Vacation rentals in Pymatuning Reservoir

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Pymatuning Reservoir

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

A cozy sunroom features large windows allowing natural light, framed by wooden walls and ceiling. Two metal chairs and a rocking chair are placed beside a small table, which holds a lamp. A door leads to the outside, enhancing accessibility to the surroundings.

Home in Andover

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 219 reviews

Hockran Family Farms Guesthouse

Fabulous Farm House - built in the 1940's this farmhouse is a family treasure. Fully renovated and modernized this home is a great place to relax and find some peace in a great small town with an abundance of local activities. This home is a great place for those seeking spiritual renewal or some quiet family time away, including all you nature lovers to the Pymatuning Lake State Park both in Ohio and Pennsylvania. This home is fully staffed by a great caretaker and local owner. Come Enjoy!

Guest favorite

The rustic cabin is framed by trees and features a welcoming porch with seating. Large front windows allow natural light to fill the space. A gently sloping yard leads to the entrance, providing access to the inviting outdoor area.

Cabin in Andover

4.78 out of 5 average rating, 103 reviews

Cozy Cabin 2 bedroom (Ohio side Pymatuning Lake)

Take a step back and make time to create some wonderful memories at our cozy, rustic 2 bedrm cabin built in early 50s. Hiking/boating/fishing near! Basic cable/HBO/Starz!/Encore HDTV; DVD player. Microwave, drip coffeemaker, toaster,griddle, crockpot, pans, dishes,utensils. Linens,towels; quilts and cozy comforters on beds. Furnace/AC/Woodburner Cozy coffee deck off kitchen. Gas grill; firepit area with seating. Plenty of room to park/plug in boat or pontoon. ☆Not a party cabin. ☆NON-SMOKING.

Top guest favorite

An inviting outdoor space is shown, featuring a large hot tub surrounded by a spacious deck. A fire pit sits nearby, and a gas grill stands ready for use. Two chairs and a round table are positioned to create a comfortable gathering area.

Home in Garrettsville

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 426 reviews

“Willow Ledge at Silver Creek”with Private Hot Tub

New Construction Modern Ranch House features rustic upscale design with beautiful cozy interiors and comfort at every turn. Stunning views await with floor to ceiling windows overlooking beautiful Silver Creek and surrounding nature. Private deck is spacious and inviting with oversize hot tub, concrete fire pit, gas grill, and outdoor dining furniture. A few minutes from great restaurants, the Brewery at Garrett’s Mill, and the coolest Coffee Shop. Perfect weekend getaway or business stay.

Top guest favorite

A calm lake is illuminated by a warm sunset, reflecting golden hues on the water surface. Docks are visible on either side, with boats anchored peacefully. The scene is framed by trees and grassy areas, creating a serene natural setting.

Cottage in Jamestown

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 200 reviews

Cottage on the Cove

Small, quaint cottage on a private cove with a view of beautiful lake Pymatuning. Perfect for a couple or individual seeking relaxation,enjoying nature or great fishing. Close to state park for hikes and boat launch. In winter months, this is the perfect spot to warm up after ice fishing, snowmobiling or cross country skiing. In the warm months, you are close to the Gatehouse Winery, Mortals Key Brewery and Carried Away Outfitters. Our lake and surrounding country roads are very picturesque.

Top guest favorite

A serene view of Pymatuning Lake is captured, showcasing calm waters under a clear blue sky dotted with fluffy white clouds. Lush green trees frame the left side of the image, providing a peaceful natural backdrop.

Apartment in Jamestown

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 140 reviews

The White Brick Inn at Pymatuning State Park

Situated steps from Pymatuning Lake and the marina. The property backs up to Pymatuning State Park which offers bird watching, frisbee golf, nature & bike trails, etc. The unit is newly updated to provide you all the comforts of home. Please note that because of the age of the home and it's location we operate on well water. We do provide bottled water and a brita system for our guests. If you are staying more than a few days, we recommend bringing your own water if well water is an issue.

Top guest favorite

A serene campfire scene displays vibrant flames flickering above a stack of logs, surrounded by rocks. Two individuals are seated nearby, hands intertwined, enjoying the warmth of the fire. The surrounding area features natural ground covered in leaves and grass.

Tiny home in Burghill

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 247 reviews

The Creekside Cottage

The Creekside Cottage is quietly located on our 240 acre property. If you're looking for a quiet "get-away" then our quaint, studio cottage is for you. We have a queen bed. Outside, we have a fire ring with firewood, grill, outdoor seating, and beautiful view. We DO NOT have TV/internet, or WiFi, although most phones get service. There is a small kitchenette but there is NO oven/stove. We DO have a toaster oven, microwave, mini-fridge, coffee pot Keurig, coffee pods, and bottled water.

