Vacation rentals in Pigeon Key

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Pigeon Key

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Top guest favorite

A sparkling in-ground pool is visible in the foreground, surrounded by a spacious patio. Lounge chairs are positioned along the deck, offering views of the lagoon. Lush palm trees provide shade, while a clear sky enhances the tranquil atmosphere of the waterfront setting.

Home in Marathon

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 145 reviews

Cancellation Deal; Sept 27 thru Oct 04; Save now!

2025 - New concrete dock, fenders & fish filet table. This ground level waterfront home has received a new face lift. Completely remodeled 3 bedroom with bonus room in the well known Sombrero Beach neighborhood. Just a short block walk to the sandy beach shore. Home has an open floor plan overlooking the in-ground pool deck and new tiki hut. Enjoy your morning coffee and happy hour in the screened-in porch with views of the wide lagoon. Come and create your family memories in the fabulous Keys.

Guest favorite

A covered Tiki Hut is featured at the waterfront, furnished with comfortable seating arrangements. Views of the water and dock are visible beyond the structure, framed by lush greenery and palm trees. The space is designed for relaxation and enjoyment of the serene surroundings.

Home in Key Colony Beach

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 112 reviews

Captain’s Quarters Ahoy Mateys! Florida, Keys

This is located at the Florida Keys in Key Colony, Marathon. It is a spacious two bedroom, two bathroom duplex surrounded by water. It is a renovated beauty and close to the best restaurants and the tranquility of this city. It is the perfect getaway where you can recharge your exhausted batteries. Captain’s Quarters is a clean and spacious base camp location for the many adventures that await you in this amazing location. Water views and the accessibility to the best fishing in the world.

Guest favorite

A spacious bedroom features a king bed with light bedding and decorative throw pillows. Large windows offer unobstructed ocean views and allow natural light to fill the room. A comfortable seating area is positioned nearby, facing the beach and tiki huts.

Condo in Key Colony Beach

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 193 reviews

Exquisite Oceanfront Paradise - Key Colony Beach

Exquisite renovation just completed (Nov 2024). Unobstructed ocean views from our beachfront condo in Key Colony Beach. Ground floor and just a few steps away from our private beach and heated pool. Location just does not get any better. Stunning, clean white interior - kitchen stocked with everything (dishes, cookware, utensils, glassware, stove, oven, toaster, microwave, blender, fridge, etc). Guests can enjoy the quiet private beach with lounge chairs, patio tables, tiki's and BBQ grills.

Top guest favorite

A wooden dock extends over calm waters, flanked by posts leading to a serene view of the sky at sunset. Lush palm trees are visible in the background, enhancing the tranquil atmosphere of the canal.

Guest suite in Key Colony Beach

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 115 reviews

Turtle-By-The-Sea: the Best Deal in KCB!

A perfect get-away for couples or budget travelers, Turtle-by-the-Sea is the best priced vacation rental or hotel room in the middle-keys. Together with its prime location and amenities there simply isn’t a better deal to be had! Bursting with Keys charm, this cozy retreat is the perfect place to relax & escape. Owners Mallory & Steve infused their love of the Keys & its surrounding ocean into every aspect of their waterside home. Shoot us a message & start planning your dream Keyscation!

Guest favorite

Palm trees are seen swaying gently in the breeze, framing the entrance to the cottage, which features a welcoming front porch with two wooden chairs. The interior showcases a modern dining area, complete with a chandelier and decorative plants. A plunge pool is visible in the outdoor space, surrounded by tropical greenery.

Home in Marathon

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 100 reviews

Florida Keys Cottage with Pool - Hawks Cay Resort

Welcome to our tropical Conch Cottage, a lovely place to create memories on your idyllic Florida Keys vacation in paradise. Our stylish waterfront villa sits alongside a clear turquoise canal on picturesque Duck Key, inside the Hawk's Cay resort, and just 10 minutes from busy Marathon. Get involved in on-site activities like snorkeling, scuba diving, fishing, boating and dolphin encounters—or simply lay out on the coral stone patio, soak up the sun, and slide into your private plunge pool.

Guest favorite

An outdoor seating area features a sectional sofa and high-top bar stools with a view of the water. A peaceful ambiance is created by the surrounding palm trees and the gentle waves of Vaca Cut. Laundry facilities are visible on the left side of the image.

Home in Marathon

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 42 reviews

Florida Keys Oceanside Utopia

Create amazing memories at this beautiful oceanside home in Marathon, FL. Relax in the backyard or outdoor bar, watching boats cruise by on the aqua waters of Vaca Cut. Enjoy a fully equipped, newly remodeled and furnished duplex, beautifully decorated and ready to be your home away from home. Our waterfront location can’t be beat. Marathon has everything you need for a vacation to do it all on one Key. We can’t wait for you to experience our vacation home. Must be 25+ years old to book.

