Vacation rentals in Brooktondale

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Brooktondale

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1

Top guest favorite

An aerial view showcases a spacious two-story home surrounded by lush greenery and expansive fields. The property is nestled within a natural landscape, with rolling hills visible in the distance. A small red structure is positioned nearby, complementing the serene surroundings.

Farm stay in Brooktondale

Oasis Retreat Nestled in Nature

Nestled on 14+ picturesque acres, this spacious 2-bedroom, 2.5-bathroom loft style home offers a unique blend of comfort, serenity, and adventure. Just 12 minutes from Cornell University and Ithaca College, this haven is perfect for families, couples or anyone seeking a peaceful escape while still being close to downtown Ithaca. The kitchen and office boast ample workspace with beautiful western views. (1st floor is owner-occupied) Come discover the Finger Lakes region from this unique hideaway!

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 17 reviews

Top guest favorite

A scenic view of a spacious green lawn, featuring five red Adirondack chairs arranged around a stone fire pit. In the background, the two-story carriage house stands with a wrap-around deck, surrounded by lush trees and distant rolling hills under a partly cloudy sky.

Home in Ithaca

Ithaca Carriage House: Scenic Views & Fire Pit

Idyllic pastoral setting with peaceful green valley & distant lake views. Cozy carriage house with wraparound deck, fire pit, bbq, cornhole, & disc golf basket — perfect for family fun & relaxing after waterfalls, trails, wineries & cideries. Breakfast items & coffee provided! Sleeps 6 with wood-burning fireplace, 3BR/2BA, W/D, DW, A/C, EV charging & solar power. 5 min to Ithaca College, 8 min to Buttermilk Falls, 10 min to Cornell, 15 min to Cayuga Lake & Farmers Market, 20 min to airport.

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 158 reviews

Top guest favorite

A spacious living area features a large leather couch, two upholstered chairs, and a wooden coffee table. Wall decor includes a round clock, and a ladder-like rack displays a cozy throw. Natural light brightens the room through a well-positioned window.

Guest suite in Brooktondale

Modern Country Retreat! 15min to Cornell & IC

Private apartment in a country setting, attached to main house with beautiful views. Separate Entrance. Peaceful location and proximity to gorgeous hiking/waterfalls or winter skiing. Enjoy wildlife, the sunrise over the valley and the vast farmland that surrounds the home. Driveway parking. Contactless Check-in. Conveniently located. 15min to downtown Ithaca, Treman and Buttermilk Falls. 6 miles to Shindagin State Forest and Six Mile Creek Winery. 4min to the famous Brookton Market Cafe.

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 141 reviews

Guest favorite

The entrance to 'The Hobbit House' is framed by lush greenery and features a distinctive wooden door in deep red. The charming exterior showcases a combination of shingled textures, with a shaded porch adorned by a wooden pergola and decorative string lights.

Farm stay in Brooktondale

Farmstay Scottland Yard-Hobbit House dogs welcome!

Scottland Yard farm stay, 'The Hobbit House' Come enjoy our little piece of paradise. We are located 10 easy miles from Ithaca NY in the beautiful Finger lakes region! we are less than 1/2 day trips from NYC, NJ, PA, Rochester and Buffalo. We have consistently been Airbnb super host for 6 years! We have seasonal glamps and cabins, but are now offering our favorite little hideaway year round! Enjoy the gentle peaceful flow of life just breathing the sweet air here at Scottland Yard Farm.

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 122 reviews

Top guest favorite

A living area is furnished with a bright turquoise sofa and a yellow chaise lounge. A wooden coffee table is centered on a soft gray area rug. Colorful artwork adorns the wall, complemented by a round mirror and a stylish lamp in the corner.

Condo in Ithaca

Sauna Getaway in the Finger Lakes

Newer (2020 built!) scandinavian style apartment with sauna. This private flat occupies an entire lower level of a house and includes all new finishings, new mattress, kitchen, full bathroom, and laundry. Just 4 miles from Cornell and 5 miles from downtown Ithaca and Ithaca College, this popular stay is perfect for parents visiting students, couples celebrating a special occasion, friends needing an escape, or anyone craving a romantic or adventurous getaway. Longer stays are also welcome.

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 177 reviews

Superhost

A modern kitchen features sleek cabinetry and an island with seating. Stainless steel appliances, including a refrigerator, are prominently displayed. Large windows provide views of the surrounding woods, while a dining table with white chairs offers a space for meals.

