Vacation rentals in Pickaway County

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Pickaway County

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Top guest favorite

A cozy family room is centered around a leather sectional sofa, with ample seating for guests. A large TV is mounted on the wall across from the seating area, beside a classic decorative fireplace. Soft lighting is provided by table lamps, enhancing the inviting atmosphere.

Apartment in Circleville

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 117 reviews

The Happy Place, in historic uptown Circleville

Housed in the 1859 Jones Building, the Happy Place keeps the integrity of the original space with meaningful updates. High ceilings, original decorative fireplaces, newly refinished original hardwood floors and a billiards room. Located in historic uptown Circleville, just steps away from dining, the Ted Lewis Museum, Wittich's Candy Shop - the nation's oldest family owned and operated confectionary. 30 minutes to downtown Columbus and 30 minutes to the Hocking Hills and Deer Creek State Pk

Superhost

The living room features elegant furnishings, including a tan sofa and two brown armchairs. A glass coffee table is placed on a textured area rug, and a decorative fireplace is visible. Natural light filters through large windows adorned with sheer curtains.

Townhouse in Circleville

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 81 reviews

Charming Historic District 3-Bedroom Apartment

Bring the whole family to this Historic Home with lots of room to relax. This Federal Style home was built in 1835 and has three bedrooms, two baths, kitchen, dining room and living room. Features include hardwood floors, 12' ceilings and modern decor. Enjoy all that Circleville has to offer: within walking distance to Lindsey's Bakery, Wittich's Candy Shop, local restaurants & shopping. The dining room offers seating for everyone and the kitchen has everything you need for the family.

Superhost

An indoor game area is presented, featuring several tables, including a foosball table and an air hockey table. The space is illuminated by overhead lights, with a rustic wooden decor in the background. Comfortable seating is available along the walls.

Cabin in Circleville

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 125 reviews

Private Fun Barn~Hot Tub~Pool Table~Karaoke

Fun Barn NEW for 2025!!! Take a step of serenity into our Norwegian inspired Hocking Hills Lodge. Luxuriously designed and perfect for large families, friends, wedding parties, and even corporate retreats. Enjoy a campfire under the stars, relax in the oversized hot tub, or embrace your competitive side in the Fun Barn! Locally owned and available 24/7. Hocking Hills Hikes: Rockhouse: 14mi Cantwell Cliffs: 19mi Conkle's Hollow: 19mi Old Man's Cave: 22mi Support small businesses, Book Now!

Superhost

A spacious living area features two comfortable sofas positioned around a stone fireplace. Natural light fills the room through sliding glass doors, while a mounted TV is visible beside a modern console. Decorative plants and a round mirror add visual interest to the space.

Home in Amanda

4.67 out of 5 average rating, 18 reviews

Moccasin Creek Cottage

Come enjoy a stay at our little cottage. It is tucked up close to the woods, with a lovely secluded backyard. We have a tv - amazon fire tv, you have to have your own subscriptions. We have WIFI, out door sitting area, and a grill. We are 7 miles from rock house. We are 2.5 miles from Tarlton, Ohio which has a IGA convenient store, Dollar General, and Crosstown diner. We are 5 miles from Laurellville with gas, grocery store and restaurants, and the famous Apple Cider House open in the fall.

Guest favorite

The front exterior of the cottage is seen, featuring a light-colored facade and large windows. A grassy lawn is surrounded by shrubs and trees, providing shade. A gravel path leads to the entrance, enhancing the welcoming appearance of the property.

Apartment in Circleville

5 out of 5 average rating, 5 reviews

Roundtown Blue Cottage

Discover your perfect short-term rental on a tranquil street located on the north side of "The Roundtown" This updated 2-bedroom, 1-bath combines comfort with convenience. Within walking distance of the hospital, perfect for traveling hospital staff. Enjoy a spacious living area, a fully equipped kitchen, and work space, makes it great for families, friends, or business travelers. Just minutes from shops, and dining, this peaceful retreat offers everything you need for a relaxing stay.

Guest favorite

The living area features wooden walls and high ceilings, creating a warm atmosphere. Two couches and an oversized chair face a gas fireplace, while a 55" smart TV is mounted nearby. Additional seating is offered by a wooden dining table accompanied by soft green blankets.