Superhost

A cozy sleeping area features a spacious bed with crisp white linens, positioned against a dark feature wall. Natural light streams in through a large window, complemented by greenery from a nearby potted plant. A small side table holds decorative items.

Boat in Marathon

4.8 out of 5 average rating, 285 reviews

Paradise awaits on this cozy houseboat!

Our vision is for you to kick back, relax, and find your home away from home! Wether you want to celebrate with your loved one or retreat by yourself this floating home offers comfortable space for 2 adults. Located near the 7 mile bridge in Marathon Florida on the Atlantic Ocean nestled in a quiet, reserved mangrove area. This spot is fantastic because you have unparalleled access to out of this world sunset/sunrise views. Kayak through the mangrove and explore the surrounding areas.

Guest favorite

Three modern Aqua Lodges are positioned on water, featuring white exteriors and blue roofs. Each lodge has a furnished deck with chairs, providing relaxed seating options. A smooth, concrete path runs alongside the lodges, leading to a marina setting with sailboats in the background.

Villa in Marathon

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 360 reviews

New Aqua Lodge 2Beds 1 Bath with Full Kitchens

This hip spot is the new thing in lodging. Aqua Lodge is all the modern amenities while being on the water. Full kitchens, flat screen tv's, wi-fi , pool, bikes, sunset beach. We have it all right at your finger tips. You can sleep up to 5 people comfortably. We have great air conditioning and big showers. The deck is furnished with a dining table for those romantic outdoor dinners in the moonlight. We also have a sunset beach area for the best sunsets in the Florida keys!

Guest favorite

A cozy living space features a navy blue sofa adorned with nautical-themed throw pillows. A dining area with a glass table and chairs is visible in the background, alongside a decorative display of framed art and a potted plant. Natural light filters through the windows.

Houseboat in Marathon

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 123 reviews

Houseboat Getaway In Marathon

Get ready to indulge in a relaxing and unforgettable experience at the first overwater houseboat getaway in Marathon, Florida! 🌴🌊 What awaits you is - fun filled days living and exploring out on the fabulous florida keys waters in your own private aqualodge, breathtaking sunsets, and a private sanctuary perched above the sea. 😍 Don't miss out on this one-of-a-kind experience! Book your stay now and create memories that will last a lifetime.

Guest favorite

A modern interior showcases a spacious living area with a sectional sofa adorned with decorative cushions. Adjacent, a bright kitchen is visible, alongside a dining table. A cozy bedroom features a bed with plush linens. Outdoor seating is arranged on a covered patio, surrounded by greenery.

Home in Marathon

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 168 reviews

Waterfront Cozy Modern Retreat w/Deep Canal

Welcome to our beautiful waterfront home in Marathon! Our smoke-free property is modern, clean and features a 37ft long concrete dock, perfect for boating and fishing enthusiasts. With easy access to the movie theater, Sombrero Beach, Turtle Hospital, Publix, Walgreens, and delicious restaurants, you'll have everything you need right at your fingertips. We can't wait for you to experience the peacefulness and convenience of our lovely home.

Guest favorite

The image showcases a vibrant living space within the Dapper Dolphin condo, featuring a stylish kitchen with granite countertops, a cozy dining area, and a comfortable bedroom with a king-sized bed. The outdoor area displays a large pool surrounded by lounge chairs, highlighting the resort's inviting atmosphere.

Condo in Marathon

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 100 reviews

Keys Fall Escape: Pool, Marina & Tiki Bar

Celebrate the season in paradise at THE DAPPER DOLPHIN, an updated coastal-themed 1-bedroom, 1-bathroom condo, accommodating up to 4 guests. Featuring a complete kitchen, balcony, and access to resort amenities including a pool, Tiki Bar, restaurant, Marina, and more! Situated in the heart of Marathon, it offers proximity to the beach, restaurants, activities, and all the essentials for an unforgettable vacation experience right on-site!

Guest favorite

Home in Marathon

5 out of 5 average rating, 10 reviews

Captain's Retreat: Disneyland for Boaters

Welcome aboard Captain's Retreat, your 6BR/5BA tropical paradise in Marathon with 80 feet of dockage for up to 3 boats! I expanded from our popular Captain's Quarters to create this ultimate family compound with fast ocean access. Cruise the Atlantic on our premium Hobie kayaks, challenge family to shuffleboard by the heated pool, or rack 'em up in the billiards room – there's something for every generation in your crew!