Guest favorite

The interior space features warm wooden walls and a high ceiling with a large clock as a focal point. A comfortable seating area with a leather couch and decorative pillows is present. Large windows allow natural light, while a patterned area rug adds texture to the floor.

Cabin in Cortland

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 181 reviews

Cheerful Cabin-Sleeps 5 - lake views + relaxation

This unique place has a style all its own. This adorable cabin is located steps away from Mosquito Lake, bars and restaurants, bait shops, public boat launch and minutes away from lovely wineries. Perfect for small families or couples. This cabin has been professionally designed and updated. Relax on the deck and listen to live music during the summer months. The sleeping space is a loft separated by a wall. Queen bed on one side, double bed and a single up top on the other side.

Superhost

The loft bedroom is designed with an A-frame structure, featuring a king bed draped with a cozy blanket. Natural light filters through a large window, illuminating plants and seating areas. Warm wood accents add texture to the inviting, spacious atmosphere.

Cottage in Tidioute

4.84 out of 5 average rating, 158 reviews

The Allegheny A-Frame

Experience the beauty of the great outdoors while enjoying the modern comforts of the Allegheny A-Frame. This recently renovated 1960s A-Frame is perfect for anyone looking to relax and immerse themselves in nature. Sitting minutes from the Allegheny National Recreational Forest & Allegheny River, there is plenty of opportunity to hike, kayak, canoe, fish and more. Retreat to the A-Frame to cozy up by the Malm fireplace, play games, and cook a meal in the fully stocked kitchen.

Guest favorite

Two comfortable, oversized bean bag chairs positioned beside a small wooden table. A potted plant adds a touch of greenery, while a decorative piece stands on the table. A patterned rug lays underneath, complementing the warm tones of the seating area.

Cottage in Linesville

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 161 reviews

Lake Escape. Cottage with hot tub & fireplace.

Unwind in our lakeside cottage with hot tub. Nestled against Pymatuning State Park, it's just a 3-minute stroll to the lake and minutes from the Marina for boat launches & rentals. Our renovated cottage is fully equipped for your stay, conveniently located near local dining, cafes, wineries, breweries, swimming spots, disc golf, and hiking/biking trails. Feel the call of nature as you bring your boats bikes, kayaks, fishing gear, and paddleboards to enjoy all the lake has to offer.

Top guest favorite

The open concept living area features wooden walls and ceilings, accentuated by bright natural light from the windows. A spacious sofa and a single red armchair are arranged around a wooden coffee table. A staircase leads to the loft area, enhancing the cabin's charm.

Barn in Kinsman

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 253 reviews

Cozy Cabin in Kinsman

This is a western themed, open concept cabin. The cabin is the upper level of a barn-like structure, separated from our home by a large patio. It has a Loft and a Sleep n’ Play Hideaway for children. (The double bed inside the Hideaway is suitable for teens and even adults.) Our cozy cabin is perfect place for either a couple, a few friends or a family. It is also a wonderful place for a retreat or a place to work away from home or the office. (See photos for clarity of layout.)

Guest favorite

A compact bathroom features wood-paneled walls and a shower area enclosed by a white curtain. A white toilet is positioned beside a small window, allowing natural light. Fresh towels are neatly arranged, and a decorative wall sign adds a subtle touch to the wooden decor.

Cabin in Cortland

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 409 reviews

Cozy Countryside Cabin Near Multiple Wineries

Our cozy and inviting cabin, the Eagle's Nest, is nestled in a countryside setting behind Greene Eagle Winery and Brew Pub in rural Northeast Ohio. If you are looking for charm, and quiet relaxing comfort, this 384 sq. ft. cabin with exposed cedar beams is your perfect overnight or weekend retreat. Many activities available in the area with Mosquito lake nearby, bike trails, state park, golf, shopping, wineries, breweries, and restaurants within 10 to 30 minutes.

Guest favorite

Home in Jamestown

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 22 reviews

Charming Lake House Steps from Pymatuning

Welcome to Jean’s by the Lake. Tucked away in a private lakeside neighborhood surrounded by the State Park. This beautiful property boasts huge windows, vaulted ceilings, and classic lake house décor. This home has all the amenities you’ll need for a perfect stay. Whether you are looking for a relaxing getaway, spending time with family & friends, visiting local wineries, boating, kayaking, or fishing we have everything you need.