Vacation rentals in Pine Island Center

Garden Cottage - Tiny House

PLEASE NOTE: The cottage is separate from our house and living quarters. The bathroom is in the back of the main house, just a few steps from the cottage, private and not shared with anyone. We take special precautions to thoroughly clean and disinfect the bedroom and bathroom after each guest. You’ll love our place because of the location, the ambiance, the outdoor space, and the neighborhood. We have a dog and a cat. Our place is good for couples, solo adventurers, and business travelers.

The Little Yellow Retreat with boat parking

Welcome to The Little Yellow Retreat! Your cozy escape on Bokeelia Island awaits. This charming home features a bright living room, fully equipped kitchen, and cheerful bedrooms, perfect for families, couples, or solo travelers. Relax in the lush backyard with fruit trees and a covered patio, or walk to nearby restaurants and a pool. Two scooters are available for $20/day for both, perfect for exploring the island. Beaches and marinas are close by. Your island getaway is waiting—book now!

Boaters Paradise: Private 1/1 with FREE parking!

Escape to your own peaceful slice of Southwest Florida! This cozy 1-bedroom offers everything you need for a comfortable, laid-back stay — just 1 mile from the famous Matlacha Bridge, known as “The Fishingest Bridge in America!” Perfect for solo travelers, couples, or boaters, this unit features a full kitchenette, private bath, and comfortable living area. You’ll also have access to FREE onsite parking for boats, trailers, RV's, etc. and be close to three public boat ramps within a mile.

Susie's Old Florida Cottage

Explore Pine Island & the Florida Gulf Coast from this retro 2-room cottage set in a pretty back yard. 45 min from Ft. Myers Beach/Sanibel. Wi-fi, A/C, kitchen, v small bathroom w/shower, 1 bedroom, cozy private deck, screened lanai. Perfect for 1 or 2. Avoid the motel feel & enjoy your privacy. Discounts for weekly/monthly bookings. No beaches on PIne Island, but enjoy kayaking, birding, biking, tennis, boating, & fishing. May 2023: Pine Island is still recovering from Hurricane Ian.

Studio in Paradise

Welcome to a little slice of paradise… You’re on island time now. Tucked back in a quiet neighborhood, this perfect little getaway provides the ultimate relaxation. Soak up some sun and sip libations while laying out at the resort style pool surrounded by lush vegetation. See the beautiful wildlife that visits the property. Take a short drive to the best tiki bars with nightly live music, or drop the boat at the nearby ramp for some world class fishing and miles of pristine beaches.

The Bokeelia Cottage

This tiny home is perfect for those seeking a peaceful retreat from every day life! Located in the quiet little fishing town of Bokeelia. Minutes from several boat ramps, restaurants, and the Bokeelia fishing pier. Take the local ferry out to the outside islands like Cayo Costa, Captiva, or Cabage Key or enjoy your time on the beautiful front porch overlooking your own private pond. Catch and release is always welcomed and don't be surprised if you see wild peacocks passing through!

Matlacha Paradise! NEW Waterfront Home-Free Kayak

Matlacha is for LOVERS! Lovers of relaxation, fishing, art, friends, social scenes and enjoying Life in a beautiful location ON THE WATER! Matlacha had damage from Ian. Our new home - none. You can still walk to great restaurants, shops and the fishing bridge. Enjoy the water in Matlacha & the Barrier Islands. Use our 1 person kayak for fun or fishing from our 8'X22' FUN & SUN deck docked in the back canal with picnic table & loungers. Relax, sun, grill and fish.

Bountiful Bokeelia

Seasonal rental, January February March available to book for all three months. You’ll be glad you did!! Forget your worries in this spacious and serene oasis. Professionally decorated, Coastal Chic, extremely quiet, 3 acre fenced and gated property off the beaten path on Pine Island. So close yet so far away! The immediate mainland has all that you could possibly need. The property boasts a unique natural swimming pond.

Pine Island Pelican Suite: privacy, pool, gardens

Welcome to the Pelican Suite! Secure, private entrance, king bed, living area with kitchen and patio. This suite is separate from the upstairs main house. Adults only. King bed, ensuite private bathroom with shower; AC. WiFi, cable, TV. Exclusive use of screened guest lanai - kitchen, fridge, BBQ, gardens, secluded heated pool. Free parking. The Pelican Suite is ideal for a relaxing no-stress break in the sun!

Sunny Island Cottage w/ Large Patio

This charming one bed/one bath home is very spacious, tiled throughout, and includes a large privately fenced in back patio to enjoy the Florida weather. This home is outfitted with mini split AC, newly renovated bathroom, and a washer and dryer inside for your convenience. This home is located near two public marinas and boat, so you are welcome to park your boat trailer on our spacious property

Serenity by the Sea

Come enjoy the island life. Bring your boat and enjoy fishing in the Gulf of Mexico. FREE use of boat dock. Large driveway that will fit boat trailer and cars. 3 bedrooms with queen beds. 2 bathrooms. Full kitchen. Dining room with table for 6. Plenty of seating inside and outside of home to spread out and relax. Close to Pine Island Center and Matlacha.

Paradise Found! - 3/2 Pool Home

Escape to our Tropical Oasis in Bokeelia, Pine Island, Florida! This 3-bed pool home offers comfort and style. Enjoy a private pool, lush surroundings, and amenities galore. Minutes from SWFL's best beaches, Cape Coral, Fort Myers, Matlacha, and Pine Island's restaurants and shops. Book now for a perfect blend of relaxation and adventure!