Vacation rentals in Fishers Island

“Shannan maintains a very clean and comfortable space for both travelers with and without kids. We visited without kids but wouldn’t hesitate to return with our children. She is very helpful, made great recommendations for local activities and restaurants and communicated clearly and always responded quickly to questions. Her personal touches were perfect. We loved that she made sure there were snacks available, as well as coffee, tea and got chocolate. The fridge was stocked with milk and cream for coffee as well. She even delivered freshly baked muffins to our kitchen. Amazing experience all around!”

“Bill was a great host and this Airbnb is one of my favorite stays! The beach is just down the street and with it being private access only, we practically had it to ourselves. The apartment itself was the quintessential beach vibe. So cute and the private porch is a great way to end the day with a glass of wine. Bed was comfy, shower was amazing. The town is friendly and beautiful and I would love to return someday!”

“I hesitate to strongly suggest June’s bungalow to anyone else because I want to selfishly keep it available for myself. But I am an honest person, so here goes: we had one of the best Airbnb experiences at the bungalow. June’s outstanding warmth and hospitality shows through all of her thoughtful touches throughout the house and through her open communication and willingness to accommodate anything her guests may need. At the bungalow, you will find everything that you need for a tranquil getaway - a screened in porch (our favorite), a beautiful water-view, sunsets, boating (although we used our floatie instead), AC, and a full kitchen where we cooked all of our food. Everything was sparkling clean and she provides everything you can ever need. And most importantly, our dogs were very happy there too. If you’re lucky like we were, you may even catch a glimpse of a beaver swimming around at night. We can’t wait to return.”