Vacation rentals with a pool in Otsego County

Beautiful Farmhouse w/ Heated Pool, Game Room

Welcome to Cooperstown Star! Cooperstown Star is a beautifully re-modeled farmhouse set in the rolling hills of Cooperstown, just 3 miles from Cooperstown Dreams Park and less than 4 miles from downtown Cooperstown, Lake Otsego, and the Baseball Hall of Fame! Relax by the pool, play some games, grill some dinner and watch the fireworks right from your backyard. You will have an amazing time at Cooperstown Star. Don't miss out! * The heated pool is available Memorial Day through Labor Day

Mtn View Lux Dome w/ Heated Plunge Pool

This luxury dome is a modern home perched on a mountain top. Our aim is to combine the comforts of a large hotel suite with all the healing qualities of nature. Venture out or hike our own trails leading to a pond and a stream in the woods. Suited for long term WFH stays! We have Fiberoptic internet (ethernet avail) and plenty of space for your setup. Stroll the property at lunch or jump in the heated plunge pool between calls. Ask me about a special offer for long term stays. (14 days +)

Catskills Barn Apt with MTN views on 34 acres

Before booking * READ * the ENTIRE listing especially the “GUEST ACCESS and HOUSE RULES for all info on the Property and Hot Tub (access is shared). December - March an AWD or 4x4 Vehicle is HIGHLY RECOMMENDED Please read the “Other things to note” section. The Monroe House Barn Apt is tucked away between our Main House and Guest Cabin on our picturesque 34 acre estate. Guests have *shared access* to our Hot Tub with stunning views of the mountains. Absolutely NO PETS or SMOKING

All-Star Retreat w/ Hot Tub, Arcade, 2 Game Rooms

Baseball fans seeking a taste of home run history will love our ideally located big-league themed home perfect for making memories with friends and family. The Cooperstown Dream House is a recently remodeled 3000+ sq ft home located <2 miles from Dreams Park and <4 Miles from the Baseball Hall of Fame / Downtown Cooperstown. With a hot tub, pool, 2 game rooms, home theater, outdoor patio w/ grill, fire pit and a kids bunk room w/ foosball and air hockey there is fun for the whole family!

Cozy Catskill Escape with sauna & pool

Experience the western Catskills in our mountain house. The three level home sits on a hill top, with stunning views from living spaces and two outdoor decks. Finish that book you’ve been reading in one of the curated nooks, gather family and friends around dining tables inside or out, swim in the pool (seasonal) or relax in the sauna or fireside. Explore charming towns 20–30 minutes away, a rustic diner just 5 minutes out, and tons of shopping 15 minutes down the road. Craving a reset?

Contemporary Cabin w/ Hot Tub, Lake & Fireplace

Ticking all the boxes, this beautiful cabin has everything you could want for your retreat from city life! Five acres of private forest encapsulates the perfect seasonal mood as you step from the great room onto the huge wrap-around deck. Relax and enjoy the property with its hot tub, fireplace, A/C, BBQ grill and poolside loungers. For the adventurous at heart, check out the community shared lake access (non fishing), rivers, hiking trails and ski stations right at your fingertips.

10 Min to Cooperstown All Star Village, Pool

Black Moose Lodge is the perfect, peaceful escape for the entire family just 10 minutes from Cooperstown All Star Village and Oneonta, NY. With 9 bedrooms and 6 bathrooms, up to 24 people can stay the night to recharge for the next day of baseball fun! On 15 peaceful acres, with a large backyard, above ground pool, and basketball court, there is space for the entire family, or multiple families! The house has 2 kitchens and 2 sets of washers and dryers for even more convenience!

Historic Tavern (w/ saltwater hot tub)

Copper top bar in your private tavern/kitchen. Sleeps 6 across 3 bedrooms (3 beds). 6-person salt water hot tub (available after 8/22/25), Picnic table, grill. 25-28min to Cooperstown Dreams Park and All Star Village, 20min to Oneonta and Cobleskill. This home was completed in the 1870s and is a jewel in the region (we’re bringing her back to life, but she’s still pretty awesome). The town pool is on the neighboring property, it’s very convenient.

Log Cabin in the Country

Outdoor space with unheated pool. All of all 3 upstairs bedrooms ( 1 queen bed, 1 with a bunk + 1 double bed, and 1 loft room with queen), 2 full baths one with washer and dryer, kitchen & living room spaces. You are the only reservation in the home. Lots of hiking and quiet space, yet close to the village (10 min.) and the city of Oneonta (30 min.) or Cooperstown (45-60min). Play or rest.

The Lodge At Fall Park With Heated Indoor Pool!

Escape to The Lodge at Fall Park, a rustic-luxury lodge on 80 private acres in Otego, NY. Enjoy a year-round heated indoor pool, private pond, fire pit, and hiking trails. With 4 bedrooms, 2 baths, and cozy wood-burning fireplace, it’s the perfect retreat—just minutes from Cooperstown All Star Village and Oneonta.

Cooperstown Baseball Rentals - Elm-Double Play #1

Elm Double & Triple Play Apts are part of spacious home that offers 5 different private units. Double Play #1 is a ground floor unit that features 2 bedrooms and 1 bathroom, just 3.2 miles to Cooperstown All-Star Village. New for 2023! Central Air Conditioning has been installed in Elm Double Play #1.

Woodview Retreat #2

This centrally-located two bedroom, two bathroom apartment is on the lower level of a duplex. This much-loved rental is now being listed by the property’s owner. Each unit in the duplex has its own firepit, grill, and access to the large shared pool. See photos for past reviews and ratings!