beachside environment.
Cottage in Bradenton Beach
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 229 reviews

Bradenton Beach Sunsets 2, Anna Maria Island, FL

Fully furnished water view beach cottage located on beautiful Anna Maria Island directly across the street from white sand beach and Gulf of Mexico. 1 Bedroom 1 bath unit that sleeps 4 with the queen pull out couch. Beach chairs/umbrellas/Boogie boards/laundry room, etc. provided. Three blocks from historic Bridge Street with lively restaurants and bars. Free island trolley and across the bridge from Cortez fishing village. Free off-street parking.

Top guest favorite
A row of brightly colored Adirondack chairs is positioned on the sandy beach, facing the tranquil ocean. The hues include yellow, orange, green, blue, pink, and purple. A clear blue sky with soft clouds complements the serene shoreline.
Cottage in Nokomis
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 173 reviews

Staycation Sanctuary

Our property is clean and welcoming. You can enjoy a relaxing, warm and peaceful getaway from the rest of the world just steps to the beach. This is the perfect "Old Florida-style" location to experience the comfort and hospitality you so deserve! Grab your bathing suit/flip flops and enjoy tranquillity of beach life, sunsets and lazy days of fishing and bird/dolphin/manatee watching and gathering sea shells-- all only 2 blocks away!

Popular amenities for Casey Key cottage rentals

  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. Florida
  4. Sarasota County
  5. Casey Key
  6. Cottage rentals