Restaurants & Recommendations

Holly
Restaurants & Recommendations

Food scene

Enjoy locally sourced all day breakfast and lunch - pancakes are a must try! Property includes “animal zoo” (peacocks, turkeys, pigs, sheep, goats, and turkeys in the barn behind the restaurant), garden center, and store selling local: crafts, honey, fudge, baked goods, as well as numerous other gifts / home goods.
105 locals recommend
Catskill Mountain Country Store - Windham
5510 NY-23
105 locals recommend
Enjoy locally sourced all day breakfast and lunch - pancakes are a must try! Property includes “animal zoo” (peacocks, turkeys, pigs, sheep, goats, and turkeys in the barn behind the restaurant), garden center, and store selling local: crafts, honey, fudge, baked goods, as well as numerous other gifts / home goods.
American food in a modern setting, enjoy the ambiance here with multiple fireplaces, wrap around windows, and upscale food. Make a reservation - you won’t regret it!
17 locals recommend
Union and Post - Windham, N.Y.
5098 New York 23
17 locals recommend
American food in a modern setting, enjoy the ambiance here with multiple fireplaces, wrap around windows, and upscale food. Make a reservation - you won’t regret it!
Incredible steak, incredible fish, everything here is delicious. Open late (a rarity in Windham) - they don’t take reservations, but its worth the wait (if there is one).
18 locals recommend
Lilly's Steaks & Cocktails
5335 New York 23
18 locals recommend
Incredible steak, incredible fish, everything here is delicious. Open late (a rarity in Windham) - they don’t take reservations, but its worth the wait (if there is one).
Come for the babyback ribs, stay for the craft beer. Fun restaurant / bar, menu has a lot of variety, and everything we have tried has been great.
72 locals recommend
Tap House Grille
5359 NY-23
72 locals recommend
Come for the babyback ribs, stay for the craft beer. Fun restaurant / bar, menu has a lot of variety, and everything we have tried has been great.
40 wines available by the glass perfectly paired with cheese + charcuterie (We love their outdoor secret garden behind the restaurant with fire es, cozy couches, and a fun European vibe)
117 locals recommend
Ze Windham Wine Bar
5369 Main Street
117 locals recommend
40 wines available by the glass perfectly paired with cheese + charcuterie (We love their outdoor secret garden behind the restaurant with fire es, cozy couches, and a fun European vibe)

Traveler advice

Book before you go

Windham Mountain Skyride

Scenic 2 mile chairlift ride to the summit of Windham Mountain (Tickets are $20/adult, closed on Tuesdays + Wednesdays, should book ahead of time to ensure availability!)