Guidebook for Sag Harbor
Food Scene
The best ice cream in Sag Harbor, open late at night over the summer, and lines move quickly. So many flavors and each one is better than the next!
18 locals recommend
Big Olaf's Ice Cream
The best ice cream in Sag Harbor, open late at night over the summer, and lines move quickly. So many flavors and each one is better than the next!
Sen
23 Main StGreat asian American food, sushi and people watching
The BEST cheese shop around. Plus they also have a gourmet deli next door. Awesome prepared foods!
17 locals recommend
Cavaniola Gourmet Cheese
89 Division StThe BEST cheese shop around. Plus they also have a gourmet deli next door. Awesome prepared foods!
Great for a quick, reliable meal. Especially when you are tired of the high price, uber sophisticated options. Think Hamptons version of a diner.
25 locals recommend
John Papas Cafe
18 Park PlGreat for a quick, reliable meal. Especially when you are tired of the high price, uber sophisticated options. Think Hamptons version of a diner.
Yummylicious!
2 Main StGreat local frozen yogurt spot!
The BEST cookies on earth. Period. Dare you to try one and not be hooked. Go NOW!!
21 locals recommend
Levain Bakery - Wainscott
354 Montauk HwyThe BEST cookies on earth. Period. Dare you to try one and not be hooked. Go NOW!!
Iconic seafood restaurant in Amagansett. Great warm and cold lobster rolls, clam and seafood bisque
91 locals recommend
Lobster Roll aka LUNCH
1980 Montauk HighwayIconic seafood restaurant in Amagansett. Great warm and cold lobster rolls, clam and seafood bisque
Very casual, on the water always good local spot. Awesome onion rings, steamers, bisque
Rick's Crabby Cowboy Cafe
435 E Lake DrVery casual, on the water always good local spot. Awesome onion rings, steamers, bisque
The Dock House
1 Long WharfGreat local seafood spot. Outstanding Lobster Roll and Bisque.
Essentials
Local grocery store that's conveniently located in town. While it's a smaller store, it should have most of the things you need, and it's nice and close.
42 locals recommend
Schiavoni's Market Inc.
48 Main StLocal grocery store that's conveniently located in town. While it's a smaller store, it should have most of the things you need, and it's nice and close.