Cabin in Laurelville

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 146 reviews

Cozy Creekside Cabin in the heart of Hocking Hills

Enjoy the best of both worlds! Our lovingly restored cabin is 15 miles from all of Hocking Hills' beautiful attractions on 2 creekside acres, with spacious porches, yard, fire pit, & newly installed hot tub and deck! Just at the outskirts of Laurelville-- half a mile from gas, groceries, diners, parks, & Laurelville Fruit Co. Enjoy the cozy living space, 55" smart TV, puzzles, games, & books. Full kitchen and 4 person dining table for making meals & memories together. 00726

Top guest favorite

An aerial view of a renovated farmhouse features dark siding and a distinctive wooden entryway. Surrounding the home, a spacious green lawn extends, with neatly trimmed grass and landscaped areas. Pathways lead to the entrance, providing an inviting approach to the property.

Home in Orient

5 out of 5 average rating, 35 reviews

Welcome To Twin Run Farm!

***Private events/parties-pricing is different, please inquire directly. Our home is an 1800's farmhouse that has been completely renovated! Sitting on 5 1/2 acres, TRF has a large private outdoor space, firepits, 3 bedrooms sleeping 10 guests, and has everything a hotel stay could offer and more! And the best part? We are dog friendly! We do have a 2 dog minimum. TRF is located in Commercial Point, Ohio-just south of Grove City and 15 miles from downtown Columbus.

Guest favorite

A welcoming living area features a brown sectional sofa arranged around a small circular table. Two tall windows allow natural light to illuminate the space, with blue curtains providing a soft contrast. A decorative pillow with the word 'ENJOY' is placed on an accent chair.

Apartment in Asheville

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 50 reviews

Suite at Lisa's Sweet Shoppe

Bring the whole family to this great place with lots of room to enjoy being together. The Suite is a spacious, well-designed apartment that was completely remodeled in 2023, which boasts all new furniture and amenities. It is housed in 100+ year old brick building, that is a unique upstairs apartment overlooking the historic business district of a small town village. The Suite also allows you the charm to stay above Lisa's Sweet Shoppe, a bakery/coffee shop.

Guest favorite

The exterior of a spacious two-story farmhouse is framed by lush green grass and a large tree, allowing sunlight to filter through the branches. A porch is visible, along with a country setting that provides a sense of tranquility.

Farm stay in Circleville

5 out of 5 average rating, 15 reviews

Scippo Creek Farm

Come enjoy a relaxing weekend on the farm. Unique and peaceful country setting that is pet friendly and perfect for big family’s. We also have a full coffee bar. If you would like to have the animal contact/experience please go to Scippo Creek Farm Stay and book your stay, the price difference includes time with the animals to soak up some love, learn about the animals and how they interact with each other and us. You can also feed and gather eggs, ect..

Guest favorite

A new hot tub is pictured in an outdoor area, surrounded by wooden decking and string lights that create a cozy ambiance. A scenic view of the natural landscape and colorful dusk sky adds to the tranquil setting, enhancing outdoor relaxation.

Cabin in Laurelville

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 194 reviews

Hot-Tub, Grill, Sunset Views, Firepit, Turntable

➤ Rustic Cabin: Secluded yet near the enchanting beauty of Hocking Hills. ➤ Sleeps 2 | 1 Loft Bedroom | 1 Bath ➤ Indoors: Fireplace, WiFi & Smart TV, Vinyl Record Player, Swing, Fully Equipped Kitchen ➤ Outdoor amenities: Hot tub, Charcoal Grill, Fire-pit, Swings, String lights, and Rocking chairs with sunset views. ➤ Located just 1-2 miles from convenience stores, grocery stores, and restaurants in Laurelville. ➤ Discounts on 3+ nights & Early Bird

Superhost

A spacious living room features a large brown sectional sofa arranged around a patterned area rug. A glass dining table sits nearby alongside upholstered chairs. Soft lighting enhances the open atmosphere, while a doorway leads to other areas of the home.

Guesthouse in Circleville

4.68 out of 5 average rating, 25 reviews

The Carriage House

The carriage house to a grand Victorian Mansion has been updated from stalls and lofts to a full one bedroom (two full pillowtop beds) one bathroom with large living room and kitchen on second floor....first floor available with notice for small gatherings for additional...Someday, the whole mansion will be available for weddings and events! This quaint town, mainstreet and exact home were once home to a Vaudeville star 100 years ago...

Guest favorite

A spacious house is set against a backdrop of greenery, with a well-maintained lawn and large trees providing shade. The exterior features a light green siding and a welcoming front porch. A paved driveway leads to an attached garage.

Home in Tarlton

5 out of 5 average rating, 33 reviews

The Main House @ Tarlton’s Edge

The Main House is the perfect place for your family to enjoy a relaxing getaway! Easy access to Hocking Hills State Park hiking trails, Circleville 15mins, Lancaster & Chillicothe under 30mins. Watch a family movie in the great room, play a game of air hockey in the basement, or simply relax with a good book next to the gas fireplace. Whatever the reason, we are sure you will love your stay at the Main House!