Home in Brooktondale

Modern Nordic Chic: Stylish Retreat Near Cornell

No checkout chores! Welcome to our 3 bedroom 1.5 bath home nestled in the Ithaca woods. Built in 2022, enjoy modern accommodations and comforts with easy access to both city and country. Wake up to a quiet view of the river while being less than 10 minutes from downtown Ithaca and Cornell. Grab lunch at the market and enjoy some small-town vibes, stop by the local winery, or just stay home and hang out on the private beach. Cornell is about 8 minutes away and IC is about 6 minutes away.

4.8 out of 5 average rating, 112 reviews

Top guest favorite

Apartment in Brooktondale

The Barn close to Ithaca, Cornell and I.C.

The Barn is a newly renovated upstairs apartment located on a horse farm. There are pastoral views and you can see the horses from your window. The apartment is on 45 acres with a pond and beautiful nature walks. The property is 9 miles/15 minutes from Cornell, Ithaca College and downtown Ithaca. We back up to Shindagin Hollow with 20 miles of trail for mountain biking, hiking , birding or snowshoeing. We are located in the Finger Lakes with wineries and breweries galore.

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 33 reviews

Top guest favorite

A comfortable living space features a light teal chaise sofa accompanied by a plush ottoman. A neutral area rug enhances the setting, while large front windows allow natural light to fill the room. A flat screen TV is placed atop a simple cabinet, with a wooden chair nearby.

Home in Brooktondale

The Trestle House

Explore all Ithaca has to offer, while staying in the beautiful Hamlet of Brooktondale, NY. Located just 6 miles from Cornell, Ithaca College, and downtown Ithaca, this single family home is the perfect place to unwind and relax. Cayuga Lake, Fingerlakes State Parks, and many hiking/biking trails are just a short drive away. This historical home was built in the 1850s and has been tastefully remodeled to include modern updates while keeping it's farmhouse charm.

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 81 reviews

Top guest favorite

A cozy seating area is adorned with a gray sofa featuring orange accent pillows and a warm throw blanket. A wooden coffee table with a cushioned top sits in front, complemented by a colorful chair and a standing lamp that provides soft illumination.

Apartment in Ithaca

Sweet Country 3 Bedroom Apartment

There is a 2 nite min. stay for most weekends. The price listed is for 2 guests. Each additional guest, after the first 2, will be $30/nite (reflected in quote when you enter the correct # of guests.) Beautiful 8-12 minute drive to downtown, Cornell & IC. The 3 bedrooms include a queen room on 1st fl. & queen & twin rooms on 2nd fl. Full, modern kitchen w/ stove/oven, microwave, dishwasher. WiFi, movie channels on the 2 TVs, small deck, 2 umbrella tables.

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 684 reviews

Top guest favorite

A warmly lit living area features a red couch and a grey armchair, arranged around a wooden coffee table. A vintage rug anchors the space, with a large cabinet displaying books and decorative items. Natural light fills the room through tall windows.

Apartment in Brooktondale

Vintage charm close to Ithaca, Cornell and I.C.

This quaint 2 bedroom apartment is located in a converted 1800’s boarding house in the darling hamlet of Brooktondale. It has old original charm with modern updates, plenty of light, a fully equipped kitchen, and new comfortable queen mattresses with luxury linens, powerful shower and soaking tub. There is high speed internet, washer and dryer. A perfect place for a longer stay or for visitors to rest up after a busy day exploring the area.

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 171 reviews

Top guest favorite

Home in Ithaca

10 min to Ithaca • Green Retreat • Infrared Sauna

Unwind in your private Sunlighten infrared sauna at this peaceful, eco-conscious retreat 10 minutes from the Ithaca Commons. Premium mattresses, deep tub, fully updated 3BR/2BA, and spacious kitchen. A calm, clean space to recharge after exploring the Finger Lakes - minutes from Cornell, Ithaca College, waterfalls, gorges, and Finger Lakes wine country. Note: One half of a quiet duplex – private entrance, parking, and sauna.

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 102 reviews

Guest favorite

A cozy corner features two seating options: a rocking chair and a reclined chair, both positioned around a small circular table. Simplistic wall art in calming blue and green tones adorns the walls, complementing the warm wood flooring.

Home in Freeville

Peaceful get away.

Relax with the whole family at this peaceful place to stay. Easy 10 minute drive to Cornell and local shops and resturants. Large yard and peaceful atmosphere with ourdoor firepit charcoal grill and dinning table. Surrounded by wooded areas and close to hiking trails and waterfalls. Enjoy the local wineries and breweries and many other unique places and restaurants.

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 118 reviews