Guidebook for Sag Harbor
Favorite Places to Eat
Excellent pizza, cold Rose, and child friendly. Sidewalk dining in the warmer weather. Right on Main Street in Sag Harbor.
59 locals recommend
Sag Pizza
103 Main StExcellent pizza, cold Rose, and child friendly. Sidewalk dining in the warmer weather. Right on Main Street in Sag Harbor.
Great for grab-n-go breakfast, lunch or dinner. Homemade Pies are not to be missed! The Kitchen Sink cookie is a local favorite. Also have every day pantry items to throw together a quick meal or snack.
39 locals recommend
Harbor Market & Kitchen
184 Division StGreat for grab-n-go breakfast, lunch or dinner. Homemade Pies are not to be missed! The Kitchen Sink cookie is a local favorite. Also have every day pantry items to throw together a quick meal or snack.
A historic classic. Food is always consistent. Covered sidewalk dining. Cold Lobster Salad is a must here! Service and decor is very old-school.
124 locals recommend
American Hotel
45 Main StA historic classic. Food is always consistent. Covered sidewalk dining. Cold Lobster Salad is a must here! Service and decor is very old-school.
One of the only waterfront restaurants in Sag Harbor. Food is excellent- seafood forward but other options as well. Always call ahead for reservations as it is not a very big restaurant.
10 locals recommend
Beacon
8 West Water StreetOne of the only waterfront restaurants in Sag Harbor. Food is excellent- seafood forward but other options as well. Always call ahead for reservations as it is not a very big restaurant.
If you are in the mood for noodles or Sushi come here! Right on Main Street. Their sister restaurant, K Pasa (Mexican) is also excellent.
81 locals recommend
Sen
23 Main StIf you are in the mood for noodles or Sushi come here! Right on Main Street. Their sister restaurant, K Pasa (Mexican) is also excellent.
Go-to local organic grocer and breakfast/lunch cafe. Miso Avocado Toast, Green Juice, and Turkey Taco Salad are some of our favorites. Also have pantry items and toiletries. Call in your order ahead to save time- they are ALWAYS very busy.
46 locals recommend
Provisions
7 Main StGo-to local organic grocer and breakfast/lunch cafe. Miso Avocado Toast, Green Juice, and Turkey Taco Salad are some of our favorites. Also have pantry items and toiletries. Call in your order ahead to save time- they are ALWAYS very busy.
A MUST see. If you do not feel like cooking come here for everything pre-made- from Breakfast, Lunch and dinner. Everything is prepared fresh daily and just grab and go. Muffins, cookies, salads, pastas, roast meats, cheese, desserts. You name it- they probably have it! This is a real indulgence market.
30 locals recommend
Round Swamp Farm
71 S Elmwood AveA MUST see. If you do not feel like cooking come here for everything pre-made- from Breakfast, Lunch and dinner. Everything is prepared fresh daily and just grab and go. Muffins, cookies, salads, pastas, roast meats, cheese, desserts. You name it- they probably have it! This is a real indulgence market.
Lulu Kitchen & Bar
126 Main StGreat bistro style food. Right on Main Street.
Sightseeing
You must come here with the kids or if you do not like the big waves/currents at the Ocean beaches. Very sandy bottom, no currents or seaweed to deal with. Lifeguards, bathrooms, plenty of parking ($40 a day) and a friendly Ice-Cream truck.
43 locals recommend
Foster Memorial Beach
1000 Noyack-Long Beach RdYou must come here with the kids or if you do not like the big waves/currents at the Ocean beaches. Very sandy bottom, no currents or seaweed to deal with. Lifeguards, bathrooms, plenty of parking ($40 a day) and a friendly Ice-Cream truck.
Closest Ocean Beach to the house. Mid-week pay to park only for non-residents. You must be a resident to park here Fri/Sat/Sunday. Stunning ocean beach with bathrooms, lifeguard, and Ice-cream Truck.
79 locals recommend
Sagg Main Beach
1200 Sagg Main StClosest Ocean Beach to the house. Mid-week pay to park only for non-residents. You must be a resident to park here Fri/Sat/Sunday. Stunning ocean beach with bathrooms, lifeguard, and Ice-cream Truck.
Main Street
Main StreetFull of locally owned shops, art galleries, and restaurants.
Arts/Theater
Great place to come for an intimate night of theater or comedy.
75 locals recommend
Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts
1 Bay StGreat place to come for an intimate night of theater or comedy.
Historic. Recently re-modeled. Indie films and hard to find classic film showings.
41 locals recommend
Sag Harbor Cinema
90 Main StHistoric. Recently re-modeled. Indie films and hard to find classic film showings.
City/town information
Come here for more shopping, art/antique galleries, and two of our favorite restaurants: Pierre's and Almond Restaurant. LW Market is a great stop for gourmet salads, breakfast items, and pantry items. Their overnight berry and oats is delicious!
30 locals recommend
Bridgehampton
Come here for more shopping, art/antique galleries, and two of our favorite restaurants: Pierre's and Almond Restaurant. LW Market is a great stop for gourmet salads, breakfast items, and pantry items. Their overnight berry and oats is delicious!
Distillery
Recently opened Vodka Distillery with vodka made from local potatoes. Recently renovated barn with tasting room that has both indoor and outside patio area. Great choices for different flavored vodka's sent home in an actual potato sack bag!
Sagaponack Farm Distillery, LLC
369 Sagg RdRecently opened Vodka Distillery with vodka made from local potatoes. Recently renovated barn with tasting room that has both indoor and outside patio area. Great choices for different flavored vodka's sent home in an actual potato sack bag!
Traveler advice
Don't miss
The Saturday farmer’s market is a must
The SHFM runs every Saturday, 9am - 1pm, at the corner of Bay and Burke on the Sag Harbor waterfront. Local fruit and vegetables, seafood, eggs, mushrooms, bread and baked goods, jam, flowers and more.
Open May-October.
Don't miss
Channing Daughter's Vineyard.
While most people flock to Wolffer Vineyard, I recommend the more low-key Channing Daughter's Vineyard for a tasting. Its not as crowded and the wines are better! Try one of their the Orange Wines...